A Obstacles to Access | 12 / 25 |
B Limits on Content | 12 / 35 |
C Violations of User Rights | 10 / 40 |
Internet freedom in Kazakhstan continues to face severe restrictions. Unlike during the previous coverage period, the government did not shut down the internet nationwide in response to protests; instead, it throttled internet access locally during protests and rallies. The government routinely blocks websites and orders the removal of content. Online journalists and individuals critical of the government continue to face legal repercussions, and this coverage period also witnessed an increase in physical attacks against online journalists and media outlets ahead of snap presidential and parliamentary elections. News outlets and government institutions experienced significant cyberattacks during the coverage period.
Several national elections were held during the coverage period. Changes to 33 articles of the constitution were approved by referendum in June 2022, and included removing the law giving former president Nursultan Nazarbaev special status. Incumbent president Qasym-Jomart Toqaev was reelected in November 2022, taking 81.3 percent of the vote according to government sources; Toqaev’s authoritarian regime was further entrenched following snap parliamentary elections held in March 2023, which saw Kazakhstan’s ruling party, Amanat, retain its majority in the legislature. None of the polls held during the coverage period were considered to be either free or fair by independent observers.
Former president Nazarbaev ruled Kazakhstan from 1990 to 2019, when he stepped down. Nazarbaev initially maintained significant influence over governance, which waned after the January 2022 protests and riots. In February 2023, President Toqaev invalidated the legal instruments that provided numerous privileges to Nazarbaev and his family members. Parliamentary and presidential elections are neither free nor fair, and major parties exhibit continued political loyalty to the government. The authorities have consistently marginalized or imprisoned genuine opposition figures. The dominant media outlets are either in state hands or owned by government-friendly businessmen. Freedoms of speech and assembly remain restricted, and corruption is endemic.
- The government throttled access to the internet during local protests throughout the coverage period, but it did not launch a nationwide internet shutdown as it did during protests in January 2022, during the last coverage period (see A3).
- Russian courts and regulators issued removal orders to Kazakhstani websites providing accurate coverage of Moscow’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine; in response, the Kazakhstani government said that the websites were outside of Russian jurisdiction and did not violate Kazakhstani laws (see B2).
- Online journalists were attacked and news outlets were vandalized ahead of both the November 2022 snap presidential elections and the March 2023 parliamentary elections (see C7).
- During the electoral period, news outlets, government websites, and the internet backbone suffered significant cyberattacks, which government officials claimed originated from outside the country (see C8).
Do infrastructural limitations restrict access to the internet or the speed and quality of internet connections? | 5 / 6 |
Internet access has increased significantly over the past decade. According to official data from the Ministry of Digital Development, Innovation, and Aerospace Industry (MDDIAI), 96.2 percent of households have internet access, including access to mobile broadband.1 In 2022, the International Telecommunications Unit (ITU) reported an internet penetration rate of 92.3 percent, a fixed broadband penetration rate of 15.4 percent, and a mobile broadband penetration rate of 94.5 percent.2
The government’s Digital Kazakhstan program met its goal of increasing the internet penetration rate to 82.3 percent by 2022.3 The country’s mobile networks continue to expand. According to official data, broadband mobile internet is available to 94 percent of the population as of April 2023,4 including fourth-generation (4G) networks. Several mobile service providers piloted fifth-generation (5G) services during the coverage period. In June 2022, the MDDIAI announced that 5G networks would be launched in Almaty and Astana that September, and Shymkent by the end of 2022, with networks launched in other “regional centers” between 2023 and 2025.5 As of February 2023, no operators offered 5G services.
According to May 2023 testing data from Ookla, the median download speed of a fixed-line broadband connection in Kazakhstan was 39.6 megabits per second (Mbps) and the median mobile broadband download speed was 22.1 Mbps.6
Most people access the internet from their mobile devices at home and at work. In cities, including Almaty,7 Astana, and Pavlodar,8 high-speed internet is available in public transport and open spaces.
Is access to the internet prohibitively expensive or beyond the reach of certain segments of the population for geographical, social, or other reasons? | 2 / 3 |
Both mobile and fixed-line internet connections remain relatively affordable, though operators have recently increased the costs of their postpaid plans or reduced their coverage.
The postpaid plans offered for fixed-line and, especially, mobile internet connections increased in cost during the coverage period. Operators either discontinued some of the attractive plans, reduced the data limits, or made them approximately 20 percent more expensive. In February 2023, Kazakhstan’s antimonopoly agency condemned the “ungrounded rise in the price of tariff plans” by mobile operators, which include new services that are not demanded by customers to justify the price increase.9 Still, all operators offer a range of affordable prepaid plans.
According to 2022 data from the ITU, 2 gigabytes (GB) of mobile data costs 0.83 percent of gross national income (GNI) per capita, while a 5 GB fixed-line broadband plan costs 0.62 percent of GNI per capita.10
Due to the sharp devaluation of the national currency in March 2022 and subsequent price spikes, the affordability of internet services relative to other costs of living decreased.11
Internet access is more limited in rural areas, where about 40 percent of the population resides as of 2022.12 As part of the Digital Kazakhstan program, the government pledged to eliminate the digital divide between urban and rural areas13 using 5G fixed wireless access (FWA).14 Mobile service providers have also shared network infrastructure to facilitate wider rural access,15 though provincial governors have still complained about the quality of access.16
Internet access is distributed relatively evenly across Kazakhstan’s ethnic communities.
There is no apparent gender-based internet access divide in Kazakhstan.17
Does the government exercise technical or legal control over internet infrastructure for the purposes of restricting connectivity? | 3 / 6 |
Score Change: The score improved from 1 to 3 because the government did not initiate a nationwide internet shutdown during protests as it did in January 2022.
During the coverage period, the government briefly throttled internet connections during local public protests and gatherings.
The government throttled internet connections locally at unsanctioned rallies in Almaty celebrating the nation’s Independence Day in December 2022, and on January 5, 2023, the one-year anniversary of the 2022 protests and ensuing violence.18 The government also throttled internet connections at protests in Almaty19 and Zhanaozen20 in April 2023. In previous years, the government has similarly disrupted the internet during protests and rallies.21 These disruptions usually do not last long and affect a narrow geographical area.
However, in January 2022, during the previous coverage period, the government disrupted nationwide internet access in response to protests, which were triggered by rising gas prices and were marred by violent responses from the authorities and armed groups in Almaty. Authorities throttled mobile internet services in West Kazakhstan Province on January 2, 2022, and initiated nationwide shutdowns beginning on January 4, when the government declared a state of emergency.22 Internet access was not fully restored across the country until January 11. During the internet shutdown, some users were able to access the internet through proxy servers (see C4).23
The government justified the January 2022 shutdown to stop alleged terrorism. Mobile service providers Kcell and Beeline explained “competent bodies” suspended communications as part of counterterrorist activities.24 Later media reports indicated that the government initially tried to use Russian deep packet inspection (DPI) technology to filter internet resources in a “more pointed” manner, but when this attempt failed, the authorities decided to block access totally.25
In November 2022, the MDDIAI announced the creation of a roster of internet resources with uninterrupted access during state of emergency situations. The roster is supposed to include vitally important state and private enterprises.26
Certain legal mechanisms allow the government to suspend telecommunications networks at will. According to a 2018 decree, the Ministry of Defense, the Ministry of Internal Affairs, the Prosecutor General’s Office, and the National Security Committee (NSC) have priority access to telecommunications networks as well as the right to suspend those networks in an emergency, or the risk thereof. The decree does not specify limits on the duration of network suspensions.
The NSC has controlled the State Technical Service (STS), which has centralized telecommunication networks and internet exchange points (IXPs), since 2017,27 assuming the authority to block content and disrupt internet networks for countercriminal purposes. In October 2020, the government reorganized the STS28 into a state-owned joint-stock company,29 which still has the legal authority to censor content and restrict connectivity.30 The NSC can act without a court order, though it must notify other state bodies within 24 hours.31 A 2016 law empowers the NSC to suspend “networks and means of communication and access to the internet” in “urgent cases that may result in commitment of grave or especially grave crimes.”
Since 2012, amendments to the Law on National Security have allowed the government to forcibly suspend telecommunications during antiterrorist or riot-suppression operations.32 In 2014, the Prosecutor General’s Office was authorized to issue orders to shut down communication services without a court order if “networks are used for felonious aims to damage interests of individuals, society or state,” including the dissemination of illegal information and calls for extremism, terrorism, mass riots, or participation in unauthorized public gatherings.33 Orders must be executed by either telecommunications companies or the STS within three hours.
The government centralizes internet infrastructure in a way that facilitates control of content and surveillance. State-owned Kazakhtelecom, through its operations and through subsidiaries, holds a de facto monopoly on the country’s backbone internet infrastructure. The state’s supervision of the STS allows the authorities to exercise control over peering centers and international gateways.34 Amendments enacted in 2017 made the management of cross-border IXPs a state monopoly in the name of “information security.”35 In February 2019, KazNIC, the nonprofit registry for the country’s .kz domain, announced the launch of an independent IXP, but it offers peering only of domestic, not international, traffic.36
In September 2022, Kazakhtelecom and Azertelecom, a telecommunications company based in Azerbaijan, “signed a strategic partnership memorandum,” to cooperate in installing fiber-optic cables in the Caspian Sea. The strategic memorandum is a component of the “Digital Silk Way” project, which aims to create “a digital telecommunications corridor between Europe and Asia.”37
Are there legal, regulatory, or economic obstacles that restrict the diversity of service providers? | 2 / 6 |
While the government does not intentionally keep new players out of the information communication technology (ICT) market, it is not actively seeking to make the market more diverse. Additionally, the state-facilitated merger of Kazakhtelecom with two major mobile service providers in 2019 has allowed the government to control a large share of the market.38 Kazakhtelecom’s only major competitor is the foreign-owned Kar-Tel (Beeline).39
There are several internet service providers (ISPs) in Kazakhstan, but Kazakhtelecom holds a dominant market position, controlling 75 percent of the fixed-line market and 78 percent of the mobile market.40 It fully or partially owns several other backbone and downstream ISPs. As of January 2023, the state owned 71.3 percent of Kazakhtelecom through Samruk-Kazyna, its sovereign wealth fund, and the Committee for State Property and Privatization under the Ministry of Finance.41 Skyline Investment Company, a Luxembourg-incorporated firm whose owner is former president Nazarbaev’s nephew Kairat Satybaldy,42 previously owned 24 percent of Kazakhtelecom;43 Satybaldy transferred his shares to the state44 in April 202245 after he was arrested on charges of embezzlement concerning Kazakhtelecom46 and “other crimes undermining the state security.”47
In October 2021, Kazakhtelecom sold 24 percent of mobile operator Kcell’s shares on the Kazakhstan Stock Exchange. They were acquired by Jusanbank, which owns mobile service provider KazTransCom.48 In April 2022, the government investigated whether Kazakhtelecom’s sale and privatization of ISP Transtelecom constituted a “violation of state interests.” In August 2021, 75 percent of Transtelecom was sold to Unit Telecom, a company run by Nazarbaev’s grandson Nurali Aliev.49 Additionally, in July 2023,50 after the coverage period, MDDIAI minister Bagdat Musin announced future plans to sell one of the Kazakhtelecom-owned mobile service providers, which include Kcell and Tele2, to private entities; Musin also proposed a similar plan in April 2022.51
All mobile service providers were given the right in 2016 to offer 4G services.52 Since mid-2018, the government and mobile service providers have been moving toward the introduction of 5G services; pilot tests have taken place in Shymkent,53 Almaty, and Astana.54
Companies providing telecommunications services require an operating license from the MDDIAI’s Telecommunications Committee under the Law on Permissions and Notifications.55 The Law on National Security limits foreign ownership of companies providing telecommunications services.56 Moreover, these companies are required to purchase and install equipment related to the state’s System for Operational Investigative Measures (SORM), a lawful interception apparatus (see C5), and to bear costs related to data-retention obligations (see C6). These companies are also required to cover costs related to the database of international mobile equipment identity (IMEI) codes (see C4)57 and to pay regular fees to the State Radio Frequency Service, the IMEI database operator. These obligations may deter new players from entering the ICT market.
Do national regulatory bodies that oversee service providers and digital technology fail to operate in a free, fair, and independent manner? | 0 / 4 |
The MDDIAI is responsible for the telecommunications sector (including ICT infrastructure), e-government, and cybersecurity. The Ministry of Information and Social Development (MISD) oversees mass media, including online content. Until the first half of 2019, both online content and the telecommunications sector were supervised by the now-defunct Ministry of Information and Communication (MIC).58 Ministers are nominated by the prime minister and appointed by the president. The ministries’ operations are not transparent or subject to independent oversight.
The NSC has increased its power to make decisions about ICT infrastructure and online content. In 2018, a cybersecurity entity called the National Coordination Center for Information Security was launched under the NSC’s supervision;59 its workings remain secret.60
The .kz country domain is managed by the nonprofit KazNIC registry. The Kazakhstan Association of IT Companies administers domain names and regulates KazNIC tariffs. A 2015 law granted the government the power to appoint both the registrar and the domain name administrator.61
Does the state block or filter, or compel service providers to block or filter, internet content, particularly material that is protected by international human rights standards? | 2 / 6 |
The government has extensive authority to block online content and can compel ISPs to restrict access to “unlawful materials.” If ISPs fail to block content in a timely manner, the STS restricts access directly and the ISPs may face fines.
In response to an access-to-information inquiry, the MISD specified that in 2022, 14,469 pages were blocked following 774 requests from the regulator. Only 241 of those were registered in the .kz domain zone. Between January and May 2023, 6,175 more pages were blocked, 6,047 of which were based abroad. The main reasons for blocking included dissemination of false information, use of the internet to commit criminal and administrative offenses, terrorist and extremist propaganda, and copyright violations, as well as hosting content related to pornography, suicide, narcotics, and online gambling. According to the MISD, there are over 68,000 banned web pages as of May 2023.62
In October and November 2022, around the time of the snap presidential elections, users reported issues accessing the websites of the BBC, several Russian media outlets,63 and Azattyq, the Kazakh service of Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty (RFE/RL).64 Users also reported experiencing intermittent problems accessing YouTube’s website and application in October 2022.65
In October 2022, the Talgar district court approved the prosecutor’s request to order the MISD to block the World Health Organization’s (WHO) website because a news item allegedly displayed “suicide propaganda.”66 It was later specified that the court ordered the blocking of one page on the WHO website, but the government did not have the technical capacity to restrict single pages on resources using Hypertext Transfer Protocol Secure (HTTPS), so it blocked the entire website.67 The ministry complied, but then asked the court to revise the decision, citing “reputational and other risks.” The Ministry of Health also intervened, and in January 2023 the WHO’s website was unblocked after the organization altered the disputed suicide-related newsletter.68
In January 2022, the authorities blocked access to independent news sites, including Orda.kz,69 prior to a total internet blackout and after it partially restored access to the internet (see A3). In late January 2022, news site Kokshetau Asia was blocked for several days following the prosecution of its chief editor Nurzhan Baimuldin, who was accused of provocative actions during the state of emergency for his critical posts on Facebook (see C3).70
In October 2021, HOLA News was blocked for 10 days after the website refused to remove information from the Pandora Papers that implicated members of former president Nazarbaev’s inner circle (see B2).71
Archive.org, petition website Change.org, and some foreign media outlets, including Kyrgyzstani news site Kloop and Russian-language news sites Fergana and Meduza, remained inaccessible during the coverage period.
Users who wish to circumvent censorship still use virtual private networks (VPNs), although most anonymizing tools are blocked (see C4).72 The authorities have confirmed that they can block VPNs using court decisions or orders from the MISD (see B3).73 In March 2023, hidemy.name, a Belize-based VPN service that was banned along with approximately 150 other VPNs in 2020, stated that it would appeal the ban in courts.74
Do state or nonstate actors employ legal, administrative, or other means to force publishers, content hosts, or digital platforms to delete content, particularly material that is protected by international human rights standards? | 1 / 4 |
The authorities use various nontechnical means to enforce the removal of content, including direct legal pressure on outlets to take down specific material and similar requests aimed at international social media platforms. There was a notable increase in cases of reported removal requests originating from the Russian government during the coverage period.
According to the MISD, in 2022 and the first five months of 2023, the regulator issued 4,116 removal requests, including 134 targeting websites based in Kazakhstan’s domain. The removal requests covered 93,014 pages, 692 of which were based in Kazakhstan,75 and 29,543 pages were taken down in response to the requests. The government has not disclosed more detailed statistics.
During the coverage period, Kazakhstani news outlets received several removal orders from Russian courts and regulators. In February 2023, a Russian court issued a subpoena to the Kazakhstani news site Arbat.media, accusing it of “discrediting the Russian army,” after sending an initial request in November 2022 ordering the website to remove an article written that September about Russia’s looming defeat in Kharkiv.76 Kazakhstan’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs stated that Kazakhstan is beyond the jurisdiction of Russian courts, and that Arbat.media did not violate any national laws.
In December 2022, Roskomnadzor, the Russian telecommunications and media regulator, demanded that news site Vlast.kz remove several articles about the Russian military invasion of Ukraine, including articles covering the killing of civilians in Mariupol, but the website declined the request.77 Informburo.kz, a news site, also received a removal demand in December, concerning an article containing updates about the war in Ukraine. The website reported that it had begun receiving removal requests from Roskomnadzor in 2020, and had restricted the content in Russia, but not to its audience in Kazakhstan.78
In August 2022, Ratel.kz also received a removal order from Roskomnadzor after publishing an article questioning how long Russian citizens would support the Russian government’s war in Ukraine. The outlet refused to remove the material in question.79
In April 2022, Roskomnadzor requested that Kazakhstani news site NewTimes.kz delete an article about sanctions against Russia, threatening to block it in Russia if it failed to comply. The request was sent to the hosting company, and the outlet decided to comply.80
Amid the January 2022 protests, at least two major news sites—KazTAG81 and Fergana82 —received takedown requests from the MISD regarding their protest-related coverage and were blocked after they refused to comply (see B1). That January, an Orda.kz reporter was also forced to delete photos taken at Republic Square in Almaty.83
According to Meta’s transparency report covering the first half of 2022, the company did not restrict any content based on requests from the Kazakhstani government.84 In the same period, Google received 64 removal requests from the authorities, targeting 23,805 items, but it did not take any actions based on the requests. Between July and December 2022, Google received 61 takedown requests from the government and courts, targeting 738 items. Google removed 8.3 percent of the requested items because they violated company policy and 0.9 percent based on legal demands. The requests in 2022 mostly concerned national security, fraud, defamation, and regulated goods and services.85 Twitter did not produce a report on content removal during the coverage period.
In 2016, the government adopted new rules for the monitoring of media, including social media, using the Automated System of Monitoring the National Information Space86 to uncover illegal content online (see C5). The authorities have continued to conduct manual monitoring since then.87 The system, which reportedly cost $4.5 million,88 became operational in 2020, according to the government’s response to an access-to-information request.
Do restrictions on the internet and digital content lack transparency, proportionality to the stated aims, or an independent appeals process? | 1 / 4 |
Extralegal blocking remains a common practice and website blocking and content-removal procedures lack transparency. In recent years, the government has developed several legal avenues to block websites and remove content.
According to the Mass Media Law,89 all internet resources, including websites and pages on social media platforms, are considered media outlets. Under 2014 amendments to the law, the Prosecutor General’s Office is authorized to order ISPs to block content without a court order. ISPs must comply with such requests until the website owner deletes the content in question. The law provides no leeway for an ISP to reject the order or for the website owner to appeal.90 The MISD has the authority to issue takedown and blocking orders until website owners remove specific content. The NSC also has the right to unilaterally suspend access to websites or information they host “in cases of emergency that may result in criminal actions,” and need only to notify the Prosecutor General’s Office and regulator afterward.
By equating all internet resources with media outlets, the Mass Media Law makes web publishers—including bloggers and social media users—liable for the content they post, but the law does not specify whether publishers are responsible for content posted by third parties. Social media users can be held liable for extremist comments posted on their pages by third parties, as permitting the publication of extremist materials in a mass media outlet is an offense under the criminal code that can be punished with up to 90 days in prison.
A new draft law on mass media has been in development since 2022. The government convened a working group that included journalists and media rights nongovernmental organizations (NGOs) to provide feedback on the law, but a draft released in February 2023 did not align with the suggestions of the working group and was condemned by many in the professional media community. The draft, produced by an interagency government commission, continues to define all online publishers as mass media, and includes an indefinite statute of limitations for cases concerning the protection of honor and dignity, which the working group suggested should be a one-year limitation. The draft also allows de facto censorship in “specific conditions,” an unclear designation that critics fear would be broadly applied.91 The draft law remained under consideration by the parliament at the end of the coverage period.
In May 2022, the government enacted the Law on Amendments and Additions to Some Legislative Acts of the Republic of Kazakhstan on the Protection of the Rights of the Child, Education, Information, and Informatization, also referred to as the Cyberbullying Law or the Law on Protection of Children’s Rights. The amendments compel websites, messaging applications, and social media platforms to delete illegal content related to cyberbullying in 24 hours, and grant the government the authority to “restrict the activity” of noncompliant platforms, including by blocking them.92 Under the amendments, platforms with at least 100,000 daily users are also required to appoint a special representative for direct communication with the MISD to promptly react to content-removal requests within 24 hours of such a request.93
In July 2022, new amendments to the governmental decree that regulates the MISD’s authority were adopted to bolster the MISD’s ability to enforce measures in the Cyberbullying Law. For example, the MISD is authorized to request the number of daily users of messaging apps and social media platforms in Kazakhstan. It is also authorized to restrict the work of these internet resources in cases of noncompliance.94
Under amendments made in September 2020, websites in the .kz and .ҚАЗ domain names can be suspended if they are physically hosted outside of Kazakhstan, do not have a safety certificate (see A3 and C6), or their software is hosted outside of Kazakhstan.95 In December 2020, the regulator said the amendments were needed to manage domestic data centers’ workload and to pursue “digital sovereignty.”96
Amendments to the Communications Law in 2016 obliged ISPs to monitor content passing through their networks and to decide whether to restrict any problematic material.97 The amendments do not specify how ISPs are to carry out this obligation. The administrative code, in force since 2016, imposes fines on ISPs for not complying with censorship orders.98
To avoid having a website or page permanently blocked and to escape legal liability, owners of internet resources must remove content that is deemed extremist or is otherwise banned. Once illegal content is identified, ISPs and the STS must suspend access to the entire website within three hours. The party responsible for the content then receives a request for its removal; if the party complies, ISPs and the STS must unblock the website.99
Websites can also be blocked by court order, even in the absence of the defendant’s representative. No notification—to the public or the website owner—about the reason for the blocking is required. The courts frequently issue orders to block websites, banning dozens at a time, mostly on the grounds of religious extremism. The appeals procedure is opaque. An individual must apply for judicial approval simply to view court rulings on blocking cases.100
In 2017, the regulator launched a pilot version of a blocked websites roster, which users could check to determine whether a website was blocked. Many blocked websites were not listed.101
Do online journalists, commentators, and ordinary users practice self-censorship? | 1 / 4 |
Self-censorship in the media is pervasive, even among independent online news outlets, because existing legislation often contains ambiguity. However, after the resignation of former president Nazarbaev in 2019, many users have visibly become more outspoken in online discussions even as most generally avoid a range of taboo topics. Online media workers continue to test boundaries, despite facing legal harassment and physical violence (see C3 and C7).
A May 2023 report on self-censorship in Kazakhstan found that journalists censor themselves for an array of reasons, including fear of repercussions for negatively covering oligarchs, the views of media outlets’ owners, and repressive state policies.102
The January 2022 protests and the ensuing crackdown sparked a wave of legal and extralegal prosecution of critics and content-removal orders (see B2 and C3). In March 2022, the Prosecutor General’s Office issued a statement urging Kazakhstani citizens to refrain from sharing provocative information, information considered false, or inciting hatred while discussing the full-scale Russian military invasion of Ukraine online.103
A 2017 law prohibits anonymous online comments (see C4).104 Although this ban is loosely observed, it limits the space for free speech on popular news sites that comply.
Are online sources of information controlled or manipulated by the government or other powerful actors to advance a particular political interest? | 1 / 4 |
Compared with print and broadcast media, the online media landscape remains a freer space for reporting and self-expression. While social media platforms remain the most liberal setting for the public exchange of news and opinions, online discourse is prone to manipulation, including by commentators paid by the government.105 According to one analysis, the activities of paid commentators serve to distract internet users in times of crisis and to play up the state’s successes. Observers reported that bots posted messages in support of President Toqaev ahead of the November 2022 presidential elections.106
In June 2022, duplicates of four Kazakhstani news sites appeared on the internet, each containing the same pro-Kremlin article on Russia-Kazakhstan relations. The URLs of the duplicate sites mimicked the original websites’ URLs, differing only by one letter. The hosting company ultimately stopped hosting the duplicate sites, leaving them inaccessible.107
Following the Russian military’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine in February 2022, Margulan Akan, an editor at Bugin Media, reported that a government official privately requested that he write a Facebook post in support of the Kremlin-helmed Eurasian Economic Union (EEU). Though he declined the request, he soon began to see government officials and social media users post similar text in support of the EEU. According to Bella Orynbetova, a journalist who previously worked for progovernment media outlets, individuals or entities associated with the government will pay influencers 50,000 tenge ($98) to post in support of government policies.108
During the January 2022 protests and the ensuing violence, information was scarce and there were instances of unverifiable information spread by government officials. For example, President Toqaev claimed 20,000 terrorists had attacked Kazakhstan. The unsubstantiated allegation was later said by an analyst close to the presidential administration to be deliberate misinformation funneled to the president by conspirators from the NSC leadership.109 Later, President Toqaev himself confirmed this claim.110 Disinformation also spread through messaging services. The government also pledged to “punish those spreading falsehoods and rumors online.”111
In December 2020, Facebook identified a network of 59 accounts, on both Facebook and Instagram, connected to the NSC and an antiextremism unit of a regional police department, which became active after a wave of political protests in 2019 and 2020 but was largely inactive by the time Facebook removed it from the platform.112
Officials, civil servants, and employees of state-owned companies are obliged to follow a set of guidelines on their internet use. These guidelines urge them not to post or repost materials that are critical of the government and not to “friend” the authors of such material to preserve the image of the public sector and prevent the dissemination of false information or leaks.113
Are there economic or regulatory constraints that negatively affect users’ ability to publish content online? | 1 / 3 |
Most major nonstate online news media outlets are affiliated with government officials or business figures with ties to the government. These outlets are likely to be recipients of government procurement contracts to produce favorable reporting. Indeed, many outlets, including domestic privately owned blogging platforms, are frequent recipients of such contracts.114 According to IREX’s 2022 Vibrant Information Barometer (VIBE), many media outlets that receive state funding avoid angering the government to ensure more funding and try not to disclose that they are recipients of state funding.115
According to research conducted by the Soros Foundation Kazakhstan, the government spent 41.7 to 47.1 billion tenge ($94.6 to $106.9 million) annually between 2016 and 2020 to implement its information agenda.116 The Legal Media Center, an NGO focused on media rights, sued the MISD to demand information about all media contracts, but a court rejected the case in January 2018, citing “commercial secrecy,” a talking point the MISD repeated when it faced similar questions in October 2020.117 Overall, the volume of state media contracts has exceeded the advertising market for several years in a row.118 Although the government made it difficult to trace and generalize data regarding state procurement contracts with mass media outlets, NGOs assert that the total amount of spending may reach 100 billion tenge a year ($226.9 million).119 The draft law on mass media introduced in February 2023 (see B3) does not require additional transparency concerning these contracts.120
The draft law on mass media would also require news outlets, including online outlets, to follow government instructions in “specific conditions,” which is a vague term that can be applied at any time, including during crises. Additionally, as in the existing law on mass media, the draft law defines all online publishers as mass media (see B3).121
In July 2023, after the coverage period, President Toqaev enacted the Law on Online Platforms and Online Advertising (see C2), requiring social media users who earn revenue through their content—including influencers—to pay a tax ranging from 3 to 10 percent on any income they generate.122
Online news media are not required to register with the government. There are no serious restrictions on their access to advertising, but periodic blocking discourages businesses from placing ads on independent news sites. Furthermore, the digital media market in Kazakhstan, as in many other countries, is quite small. According to the 2022 VIBE, most media in Kazakhstan depend on state financing or grants from international organizations.123 Online outlets’ ability to remain in business is also limited by certain regulations, including a 20 percent cap on foreign stakes in any company.124
Does the online information landscape lack diversity and reliability? | 2 / 4 |
Despite the challenging business environment for independent outlets, a small number of respected and critical websites continue to operate in Kazakhstan. The restrictions on the online media market remain less severe than those on the traditional media sector.
International social media and communications platforms are accessible and popular, although connectivity is sometimes restricted (see A3 and B1). According to DataReportal, which measures aggregate users across various platforms as opposed to unique individuals, there were 11.85 million social media users in Kazakhstan as of January 2023.125
In October 2022, ISP and mobile operator Beeline announced that it would stop broadcasting 15 Russian TV channels in its digital television package. Following reported consultations with Russia’s Ministry of Digital Development, Communications, and Mass Media, Beeline reversed this decision.126
Users can freely access most international news platforms, but only some Kazakhstanis consume content in English. While there is much more domestic online content available in Russian than in Kazakh, including on news portals and social media, the volume of Kazakh-language content is gradually increasing.
Tools like VPNs are widely used to circumvent sporadic blocking, although the authorities have blocked some VPN services (see C4).
All public institutions are required to provide at least Kazakh- and Russian-language versions of their websites, and many private-sector entities follow this example. The country has started transitioning from the Cyrillic alphabet to the Latin alphabet, with the stated aim of making the Kazakh language compatible with most encoding and fonts for digital communications.127
Do conditions impede users’ ability to mobilize, form communities, and campaign, particularly on political and social issues? | 3 / 6 |
Score Change: The score improved from 2 to 3 because there were fewer restrictions on online organizing during the coverage period.
Social media platforms and other digital tools are used for civic and political organizing in Kazakhstan. Popular platforms are subject to periodic restrictions, particularly ahead of and during demonstrations. Discussions of political or social issues on social media platforms are often eclipsed by sensationalist content that is widely shared online.
During and after the January 2022 protests and the ensuing violence, the authorities claimed they disrupted online communications to prevent the spread of information and use of apps for coordinating “riots.” They also cracked down on individuals who shared footage of the events (see C3). However, shortly after the January 2022 protests, civil society and the general public started to advocate for more significant political transformation, which Toqaev had promised when he was elected in 2019. This resulted in significant activity both online128 and offline,129 including multiple online petitions as well as several rallies and humanitarian initiatives that mobilized participants, mainly through social media. For example, in March 2022, over 2,000 people attended a rally supporting Ukraine.130
In September 2021, civil society representatives created a petition against the Cyberbullying Law (see B3).131 In March and April 2022, people who opposed the bill held protests in Almaty and Astana, then called Nur-Sultan.132
The authorities sometimes block messaging apps or internet access ahead of protests to prevent users from accessing group chats to coordinate protest actions, including those run by the Democratic Choice of Kazakhstan (DVK), a banned opposition party. Informants have infiltrated critical groups on Telegram and other platforms to build cases for prosecutions.133
Many online petition websites remain blocked to prevent campaigning. In December 2022, the Majilis, Parliament’s lower chamber, approved the first reading of the draft law on public oversight, which includes an online petitioning mechanism. Under the draft law, a special online platform will be created to host electronic petitions to local and national state bodies. Those bodies would be obligated to consider a petition if it reaches a certain threshold of signatures, though the threshold differs for each body.134 The MISD initially announced its intention to create an official petition platform in 2019.135
Police routinely summon activists ahead of planned protests to warn them against holding demonstrations, intimating that they will face consequences, or preemptively detain them to prevent their participation.136
Do the constitution or other laws fail to protect rights such as freedom of expression, access to information, and press freedom, including on the internet, and are they enforced by a judiciary that lacks independence? | 1 / 6 |
The constitution guarantees freedom of expression, but this right is qualified by other laws and severely restricted in practice by prohibitions on defamation, publication of false information, and other speech-related offenses (see C2). In June 2022, following a national referendum, the government published amendments to the constitution that transfer some of the president’s powers to the parliament.137 During the protests and ensuing violence in January 2022, Toqaev temporarily declared a state of emergency, which criminalized “mass gatherings.”138
Although internet resources are deemed mass media outlets, bloggers do not enjoy the same rights as journalists, and even formally employed journalists face numerous restrictions on their work. In February 2019, for example, the regulator said it would further restrict journalists’ already limited access to events at state bodies.139 Police and government supporters who harass bloggers and journalists are seldom punished and enjoy de facto immunity. Nevertheless, the government’s plan for the development of Kazakhstan’s information sphere, adopted in April 2020, envisions raising the profile of bloggers, including by according them the right to be accredited by various government institutions.140
The president appoints all judges, and the judiciary is not independent in practice. The Constitutional Court was abolished in 1995 and replaced with the Constitutional Council, to which citizens and public associations were not eligible to submit complaints. However, during the coverage period, as part of President Toqaev’s reform agenda and as a result of a nationwide referendum on constitutional amendments in June 2022, the Constitutional Court was restored. The court started accepting citizens’ appeals in January 2023, and as of February 24, 2023, nearly 1,500 complaints had been submitted; over 1,000 had received a written explanation, approximately 400 were under consideration, and 27 were under preliminary review.141
Are there laws that assign criminal penalties or civil liability for online activities, particularly those that are protected under international human rights standards? | 0 / 4 |
The government uses several provisions in the criminal code and the code of administrative offenses to restrict forms of online expression that may be protected under international human rights standards.142 Vaguely worded legislation leaves ample space for interpreting criticism and opinions as defamation or extremism.
Article 174 of the criminal code prescribes fines of up to $50,000, up to 7 years of probation, or imprisonment of up to 20 years for the incitement of class, ethnic, national, religious, or social hatred.143 The maximum penalty of 20 years’ imprisonment can be awarded if the crime is “committed by a criminal group or entails severe consequences.” Prosecutions under Article 174 are widespread, and human rights advocates have repeatedly voiced concerns about the lack of clarity in its terminology, especially the concept of “social” hatred.144 Article 179 prescribes 5 to 10 years in prison for “propaganda or public calls” for the seizure of power or “forcible change of the constitutional order” when made using mass media or telecommunications, while Article 256 prescribes 7 to 12 years in prison for “public appeals to commit an act of terrorism” made through the same means.145 Article 274 prohibits the dissemination of rumors or “knowingly false information that creates the danger of disrupting public order or causing substantial harm” to citizens, organizations, or the state, which is also punishable by up to seven years in prison in the most extreme cases.146
In March 2023, President Toqaev signed into law amendments to the criminal code that prescribe stricter penalties for incitement to riots using telecommunications networks, with possible sentences ranging from three to seven years’ imprisonment.147
In June 2020, President Toqaev signed into law amendments decriminalizing defamation.148 The amendments move defamation from Article 130 of the criminal code to the code of administrative offenses, which entails a fine of $1,000 to $3,500 or 15 to 20 days’ administrative detention. If the act of defamation was made publicly, via mass media, or on ICT networks, the fine increases to between $1,200 and $4,200, and the detention period increases to 20 to 25 days; if the act of defamation contains accusations of corruption against a public official, the administrative detention period can reach up to 30 days. Under these amendments, Article 174 remains in the criminal code, although the word “provocation” was changed to “incitement,” and violators can face fines ranging from $13,000 to $45,000 instead of prison sentences in some cases.149
However, insult remains a crime. The criminal code provides stricter punishments for insulting state officials, judges, and lawmakers. Government officials and progovernment business magnates have a history of using defamation and insult charges to punish critical reporting. In January 2023, President Toqaev announced that he was nullifying a law that had prevented insults against former president Nazarbaev and his family members. 150 The Ministry of Justice confirmed that it will introduce amendments to the criminal code eliminating these special protections.151 However, as of May 2023, articles criminalizing the desecration of Nazarbaev’s image and insulting Nazarbaev or members of his family remained in the criminal code.
In July 2023, after the coverage period, the government enacted the Law on Online Platforms and Online Advertising (see B6), which stipulates that individuals who post false information on social media can be fined 69,000 tenge ($147); business influencers can be fined up to 138,000 tenge ($294).152
In 2015, the MIC, which was later dissolved and had its duties transferred to the MISD, stated that social media users could be held liable for extremist comments posted on their pages by third parties, an offense under Article 183 of the criminal code and punishable by up to 50 days in jail.153 Users who post or share such content may be fined for its “production, storage, import, transportation, and dissemination,” and in some cases, jailed for up to 20 years under Article 174 of the criminal code.154
Are individuals penalized for online activities, particularly those that are protected under international human rights standards? | 2 / 6 |
Individuals, including journalists, are frequently penalized for online activities. Kazakhstani authorities have a long track record of issuing charges of defamation and, more recently, the dissemination of false information as a pretext to silence or punish critics. Arrests related to the January 2022 protests and subsequent state of emergency continued during the coverage period.155
In March 2023, blogger Duman Mukhametkerim, who contested the parliamentary elections that month, spent 25 days under administrative arrest for allegedly calling for “mass riots” after he called for protests against the “fraudulent” election results in a YouTube video.156 In April 2023, opposition politician Nurjan Altaev was arrested and jailed for 15 days for allegedly calling for mass riots after he livestreamed from a police station in Astana, calling on people in the city to rally in support of oil workers who had been detained for striking.157
In February 2023, critical blogger Makhambet Abzhan was sentenced to nine years in jail for allegedly extorting a businessman and blackmailing him with the publication of defamatory materials.158 Abzhan had initially been imprisoned for two months on these charges, which other journalists condemned as a ”political hunt,” in July 2022.159 Previously, in January 2022, police in Astana, then called Nur-Sultan, briefly detained Abzhan,160 who was covering protest rallies in the capital, and later tried to storm his apartment (see C7). Fearing for his safety, Abzhan went into hiding until later that month, when he resurfaced and told the media that he had been designated as a witness in a criminal case161 that involved his interview with Dozhd, an independent Russian television channel.162
In December 2022, Mikhail Kozachkov, a prominent investigative journalist at the newspaper Vremya (Time) and administrator of a popular Telegram channel, was arrested by the Financial Monitoring Agency (FMA), a special service dealing with economic crimes,163 charged him with disseminating false and discrediting information that aided the mafia in launching illegal hostile takeovers.164 Vremya denounced the prosecution as politically motivated, saying that Kozachkov was arrested in retaliation for his investigative and critical journalistic work.165 Adil Soz, the country’s largest media rights watchdog, made a statement condemning alleged procedural violations in the case, including by the FMA.166 Kozachkov denied the accusations,167 and a number of Kazakhstani and international organizations urged the government to release him.168 In February 2023, he was released from the detention facility and placed under house arrest.169 The case remained ongoing as of the end of the coverage period.
In November 2022, environmental activist Nikolai Katchiev, who advocated against corruption schemes allegedly involving local factories and the municipal administration in Bestobe, was detained and interrogated. The authorities also searched his house and seized his laptop. He is currently accused of disseminating patently false information in his YouTube videos. In 2021, he was found guilty of the same crime and sentenced to one year of probation.170
In August 2022, Aya Sadvakasova, an activist from Stepnogorsk, was sentenced to three years’ probation for allegedly disseminating false information via social media during the January 2022 protests; she was also accused of being a member of the banned DVK. According to media reports, as of August 2022, 11 criminal cases related to “fake news dissemination” during the January protests and ensuing violence had been opened, with at least one case resulting in a sentence of one year of probation.171
In June 2022, the minister of education and science, Sayasat Nurbek, sued journalist Gulbanu Abenova over a November 2020 Facebook post in which she alleged that Nurbek might be involved in corruption schemes. In September 2022, the court ruled in favor of Nurbek, requiring Abenova to pay the minister one million tenge ($2,178) as compensation for “moral damage.”172
In March 2022, bloggers Margulan Boranbay and Danat Namazbaev were sentenced to five years in prison for “incitement of interethnic strife” for their Facebook posts, which called for a change in government and advocated for accountability for corrupt government officials. Both were known as critics of the government, Russian imperialism, and Moscow’s war against Ukraine. Boranbay was previously arrested in October 2020 on similar charges and had since been under house arrest.173 According to the March 2022 court ruling, he will be denied the right to engage in media-related activities for three years after his release.174 In July 2022, an Almaty court denied their appeal and added two months to Boranbay’s sentence.175
In May 2021, Temirlan Ensebek, a blogger who ran a satirical social media account, was arrested for allegedly spreading “misinformation and misleading the public,” despite the fact that Ensebek deleted the account several months before he was detained.176 His laptop and mobile phones were confiscated.177 Ensebek was interrogated and released, but he faced charges of “dissemination of patently false information, posing a hazard of significant damage to rights and lawful interests of citizens, society, and state,”178 which can result in fines up to $20,000 or a 3-year prison term.179 The case against Ensebek was ultimately dismissed in September 2022.180
The authorities are known to use terrorism and extremism charges, including “provocation of hatred” (Article 174 of the criminal code), to prosecute online activity,181 usually applying “restricted freedom,” or suspended sentences.182 Local human rights advocates have criticized the lack of expertise among judges and prosecutors evaluating extremism or terrorism charges.183 There were no major cases using this legal ground for prosecution for online activities recorded during the coverage period.
In past years, the authorities routinely arrested and prosecuted individuals for posting critical commentary online, especially online activities related to the banned DVK. The classification of the DVK as an extremist group made it illegal to disseminate its content online, including through private messages.184
Does the government place restrictions on anonymous communication or encryption? | 1 / 4 |
The government places restrictions on anonymous communication. Since December 2017, users have been required to identify themselves using government-issued digital signature technology or short-message service (SMS) verification in order to comment on domestic websites;185 failure to enforce the rule can lead to fines.186 Some news outlets and other sites introduced identification functionality in response to the requirement, but more simply disabled their comment sections, inviting readers to comment on social media platforms instead.
The government is cracking down on VPNs and other anonymizing tools with court orders.187 Websites of popular VPNs, including TunnelBear and TouchVPN, are inaccessible. In 2020, the regulator blocked 148 circumvention tools (see B1).188 In March 2023, Belize-based VPN hidemy.name, which was banned in 2020, announced that it would challenge the ban in court (see B1).189
Encryption tools are not restricted, but most users do not employ them. When internet access was restricted during the January 2022 protests, neither VPN gateways nor other circumvention tools, including the built-in VPNs in the Telegram app, were available. However, some users were able to gain access because Kazakhstanis living abroad set up proxy servers, primarily for Telegram.190
SIM card registration is required for mobile phone users. The government also requires users to register all devices that use mobile networks with their mobile service providers, linking a person’s government-issued identification, SIM card information, and device IMEI codes. Under 2018 legal amendments, unregistered mobile devices were to be disabled by service providers beginning in January 2019.191 In October 2019, the authorities enabled the IMEI code system, forcing operators to disable numerous unregistered devices (see A3 and A4). By law, operators are prohibited from providing services to clients with unregistered devices.192
Authorities presented the 2018 amendments as a means of fighting mobile device theft, counterfeiting, and terrorism.193 However, human rights advocates warned of their effects on user privacy and their potential to enable surveillance by effectively linking personal identification numbers, SIM cards, and IMEI codes.194 The technical capacity to disable a device was reportedly used to target activists during the protests during and after the 2019 presidential elections.195
Since 2016, users have had to obtain an SMS code to access public Wi-Fi networks, which opens the door to surveillance because of the country’s SIM card registration requirement.196 Businesses can be fined up to 300,000 tenge ($680) for failing to comply with the new rules, while users can be fined up to 30,000 tenge ($68).197 As of 2021, only larger restaurant chains had introduced this system.
Does state surveillance of internet activities infringe on users’ right to privacy? | 2 / 6 |
It is difficult to estimate the extent of government surveillance in Kazakhstan, but users in the country have been targeted by spyware. Digital rights groups allege that large-scale surveillance infrastructure is in place. The government employs SORM technology, which originated in Russia and is similar to that employed by other former Soviet countries, for DPI purposes and other functions. An investigation by the news site Vlast published in February 2019 revealed a vast network of ties between Kazakhstan and Russia in the area of cybersecurity.198
In June 2022, Inga Imanbai, who is married to unregistered Democratic Party leader Janbolat Mamai, reported that her phone had been infected with Hermit spyware, which can record audio and extract information from Android devices.199 Imanbai’s claim came just days after Lookout Threat Lab released an investigation revealing that the Kazakhstani government had “probably” purchased Hermit from the Italian company RCS Labs and used it to target domestic actors.200 The software reportedly resembles the Israeli NSO Group’s Pegasus spyware, which the government has also allegedly used, and specifically targets Android devices.201
In July 2021, Forbidden Stories, a French nonprofit news outlet, and a coalition of news organizations including the Organized Crime and Corruption Reporting Project (OCCRP), identified phone numbers linked to Kazakhstani oligarchs and political figures in a leaked dataset. Investigators described the dataset as a list of people of interest to clients of the NSO Group, which sells Pegasus. According to the investigation, almost 2,000 Kazakhstani phone numbers were selected for targeting during former president Nazarbaev’s rule.202 Numbers belonging to President Toqaev, then prime minister Askar Mamin, prominent political figures, oligarchs close to Nazarbaev, and opposition figures were among them. The government has repeatedly denied the allegations. Additionally, two Kazakhstani journalists identified their numbers on the list.203
In November 2021, six activists from Oyan Kazakhstan, a proreform youth movement, received messages from Apple warning them that their devices might have been compromised by Pegasus.204 A forensic investigation conducted by Amnesty International’s Security Lab confirmed that four activists’ devices had been infected with the spyware.205
In January 2018, new NSC–developed technical regulations for SORM entered into force.206 Local human rights monitors have since alleged that law enforcement bodies and special services watch and wiretap phone conversations of opposition activists without following proper procedures.207
Various authorities monitor internet traffic. The STS is responsible for overseeing cross-border network traffic through a system called the Centralized Management of Telecommunication Networks. All telecommunications service providers must be connected to this system and are required to grant authorities physical access to their control centers.208 Kazakhtelecom, which maintains a DPI system separate from SORM, insists that it is used for traffic management and provides no access to users’ personal data.209
A root security certificate called the Qaznet Trust Certificate had been introduced legally in 2016.210 Since then it has been “tested” several times in Astana.211 Users were warned212 that they might have difficulty accessing foreign websites, which were often inaccessible during these tests, if they chose to not install the certificate.213 The certificate’s introduction was justified as a means of fighting the theft of users’ personal data, fraud, and other online threats, including cyberattacks.214 In July 2019, the NSC admitted that the certificate enables it to decrypt secure traffic but said it did not plan to store and view the details of citizens’ online activities.215
In early August 2019, the NSC declared that the certificate’s trial period was over, claiming that the pilot test allowed it to test its cybersecurity systems as well as reveal and prevent millions of cybersecurity incidents.216 Apple, Google, and Mozilla promised to ban the certificate from their respective web browsers (Safari, Chrome, and Firefox) to ensure that their users’ personal data were not intercepted.217 In December 2020, these companies, along with Microsoft, followed through and banned the certificate from their networks and software.218
The authorities appear to engage in social media surveillance, including under the auspices of the MISD219 and via contractors like Alem Research and IMAS, a private company that advertises a “monitoring system” that conducts this type of social media surveillance. IMAS’s clients include the Prosecutor General’s Office, the Ministry of Justice, and various local government administrations.220
In May 2022, the Prosecutor General’s Office reported that the Ministry of Internal Affairs had obtained special equipment and software to monitor social networking sites and identify users of social media and messaging applications.221 According to government officials, they obtained this equipment to prevent scams, fraud, and Ponzi schemes.
Activists using social media are occasionally intercepted or punished, sometimes preemptively, by authorities who have prior knowledge of their planned activities.222 Reports have emerged that authorities penetrated group chats on WhatsApp and Telegram, based on claims by activists that they faced repercussions for material they posted only via those apps. It is unclear how authorities could have gained access to these closed chats, but it is generally understood that either there are informants in critical groups, or that police seize and access the phones of detained activists.223
In November 2020, the NSC adopted the Rules of Operation of the National Video-Monitoring System.224 The system contains hardware and software for collection, processing, and storage of video files for the purpose of national security and public order. The NSC determines if an individual or entity is obliged to connect to the system, defining them as “clients,” and outlines the costs for the installation and service of the equipment.
In June 2020, Toqaev signed the law on digital technologies, which designated the Information Security Committee at the MDDIAI as the body responsible for the protection of personal data. The law also provided for creation of the national video-monitoring system, which lacks precise regulation and public oversight, and biometric authentication of citizens with no guarantee of data protection.225
Does monitoring and collection of user data by service providers and other technology companies infringe on users’ right to privacy? | 2 / 6 |
Telecommunications companies have implemented SORM technical regulations (see C5), effectively granting the Kazakhstani government real-time access to their subscribers’ data.
The process that governs the authorities’ ability to request user data from various companies is not always followed. Security agencies can effectively access user data stored by the companies at will, as firms that wish to operate in the country have no means of resisting their demands. In its “exit report” upon leaving the Kazakhstani market, Tele2, the Swedish mobile service provider whose stake in Tele2-Altel was bought by Kazakhtelecom in 2019, noted that “it was not possible for Tele2 KZ to know how often the SORM system was used and whether the required warrant had been obtained.”226
Legislation obliges both fixed-line ISPs and mobile service providers to retain records of users’ online activities, phone numbers, billing details, internet protocol (IP) addresses, browsing history, protocols of data transmission, and other data.227 Providers must store user data for two years and grant access within 24 hours to “operative-investigatory bodies,” including the NSC and other security agencies, when approved by a prosecutor or “by coordination with the Prosecutor General’s Office.”228 The code of administrative offenses imposes fines on ISPs for failure to store user data.229 Tele2’s exit report revealed that it was not allowed to publish the nature and number of the requests it received from law enforcement.230
Domain names using the .kz and .KA3 country codes must operate on domestic servers.231 According to Kazakhstani communications law, users’ personal data must be stored within Kazakhstani borders.232 In late 2017, the government announced that it planned to negotiate with foreign social media platforms and persuade them to operate local servers that could provide easier state access to citizens’ personal data.233 In September 2020, the government amended domain registration rules, enabling the government to suspend a domain name if the website is physically hosted outside of Kazakhstan or if any of its software is hosted outside of the country (see B3).234
In April 2021, the government adopted the Rules on Examination of Processes Related to Personal Data, which allows the STS to access the hardware and software (“objects of informatization”) of “electronic information resources” to assess their “personal data management.”235 Also, according to the administrative code, operators are subject to fines for failure to distribute the National Security Certificate among clients, store personal information of users, or grant law enforcement bodies or special services access to data or equipment (see A3, B1, and C5).236
Domestic website owners are required to retain commentators’ data for at least three months and provide the government with this information upon request.237
Are individuals subject to extralegal intimidation or physical violence by state authorities or any other actor in relation to their online activities? | 2 / 5 |
The coverage period was marked by a significant increase in the number of cases of violence and intimidation against journalists.
A seemingly coordinated spate of attacks against journalists and media outlets began in October 2022, ahead of the snap presidential election in November, and continued into early 2023, in the lead-up to the parliamentary elections. In October, the Orda.kz editorial office received a severed head of a pig.238 Glass doors and windows at the office of Elmedia, an independent news site, were broken six times between October 2022 and January 2023.239 In January and February 2023, cars belonging to independent journalist Dinara Egeubaeva240 and journalist Vadim Boreyko’s241 cameraman were set on fire. Boreyko also reported in January that his apartment’s entrance door was blocked and torched.242 In February 2023, independent journalist Daniyar Moldabekov reported that he was punched in the face at his front door and instructed to “behave” by an unknown person wearing a medical mask.243
In February 2023, the Ministry of Internal Affairs and the NSC announced the arrest of a foreign national, who they called a “coordinator” of the attacks against journalists and a “qualified hacker.” The equipment seized from this man reportedly provided evidence of the network of attackers and payment information. Later, in March 2023, four more foreigners were named as his accomplices,244 and seven more suspects in the case were arrested.245 According to the press release, the attacks were intended to imitate “government-inspired persecution of journalists,” and discredit “the president and his democratic reforms.”246 Prior to the arrest of the foreign national, 18 people were detained for crimes against journalists and bloggers between September 2022 and February 2023.247 Police deemed some of the acts, including the broken glass in the Elmedia office, to be minor hooliganism.248
These acts cast a chilling effect on independent journalism, and were widely condemned by both the Kazakhstani media community and international organizations, including Reporters Without Borders (RSF) and the Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ). The spokesperson for the MISD commented that “attacks on journalists are attacks on the society and state,”249 and President Toqaev repeatedly urged law enforcement to investigate the cases, find the perpetrators, and protect journalists.250
In July 2022, Olesya Vertinskaya, a journalist for independent news site Dorozhniy Kontrol (Road Control), which reports on police and traffic officers, was attacked outside of her home. She had received threatening text messages about her stories on a local fish company prior to the attack.251
During the protests and ensuing violence in January 2022, the authorities raided journalists’ homes and seized their phones.252 Leonid Rasskazov, a journalist working with online news outlet Orda.kz, was shot with a rubber bullet while covering the protests.253
Members of the LGBT+ community in Kazakhstan sporadically face online harassment and tend to exercise self-censorship.254
Are websites, governmental and private entities, service providers, or individual users subject to widespread hacking and other forms of cyberattack? | 0 / 3 |
Score Change: The score declined from 1 to 0 because online media outlets and government institutions faced severe cyberattacks during the coverage period.
There were several major technical attacks against independent media during the coverage period. Government websites and the Kazakhstani sector of internet in general also faced a multitude of significant cyberattacks from “foreign actors.”
In July 2022, critical news sites Orda.kz255 and UlysMedia256 reportedly experienced a series of distributed denial of service (DDoS) attacks. Orda.kz claimed it had been attacked three times in the six months leading up to July 2022. In September 2022, Toppress.kz, Sn.kz, and NewTimes.kz also reported that they had faced DDoS attacks. 257 Kazakhtelecom confirmed that the attacks originated from abroad.258 According to Toppress.kz, they faced the problems after publishing material about a United Nations (UN) report on war crimes committed by the Russian military in Ukraine.259 UlysMedia260 and KazTAG,261 another critical outlet, were also targeted by DDoS attacks in October 2022. In January 2023, UlysMedia reported that its website was hacked and defaced. The attackers also published personal data, identification documents, and family photographs belonging to Samal Ibraeva, the outlet’s editor in chief.262 In March 2023, Factcheck.kz reported a DDoS attack.263
In September 2022, the STS reported large-scale, coordinated264 cyberattacks, allegedly originating from abroad, on the Kazakhstani segment of the internet, which caused serious congestion of the backbone networks.265 The STS later stated that nearly 20 million cyberattacks were repelled, claiming the attackers may have intended to disrupt the internet in Kazakhstan ahead of the November 2022 presidential elections.266 President Toqaev claimed that these cybersecurity threats were an attempt to “sow chaos and hinder positive reforms.”267 Some experts noted that the cyberattacks coincided with military mobilization in Russia and the mass exodus of military-age men from Russia; others believed the attacks were echoes of international hacker attacks against Russia.268
In March 2023, the STS reported a cybersecurity incident in which a foreign hacker group allegedly stole files from state bodies and organizations and compromised the bodies’ hardware and software.269
Footnotes
- 1Ministry of Digital Development, Innovation, and Aerospace Industry of the Republic of Kazakhstan, Official response to access to information request, May 2023.
- 2ITU Datahub, “Kazakhstan: Individuals Using the Internet.” “Kazakhstan: Fixed-broadband subscriptions,” “Kazakhstan: Active mobile broadband subscriptions,” accessed September 2023, https://datahub.itu.int/data/?e=KAZ.
- 3Ministry of Digital Development, Innovation, and Aerospace Industry of the Republic of Kazakhstan, “Digital Kazakhstan,” December 12, 2017, https://digitalkz.kz/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/%D0%A6%D0%9A-%D1%80%D1%….
- 4Ministry of Digital Development, Innovation, and Aerospace Industry of the Republic of Kazakhstan, Official response to access to information request, April 2023.
- 5“5G network to be launched in three Kazakhstan cities by end of 2022,” Qazaq TV, June 13, 2022, https://qazaqtv.com/en/news/society/21267-5g-network-to-be-launched-in-….
- 6Speedtest, “Speedtest Global Index: Global Speeds May 2023,” accessed August 2023, https://www.speedtest.net/global-index.
- 7"Almaty subway equipped with free Wi-Fi", Vlast.kz, April 5, 2021, https://vlast.kz/novosti/44433-v-almaty-na-vseh-stanciah-metro-poavilsa….
- 8"Parks and riverbank in Pavlodar to offer free internet", Inform.kz, September 5, 2020, https://www.inform.kz/ru/besplatnyy-internet-mozhet-poyavit-sya-v-parka….
- 9“Mobile operators in Kazakhstan increase prices ungroundedly,” Kazakhstan Today, February 23, 2023, https://www.kt.kz/rus/state/operatory_sotovoy_svyazi_v_kazahstane_neobo….
- 10International Telecommunication Union, “ICT Prices,” accessed May 2023, https://www.itu.int/en/ITU-D/Statistics/Pages/ICTprices/default.aspx.
- 11“Tenge, inflation, salaries,” Kapital.kz, March 10, 2022, https://kapital.kz/finance/103523/tenge-inflyatsiya-i-zarplaty-chto-del….
- 12“Kazakhstan population statistics,” National Statistics Authority, accessed March 15, 2022, https://stat.gov.kz/api/getFile/?docId=ESTAT334809&lang=ru.
- 13“Kazakhtelecom opens public access points in villages,” Tengrinews.kz, March 15, 2022, https://tengrinews.kz/internet/kazahtelekom-zavershil-ustanovku-seti-po….
- 14“President instructed Kazakhtelecom to lower digital divide,” 24.kz, February 24, 2022, https://24.kz/ru/news/policy/item/529994-k-tokaev-poruchil-snizit-tsifr….
- 15“Сотовые операторы Казахстана договорились о шеринге сетей в рамках проекта ‘250+’," Tengrinews.kz, October 2, 2020, https://tengrinews.kz/internet/sotovyie-operatoryi-kazahstana-dogovoril….
- 16“North Kazakhstan Governor: wide coverage, poor quality,” Inform.kz, Februar 16, 2022, https://www.inform.kz/ru/akim-sko-ob-internete-ohvat-rastet-a-kachestvo….
- 17Economist Impact, “The Inclusive Internet Index 2022, Kazakhstan: Availability: Usage: Gender gap in internet access,” accessed September 2022, https://impact.economist.com/projects/inclusive-internet-index/2022/cou….
- 18Vlast.kz Telegram channel, January 5, 2023, accessed February 28, 2023, https://t.me/vlastkz/12764.
- 19Vlast.kz Telegram channel, April 9, 2023, accessed May 23, 2023, https://t.me/vlastkz/13573.
- 20Vlast.kz Telegram channel, April 11, 2023, accessed May 23, 2023, https://t.me/vlastkz/13670.
- 21"Hundreds protest in Almaty at a Democratic Party rally," Vlast.kz, April 24, 2021, https://vlast.kz/novosti/44711-sotni-celovek-vysli-na-miting-dempartii-…; “Женский марш и митинг в Алматы,” Mediazona.ca, March 8, 2021, https://mediazona.ca/online/2021/03/08/marsh; “Назарбаев, кет! Призывы к уходу «лидера нации» на митинге за реформы,” Azattyq.org, October 31, 2020, https://rus.azattyq.org/a/kazakhstan-almaty-rally-on-political-reforms/….
- 22“Internet disrupted in Kazakhstan as energy protests escalate,” NetBlocks, January 4, 2022, https://netblocks.org/reports/internet-disrupted-in-kazakhstan-amid-ene….
- 23Katia Patin, “Kazakhstan shut down its internet. These programmers opened a backdoor,” Coda Story, January 27, 2022, https://www.codastory.com/authoritarian-tech/kazakhstan-shut-down-its-i….
- 24“Kcell and Beeline explained interruption of service,” Tengrinews.kz, January 5, 2022, https://tengrinews.kz/news/v-kcell-i-beeline-obyyasnili-pereboi-so-svya….
- 25“Government tried to use DPI to block internet,” Exclusive.kz, January 12, 2022, https://www.exclusive.kz/expertiza/daily/127157/.
- 26“A list of organizations with uninterrupted internet access during states of emergency to be made in Kazakhstan,” Vlast.kz, January 26, 2023, https://vlast.kz/novosti/53612-v-kazahstane-sostavat-spisok-organizacij….
- 27“Постановление Правительства Республики Казахстан от 27 июля 2017 года № 457 О некоторых вопросах государственной технической службы [Decree of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated July 27, 2017 No. 457],” Zakon, March 26, 2019, https://online.zakon.kz/Document/?doc_id=33104760#pos=0;124.44445037841….
- 28Government Decree #630, October 1, 2020, http://adilet.zan.kz/rus/docs/P2000000630?fbclid=IwAR1ook-yTs9FAYb6YytB….
- 29State Technical Service website, accessed April 5, 2021, https://sts.kz/ru/board_of_directors.
- 30Закон Республики Казахстан от 5 июля 2004 года № 567-II «О связи» (с изменениями и дополнениями по состоянию на 02.07.2020 [The Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated July 5, 2004 No. 567-II “On Communications”, Article 41-1.1-2],” Zakon, January 10, 2020, https://online.zakon.kz/Document/?doc_id=1049207#pos=1133;-53&sdoc_para….
- 31“Закон Республики Казахстан от 5 июля 2004 года № 567-II «О связи» (с изменениями и дополнениями по состоянию на 02.07.2020 [The Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated July 5, 2004 No. 567-II “On Communications”, Article 41-1.1-2],” Zakon, January 10, 2020, https://online.zakon.kz/Document/?doc_id=1049207#pos=1133;-53&sdoc_para….
- 32“Закон Республики Казахстан от 6 января 2012 года № 527-IV «О национальной безопасности Республики Казахстан» (с изменениями и дополнениями по состоянию на 07.07.2020 г.) [On National Security of the Republic of Kazakhstan],” Zakon, January 1, 2020, https://online.zakon.kz/Document/?doc_id=31106860&mode=all.
- 33“Закон Республики Казахстан от 23 апреля 2014 года № 200-V «О внесении изменений и дополнений в некоторые законодательные акты Республики Казахстан по вопросам деятельности органов [On Amendments and Additions to Some Legislative Acts of the Republic of Kazakhstan on the Activities of Internal Affairs Bodies],” Zakon, October 29, 2015, https://online.zakon.kz/Document/?doc_id=31539059.
- 34“Постановление Правительства Республики Казахстан от 27 июля 2017 года № 457 «О некоторых вопросах государственной технической службы» (с изменениями от 26.03.2019 г.) [On Certain Issues of the State Technical Service],” Zakon, March 26, 2019, https://online.zakon.kz/Document/?doc_id=33104760#pos=0;124.44445037841….
- 35“Закон Республики Казахстан от 28 декабря 2017 года № 128-VI «О внесении изменений и дополнений в некоторые законодательные акты Республики Казахстан по вопросам информации и коммуникаций (с изменениями от 24.05.2018 г.) [On Information and Communications, Article 9-2],” Zakon, May 24, 2018, https://online.zakon.kz/Document/?doc_id=34205812#sub_id=92.
- 36KazNIX.kz, “KazNIX – traffic exchange point,” https://kaznix.kz/en/.
- 37NEQSOL Holdings, “AzerTelecom and Kazakhtelecom sign strategic partnership memorandum on Trans-Caspian project,” October 3, 2022, https://www.neqsolholding.com/news-and-media/azertelecom-and-kazakhtele….
- 38"Kazakhtelecom group scores T51 billion in profit," Kazakhtelecom, October 31, 2019, https://telecom.kz/ru/news/view/31323.
- 39“Сколько заработали и на что потратили средства сотовые операторы РК в 2020 году?” Ranking.kz. December 22, 2020, http://ranking.kz/ru/a/infopovody/skolko-zarabotali-i-na-chto-potratili….
- 40“Домашний интернет в РК — один из самых дешевых в мире [Home internet in Kazakhstan is one of the cheapest in the world],” Kapital.kz, December 23, 2021 https://kapital.kz/economic/101402/domashniy-internet-v-rk-odin-iz-samy…
- 41Kase.Kz, “Kazakhtelecom JSC (KZTK),” https://kase.kz/en/issuers/KZTK/.
- 42“Nazarbayev’s nephew owns an offshore company behind Kazakhtelecom,” Azattyq.org, February 17, 2022, https://rus.azattyq.org/a/31107946.html.
- 43Kase.Kz, “Kazakhtelecom JSC (KZTK),” https://kase.kz/en/issuers/KZTK/.
- 44“Satybaldy returned 28,8 per cent of Kazakhtelecom shares,” Vlast.kz, April 12, 2022, https://vlast.kz/novosti/49515-v-gosudarstvennuu-sobstvennost-vozvrasen….
- 45“Government Seizes Large Kazakhtelecom Stake from Nazarbaev's Nephew,” RFE/RL, April 12, 2022, https://www.rferl.org/a/kazakhstan-nazarbaev-nephew-shares-nationalized….
- 46“Kazakhtelecom minority shareholders ask clarity about deals,” Vlast.kz, March 14, 2022, https://vlast.kz/novosti/49127-dat-ocenku-sdelkam-kazahtelekoma-prosat-…
- 47“Kairat Satybaldy arrested for 2 months,” Vlast.kz, March 15, 2022, https://vlast.kz/novosti/49135-kajrat-satybaldy-arestovan-na-2-mesaca.h… .
- 48“Kazakhtelecom sells minority stake in Kcell,” Telecom Paper, October 1, 2021, https://www.telecompaper.com/news/kazakhtelecom-sells-minority-stake-in….
- 49“Company of Nazarbayev’s grandson to be scrutinized in Kazakhstan,” Kursiv.kz, April 6, 2022, https://kz.kursiv.media/2022-04-06/v-kazahstane-proveryat-kompaniju-vnu….
- 50“Kazakhtelecom to sell one of its mobile subsidiaries this year, says Minister,” CommsUpdate, July 28, 2023, https://www.commsupdate.com/articles/2023/07/28/kazakhtelecom-to-sell-o….
- 51“Minister Mussin to offer one of the Kazakhtelecom-owned mobile operators to the market,” Vlast.kz, April 5, 2022, https://vlast.kz/novosti/49422-musin-predlagaet-vyvesti-na-rynok-odnogo….
- 52Adil Nurmakov, “Казахстан снял государственную монополию на предоставление 4G [Kazakhstan lifts state monopoly on 4G],” Digital.Report, January 13, 2016, https://digital.report/v-kazahstane-snyata-monopoliya-na-predostavlenie….
- 53"Beeline запустил первую в Казахстане пилотную сеть 5G [Beeline launches first pilot 5G network in Kazakhstan]," Beeline, October 18, 2019, https://perma.cc/SLK3-3YVQ.
- 54“Almaty and Nur-Sultan test 5G,” Kapital.kz, October 6, 2021, https://kapital.kz/tehnology/99267/v-almaty-i-nur-sultane-nachali-testi….
- 55Baker McKenzie, “Doing Business in Kazakhstan 2019,” https://www.bakermckenzie.com/-/media/files/insight/guides/2019/doing-b….
- 56Baker McKenzie, “Doing Business in Kazakhstan 2019,” https://www.bakermckenzie.com/-/media/files/insight/guides/2019/doing-b….
- 57"Всё, что нужно знать об обязательной регистрации сотовых телефонов в Казахстане [All you need to know about cellphone registration in Kazakhstan]," Forbes, September 19, 2018, https://forbes.kz//process/technologies/vse_chto_nujno_znat_ob_obyazate….
- 58Aidana Yergaliyeva, “Kazakh President appoints new government, reorganises ministries,” Astana Times, February 26, 2019, https://astanatimes.com/2019/02/kazakh-president-appoints-new-governmen….
- 59" «Киберщит» заработает в Казахстане к концу 2018 года [Cybershield to start operation by the end of 2018]," Profit, April 13, 2018, https://profit.kz/news/45194/Kiberschit-zarabotaet-v-Kazahstane-k-koncu….
- 60“Kazakh Leader To Become Life-Long Security Council Chairman,” Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, May 31, 2018, https://www.rferl.org/amp/kazakh-parliament-adopts-bill-grant-nazarbaev….
- 61“В Казахстане регистратора зоны .kz будет определять государств [Kazakh regulator to determine the registry of .kz zone],” Digital.Report, March 7, 2016, https://digital.report/kazahstanskiy-regulyator-budet-opredelyat-admini….
- 62Official response by the Ministry of Information and Social Development to an information request, May 2023.
- 63“Several Russian and global media sites not accessible from Kazakhstan,” Forbes.kz, October 28, 2022, https://forbes.kz/massmedia/v_kazahstane_ne_otkryivayutsya_saytyi_dvuh_….
- 64“Thin type of internet censorship,” Azattyq.org, April 28, 2023, https://rus.azattyq.org/a/kazakhstan-throttling-azattyq-currenttime/323….
- 65“Kazakhstanis complain about YouTube acting up,” Tengrinews.kz, October 28, 2022, https://tengrinews.kz/internet/kazahstantsyi-pojalovalis-na-sboi-v-rabo….
- 66“Kazakhstan blocks WHO website,” Vlast.kz, November 25, 2022, https://vlast.kz/novosti/52750-v-kazahstane-zablokirovan-sajt-vsemirnoj….
- 67“WHO website blocked because the Ministry of Information lacks capacity to block pages,” Vlast.kz, December 8, 2022, https://vlast.kz/novosti/52941-sajt-voz-zablokirovan-polnostu-poskolku-….
- 68“Access to WHO site restored in Kazakhstan”, Vlast.kz, January 19, 2023, https://vlast.kz/novosti/53507-v-kazahstane-snova-dostupen-sajt-voz.html.
- 69“Blocking the protests,” Adil Soz, January 4, 2022, http://www.adilsoz.kz/news/show/id/3449.
- 70“Kokshetau Asia information portal blocked in Kazakhstan,” Adil Soz, January 28, 2022, http://www.adilsoz.kz/news/show/id/3512.
- 71Committee to Protect Journalists, “Kazakh outlet HOLA News reports website blocks after Pandora Papers coverage,” October 20, 2021, https://cpj.org/2021/10/kazakh-outlet-hola-news-reports-website-blocks-….
- 72Marat Shaken, “Первый казахстанский VPN сервис — VPN Nomad! [The first Kazakhstani VPN service – VPN Nomad!],” October 31, 2016, Facebook post, https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=1173041906116636&set=a.38395629….
- 73Rabiga Dysengulova, "Могут ли блокировать VPN в Казахстане [Can VPNs be blocked in Kazakhstan?]," Tengrinews.kz, July 26, 2019, https://tengrinews.kz/kazakhstan_news/mogut-li-blokirovat-vpn-v-kazahst….
- 74“A VPN service to appeal the blocking by Kazakhstan’s government,” Vlast.kz, March 14, 2023, https://vlast.kz/novosti/54286-zarubeznyj-vpn-servis-obzaluet-v-sude-bl….
- 75Official response by the Ministry of Information and Social Development to an information request, May 2023.
- 76“Kazakh Foreign Ministry comments on subpoena of a Kazakhstani media outlet to Russian court,” KazTAG, February 6, 2023, https://kaztag.kz/ru/news/mid-o-vyzove-kazakhstanskogo-smi-v-sud-rf-res….
- 77“Roskomnadzor demands that Vlast deletes stories about war in Ukraine,” Vlast.kz, December 13, 2022, https://vlast.kz/novosti/53007-roskomnadzor-trebuet-ot-vlasti-udalit-ne….
- 78Taissiya Koroleva, “Kazakhstan: How to Protect Digital Sovereignty of the Country?” Central Asian Bureau for Analytical Reporting, March 9, 2022, https://cabar.asia/en/kazakhstan-how-to-protect-digital-sovereignty-of-…
- 79Taissiya Koroleva, “Kazakhstan: How to Protect Digital Sovereignty of the Country?” Central Asian Bureau for Analytical Reporting, March 9, 2022, https://cabar.asia/en/kazakhstan-how-to-protect-digital-sovereignty-of-…
- 80“Roskomnadzor regulates Kazakhstani media?” Adil Soz, April 29, 2022, http://www.adilsoz.kz/news/show/id/3601.
- 81KazTAG Facebook page, post dated January 4, 2022, accessed March 17, 2022, https://www.facebook.com/kaztag/posts/6802240083181940.
- 82Daniil Kislov (Fergana chief editor) Facebook page, post dated January 10, 2021, accessed March 17, 2022, https://www.facebook.com/100001871463192/posts/6716351908437125/?d=n.
- 83“RSF refers violence against reporters covering protests in Kazakhstan to UN,” Reporters Without Borders, January 12, 2022, https://rsf.org/en/news/rsf-refers-violence-against-reporters-covering-….
- 84Facebook Transparency, “Kazakhstan,” accessed August 2023, https://transparency.fb.com/data/content-restrictions/country/KZ/.
- 85Google Transparency Report, “Kazakhstan: Government requests to remove content,” accessed August 2023, https://transparencyreport.google.com/government-removals/government-re….
- 86“В Казахстане приняли правила государственного мониторинга интернета [Kazakhstan adopts rules for state monitoring of internet],” Digital.Report, February 29, 2016, https://digital.report/v-kazahstane-prinyali-pravila-gosudarstvennogo-m….
- 87“Более 30 тыс. сайтов за год блокируется в Казахстане [Kazakhstan blocks more than 30,000 websites a year],” Digital.Report, June 8, 2017, https://digital.report/bolee-30-tyis-saytov-za-god-blokiruetsya-v-kazah….
- 88“Мониторить соцсети начнут по-новому в Казахстане [Monitoring social networks will start in a new way in Kazakhstan],” Sputnik News, June 6, 2019, https://ru.sputniknews.kz/society/20190606/10405710/socseti-monitoring-….
- 89“[About the Media],” Parliament of the Republic of Kazakhstan, amended April 11, 2019, https://egov.kz/cms/ru/law/list/Z990000451.
- 90“Сетевые издания в Казахстане: принудительная добровольность [Online publications in Kazakhstan: Voluntary or Obligatory?],” Digital.Report, January 21, 2016, https://digital.report/kazakhstan-new-regulations-online-media/.
- 91“A Law to Kill the Media,” Vlast.kz, February 8, 2023, https://vlast.kz/obsshestvo/53820-zakon-kotoryj-ubet-smi-v-kazahstane.h….
- 92“Draft law that would force social media promptly remove illegal content sent to Senate,” Informburo.kz, March 9, 2022, https://informburo.kz/novosti/zakonoproekt-obyazyvayushij-socseti-bystr….
- 93“How the cyberbullying law will regulate platforms,” Orda.kz, April 7, 2022, https://orda.kz/zakon-o-kiberbullinge-kakie-platformy-budet-kontrolirov….
- 94Government of Kazakhstan, “On making additions to the Decree of the Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated March 26, 2019 No. 142 ‘On certain issues of the Ministry of Information and Social Development of the Republic of Kazakhstan’.” July 22, 2022, https://adilet.zan.kz/rus/docs/P2200000515#z22.
- 95“On approval of the Rules for registration, use and distribution of domain names in the space of the Kazakhstani segment of the Internet,” http://adilet.zan.kz/rus/docs/V1800016654.
- 96“Letter from the Ministry to registrants of .KZ and .ҚАЗ domain names,” December 20, 2020, https://drive.google.com/file/d/1e2360pcRvCzHldQaZ5gjqYLpSPed-BGb/view?….
- 97“Закон Республики Казахстан от 5 июля 2004 года № 567-II «О связи» (с изменениями и дополнениями по состоянию на 02.07.2020 г.) [Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated July 5, 2004 No. 567-II “ On Communications (with amendments and additions as of July 2, 2020],” Zakon, https://online.zakon.kz/document/?doc_id=1049207#pos=1189;-36.
- 98“Кодекс Республики Казахстан об административных правонарушениях от 5 июля 2014 года № 235-V (с изменениями и дополнениями по состоянию на 07.07.2020 г.) [The Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan on Administrative Offenses],” Zakon, https://online.zakon.kz/document/?doc_id=31577399#pos=8779;-54.
- 99“Закон Республики Казахстан от 5 июля 2004 года № 567-II «О связи (с изменениями и дополнениями по состоянию на 02.07.2020 г.) [Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated July 5, 2004 No. 567-II “On Communications (with amendments and additions as of July 2, 2020],” Zakon, https://online.zakon.kz/m/document/?doc_id=1049207#sub_id=41010000.
- 100Interview with legal expert Igor Loskutov, Almaty, April 7, 2017.
- 101“Как узнать, заблокирован ли сайт в Казахстане, рассказал Абаев {Abayev on how to find out if a site is blocked in Kazakhstan],” Tengrinews, June 21, 2017, https://tengrinews.kz/internet/kak-uznat-zablokirovan-li-sayt-v-kazahst….
- 102Yekaterina Volkova, “Why is There Self-Censorship in Kazakhstan-based Media?,” Central Asian Bureau for Analytical Reporting, May 22, 2023, https://cabar.asia/en/why-is-there-self-censorship-in-kazakhstan-based-…
- 103“Prosecutor General’s Office made a statement about social media posts about Russia-Ukraine conflict,” Tengrinews.kz, March 28, 2022, https://tengrinews.kz/kazakhstan_news/genprokuratura-obratilas-kazahsta….
- 104“Kazakh ban on anonymous web comments explained,” Astana Times, December 9, 2017, https://astanatimes.com/2017/12/kazakh-ban-on-anonymous-web-comments-ex….
- 105Nazira Kozhanova, "Finding Kazakhstan’s Troll Farms," The Diplomat, February 20, 2019, https://thediplomat.com/2019/02/finding-kazakhstans-troll-farms//.
- 106Sofya Du Boulay, “Fake accounts and presidential elections in Kazakhstan,” Global Voices, May 26, 2023, https://globalvoices.org/2023/05/26/fake-accounts-and-presidential-elec….
- 107“Copies of 4 Kazakhstani news sites appeared in the internet,” Vlast.kz, June 21, 2022, https://vlast.kz/novosti/50493-kopii-cetyreh-kazahstanskih-novostnyh-sa….
- 108Zholdas Orisbayev, “Kazakh spin doctors try to tame anti-Russia mood,” Eurasianet, March 9, 2022, https://eurasianet.org/kazakh-spin-doctors-try-to-tame-anti-russia-mood.
- 109“The 20,000 terrorist data was given to Tokayev by the former NSC leadership,” Sputnik Kazakhstan, February 15, 2022, https://ru.sputnik.kz/20220215/tsifru-pro-20-tys-terroristov-tokaevu-da….
- 110“Tokayev referred to former law enforcement officials while talking about 20,000 terrorists,” Azattyq.org, June 5, 2022, https://rus.azattyq.org/a/31883960.html.
- 111Katrina Keegan, “Information Chaos in Kazakhstan,” The Diplomat, January 10, 2022, https://thediplomat.com/2022/01/information-chaos-in-kazakhstan/.
- 112Facebook Newsroom, “December 2020 Coordinated Inauthentic Behavior Report,” January 12, 2021, https://about.fb.com/news/2021/01/december-2020-coordinated-inauthentic….
- 113Victor Burdin, “Госслужащим РК запретили критиковать власть в соцсетях [State officials not allowed to criticize the power on social media],” Forbes Kazakhstan, January 12, 2015, https://forbes.kz/process/internet/gosslujaschim_i_byudjetnikam_rk_zapr….
- 114Joanna Lillis, “Nazarbayev's long rule leaves toxic legacy for Kazakhstan's media,” Committee to Protect Journalists, April 9, 2019, https://cpj.org/blog/2019/04/nazarbayev-kazakhstan-legacy-press-freedom….
- 115IREX, “Vibrant Information Barometer 2022: Kazakhstan,” 2022, https://www.irex.org/VIBE_2022_Kazakhstan.
- 116“200,000 tenge a minute,” Azattyq.org, July 9, 2021, https://rus.azattyq.org/a/31348000.html
- 117“Объемы размещаемого в частных СМИ госзаказа не афишируются «по пожеланию партнеров» — министр,” Azattyq.org, October 23, 2020, https://rus.azattyq.org/a/30908936.html.
- 118Vadim Boreiko, "Госзаказ в СМИ победил доходы от рекламы [State media contracts exceed ads income]," Informburo.kz, August 14, 2019, https://informburo.kz/stati/goszakaz-v-smi-pobedil-dohody-ot-reklamy.ht….
- 119“On reform of the media legislation”, Adil Soz, December 6, 2021, http://www.adilsoz.kz/news/show/id/3440
- 120“A Law to Kill the Media,” Vlast.kz, February 8, 2023, https://vlast.kz/obsshestvo/53820-zakon-kotoryj-ubet-smi-v-kazahstane.h….
- 121“A Law to Kill the Media,” Vlast.kz, February 8, 2023, https://vlast.kz/obsshestvo/53820-zakon-kotoryj-ubet-smi-v-kazahstane.h….
- 122Almaz Kumenov, “Kazakhstan adopts law to regulate untamed social media scene,” Eurasianet, July 12, 2023, https://eurasianet.org/kazakhstan-adopts-law-to-regulate-untamed-social….
- 123IREX “Vibrant Information Barometer 2022: Kazakhstan,” 2022, https://www.irex.org/VIBE_2022_Kazakhstan.
- 124IREX “Vibrant Information Barometer 2022: Kazakhstan,” 2022, https://www.irex.org/VIBE_2022_Kazakhstan.
- 125Simon Kemp, “Digital 2023 Kazakhstan,” February 15, 2023, https://datareportal.com/reports/digital-2023-kazakhstan.
- 126“Beeline Kazakhstan will not stop broadcast of Russian channels,” Vlast.kz, October 3, 2022, https://vlast.kz/novosti/51938-beeline-kazakhstan-ne-stanet-prekrasat-t….
- 127“Kazakhstan wants Kazakh written in Latin, not Cyrillic script,” The Economist, November 14, 2017, http://econ.st/2sN04el.
- 128“Petitions launched in Kazakhstan since the beginning of January,” The Steppe, January 20, 2022, https://the-steppe.com/razvitie/kakie-peticii-zapustili-v-kazahstane-s-….
- 129See “People in Almaty rallying for cleaner air,” Vlast.kz, February 26, 2022, https://vlast.kz/novosti/48888-v-almaty-prohodit-miting-za-cistyj-vozdu…; “Rally demanding freer registration of political parties taking place in Almaty,” Vlast.kz, February 27, 2022, https://vlast.kz/novosti/48894-v-almaty-prohodit-miting-za-registraciu-…; “Rally in support of women’s right to participate in politics,” Vlast.kz, March 8, 2022, https://vlast.kz/novosti/49030-v-almaty-prohodit-miting-za-pravo-zensin….
- 130Catherine Putz, “Rally in Support of Ukraine Illustrates Kazakhstan’s Awkward Position,” March 7, 2022, https://thediplomat.com/2022/03/rally-in-support-of-ukraine-illustrates….
- 131“Kazakh civil society opposes amendments to block social networks,” Vlazt.kz, September 29, 2021, https://vlast.kz/novosti/46862-grazdanskoe-obsestvo-kazahstana-vystupil….
- 132Zhar Zardykhan, “Nothing new in the ‘New Kazakhstan’ as attacks on social media freedom continue,” Global Voices, May 6, 2022, https://globalvoices.org/2022/05/06/new-kazakhstan-world-press-freedom-….
- 133“ОБРАЩЕНИЕ заместителя Генерального Прокурора Республики Казахстан Ахметжанова М.М. в порядке статьи 31 Закона Республики Казахстан «О прокуратуре» [Address of the Deputy Prosecutor General of the Republic of Kazakhstan Akhmetzhanov M.M. in accordance with Article 31 of the Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan ‘On the Prosecutor's Office],” Prosecutor General’s Office of the Republic of Kazakhstan, April 29, 2019, http://prokuror.gov.kz/rus/novosti/press-releasy/obrashchenie-zamestite….
- 134“Petitioning mechanism discussed in parliament”, Vlast.kz, December 7, 2022, https://vlast.kz/novosti/52914-poradok-podaci-peticij-v-kazahstane-rass…
- 135Botagoz Aitzhanova, " В Казахстане планируют узаконить петиции [Online petitions to be legalized in Kazakhstan]," Tengri News, February 8, 2019, https://tengrinews.kz/kazakhstan_news/v-kazahstane-planiruyut-uzakonit-….
- 136Daniyar Moldabekov, " В Алматы отпустили нескольких задержанных активистов [Several activists detained in Almaty]," Vlast.kz, March 1, 2020, https://vlast.kz/novosti/37487-v-almaty-otpustili-neskolkih-zaderzannyh….
- 137Library of Congress,” Kazakhstan: Newly Adopted Constitutional Amendments Introduce New Governance Model and Strengthen Role of Parliament,” July 20, 2022, https://www.loc.gov/item/global-legal-monitor/2022-07-20/kazakhstan-new….
- 138Valerie Hopkins, “Kazakhstan Declares State of Emergency as Protests Over Fuel Prices Spread,” January 4, 2022, The New York Times, https://www.nytimes.com/2022/01/04/world/europe/kazakhstan-emergency-pr….
- 139" Большая часть журналистов не сможет получить аккредитацию": юрист комментирует приказ министра Абаева [Most journalists won't get accreditation]," Current Time TV, February 14, 2019, https://www.currenttime.tv/a/29770437.html.
- 140Ministry of Justice of the Republic of Kazakhstan and Institute of Legislation and Legal Information, “НАЦИОНАЛЬНЫЙ ПЛАН РАЗВИТИЯ СФЕРЫ ИНФОРМАЦИИ НА 2020-2022 ГОДЫ [National plan on development of information sphere for 2020-2022],” Adilet.Zan, April 7, 2020, http://adilet.zan.kz/rus/docs/P2000000183#z13.
- 141Constitutional Court of Kazakhstan, “Information on appeals to the Constitutional Court,” February 24, 2023, https://www.gov.kz/memleket/entities/ksrk/press/news/details/512377?lan….
- 142“КАК НЕ СЕСТЬ ЗА РЕПОСТ В КАЗАХСТАНЕ: ПРАВА И ЗАКОНЫ В ИНТЕРНЕТЕ [How not to situate a repost in Kazakhstan: rights and laws on the Internet],” Legal Media Center, June 4, 2020, http://lmc.kz/ru/news/kak-ne-sest-za-repost-v-kazahstane-prava-i-zakony….
- 143Bruce Pannier, “The Victims of Kazakhstan's Article 174,” Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, February 2, 2016, https://www.rferl.org/a/qishloq-ovozi-kazakhstan-article-174/27527738.h….
- 144Batyrhan Togaibaev, "Все ходим под статьей [We all go under the article]," Expert Kazakhstan, February 7, 2019, http://expertonline.kz/a15874/.
- 145“УГОЛОВНЫЙ КОДЕКС РЕСПУБЛИКИ КАЗАХСТАН [The Criminal Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan,]” Zakon, July 3, 2014, https://online.zakon.kz/document/?doc_id=31575252.
- 146“УГОЛОВНЫЙ КОДЕКС РЕСПУБЛИКИ КАЗАХСТАН [The Criminal Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan],” Zakon, July 3, 2014, https://online.zakon.kz/document/?doc_id=31575252.
- 147“Tokayev approves stricter punishment for the calls for riots”, Vlast.kz, March 17, 2023, https://vlast.kz/novosti/54339-tokaev-podpisal-popravki-uzestocausie-na…
- 148“В Казахстане декриминализировали клевету [Libel decriminalized in Kazakhstan],” Vlast.KZ, June 27, 2020, https://vlast.kz/novosti/40475-v-kazahstane-dekriminalizirovali-klevetu….
- 149" Декриминализация клеветы в Казахстане: минимальный штраф составит 424 тысячи тенге [Decriminalization of libel in Kazakhstan]," Informburo.kz, March 1, 2020, https://informburo.kz/novosti/dekriminalizaciya-klevety-v-kazahstane-mi….
- 150“УГОЛОВНЫЙ КОДЕКС РЕСПУБЛИКИ КАЗАХСТАН [The Criminal Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan],” Zakon, July 3, 2014, https://online.zakon.kz/document/?doc_id=31575252.
- 151“Elbasy law invalidation: Criminal code to be amended, too”, Informburo.kz, January 18, 2023, https://informburo.kz/novosti/otmena-zakona-o-elbasy-v-ugolovnyi-kodeks…
- 152Almaz Kumenov, “Kazakhstan adopts law to regulate untamed social media scene,” Eurasianet, July 12, 2023, https://eurasianet.org/kazakhstan-adopts-law-to-regulate-untamed-social….
- 153“Уголовный кодекс Республики Казахстан от 3 июля 2014 года № 226-V (с изменениями и дополнениями по состоянию на 07.07.2020 г.) [The Criminal Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated July 3, 2014 No. 226-V (with amendments and additions as of 07.07.2020)],” Zakon, https://online.zakon.kz/document/?doc_id=31575252#pos=2635;-37.
- 154Alisher Akhmetov, “Казахстанцев могут арестовать за чужие комментарии на их страницах в соцсетях [Kazakhstani citizens can be arrested for someone else's comments in social media],” Tengri News, October 21, 2015, https://tengrinews.kz/kazakhstan_news/kazahstantsev-mogut-arestovat-chu….
- 155“18 journalsts detained during riots,” Orda.kz Telegram channel, January 18, 2022, https://t.me/orda_kz/15455.
- 156"Journalist who wanted to protest against election results arrested." Azattyq.org, March 21, 2023, https://rus.azattyq.org/a/32327874.html.
- 157“Politician Altayev arrested for 15 days,” Vlast.kz, April 12, 2023, https://vlast.kz/novosti/54713-politika-nurzana-altaeva-arestovali-na-1….
- 158“Makhambet Abzhan sentenced to 9 years in prison,”, Adil Soz, February 3, 2023, http://www.adilsoz.kz/news/show/id/3943.
- 159Cheryl Reed, “Kazakhstan: Citizen journalist’s arrest decried by media rights advocates,” July 5, 2022, https://eurasianet.org/kazakhstan-citizen-journalists-arrest-decried-by…; https://www.rferl.org/a/kazakhstan-politician-altaev-jailed-oil-worker-…
- 160“Police came to journalist Makhambet Abzhan,” Vlast.kz, January 5, 2022, https://vlast.kz/novosti/48032-k-zurnalistu-mahambetu-abzanu-domoj-pris….
- 161“Abzhan resurfaced as witness in a criminal case,” Azattyq.org, January 20, 2022, https://rus.azattyq.org/a/31663732.html
- 162“Investigation into Abzhan case ongoing,” Adil Soz, January 31, 2022, http://www.adilsoz.kz/news/show/id/3516.
- 163Committee to Protect Journalists, “Kazakh financial police arrest investigative journalist Mikhail Kozachkov,” December 19, 2022, https://cpj.org/2022/12/kazakh-financial-police-arrest-investigative-jo….
- 164“Journalist Mikhail kozachkov detained,” Tengrinews.kz, December 18, 2022, https://tengrinews.kz/kazakhstan_news/zaderjan-jurnalist-mihail-kozachk….
- 165“Statement regarding arrest of Mokhail Kozachkov,” Vremya, December 18, 2022, https://time.kz/news/main/2022/12/18/zayavlenie-redaktsii-gazety-vremya….
- 166“Adil Soz worried by irregularities in M.Kozachkov case,” Vlast.kz, December 18, 2022, https://vlast.kz/novosti/53086-adil-soz-obespokoen-naruseniem-procedurn…
- 167“Kozachkov thinks the case against him is a personal revenge from an official,” Vlast.kz, December 19, 2022, https://vlast.kz/novosti/53103-kozackov-scitaet-svoe-presledovanie-licn….
- 168“Media community and human rights defenders ask Tokayev to release Kozachkov,” Vlast.kz, December 19, 2022, https://vlast.kz/novosti/53095-medijnoe-soobsestvo-i-pravozasitniki-pro….
- 169“Mikhail Kozachkov put under house arrest,” Vremya, February 18, 2023, https://time.kz/news/2023/02/18/mihail-kozachkov-pereveden-pod-domashni….
- 170“House of Nikolai Katchiev, a Bestobe activist, searched,” Vlast.kz, https://vlast.kz/novosti/52531-u-aktivista-iz-bestobe-nikolaa-katcieva-….
- 171“Activist from Stepnogorsk sentenced to 3 years of probation,” Vlast.kz, August 15, 2022, https://vlast.kz/novosti/51199-aktivistku-iz-stepnogorska-prigovorili-k….
- 172“Minister Sayasat Nurbek sued journalist for money,” The Village, September 5, 2022, https://www.the-village-kz.com/village/city/news-city/25207-ministr-say….
- 173“Общественный деятель Маргулан Боранбай водворен в ИВС,” Vlast.kz, October 2, 2020, https://vlast.kz/novosti/41923-obsestvennyj-deatel-margulan-boranbaj-vo….
- 174“Critics of Russian policies sentenced to 5 years in prison,” Azattyq.org, March 15, 2022, https://rus.azattyq.org/a/31753729.html
- 175“Kazakh Court Denies Appeals of Two Russia Critics against Prison Sentences,” Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, July 18, 2022, https://www.rferl.org/a/kazakhstan-russia-critics-appeal-denied/3194897….
- 176"Blogger Qaznews24 taken by police," Tengrinews.kz, May 15, 2021, https://tengrinews.kz/events/avtora-pablika-qaznews24-dostavili-v-polit….
- 177“Invented news, real criminal case,” Azarttyq.org, May 15, 2021, https://rus.azattyq.org/a/kazakhstan-qaznews24-tenirlan-yensebek-absurd….
- 178"Minister opined on the Qaznews24 case," Tengrinews.kz, May 26, 2021, https://tengrinews.kz/kazakhstan_news/ministr-vyiskazalas-o-dele-instag….
- 179“Minister of information commented upon the Yensebek case,” Azattyq.org, May 26, 2021, https://rus.azattyq.org/a/31274918.html.
- 180“Police terminated the case against Temirlan Yensebel’s satirical page,” Azattyq.org, September 15, 2022, https://rus.azattyq.org/a/32034634.html.
- 181Felix Corley, “Kazakhstan: Eight jailed for up to eight years,” Forum 18, August 5, 2019, http://www.forum18.org/archive.php?article_id=2498.
- 182Tatyana Kiseleva, "За разжигание розни в соцсетях стали судить все чаще — статистика [More and more people are being tried for inciting hatred in social networks – statistics]," 365info.kz, October 26, 2018, https://365info.kz/2018/10/za-razzhiganie-rozni-v-sotssetyah-stali-sudi….
- 183Andrei Grishin, “Борьба с экстремизмом в Казахстане: граждане не понимают за что их судят [Fighting Extremism in Kazakhstan: Citizens Don’t Know Why They’re Targeted],” CABAR, October 30, 2018, https://cabar.asia/ru/borba-s-ekstremizmom-v-kazahstane-grazhdane-ne-po….
- 184“Kazakhstan: Court Dubs Opposition Movement Extremist,” Eurasianet, March 13, 2018, https://eurasianet.org/kazakhstan-court-dubs-opposition-movement-extrem….
- 185“Парламент принял закон в пользу коррупционеров [Parliament passed a law in favor of corrupt officials],” Adil Soz, December 21, 2017, http://www.adilsoz.kz/news/show/id/2535.
- 186Almaz Kumenov, “Kazakhstan: Online Anonymity Ban in Force from April,” Eurasianet, February 2, 2018, https://eurasianet.org/kazakhstan-online-anonymity-ban-in-force-from-ap….
- 187Meyirim Smayil, “В МИК РК прокомментировали борьбу с VPN и анонимайзерами [MIC commented on their fight against VPNs and anonymizers],” Tengri News, March 14, 2017, https://tengrinews.kz/kazakhstan_news/v-mik-rk-prokommentirovali-borbu-….
- 188Official response by the Ministry of Information and Social Development to an information request.
- 189“A VPN service to appeal the blocking by Kazakhstan’s government.” Vlast.kz, March 14, 2023, https://vlast.kz/novosti/54286-zarubeznyj-vpn-servis-obzaluet-v-sude-bl….
- 190Katia Patin, “Kazakhstan shut down its internet. These programmers opened a backdoor,” Coda Story, January 27. 2022, https://www.codastory.com/authoritarian-tech/kazakhstan-shut-down-its-i….
- 191“Новые правила регистрации мобильных телефонов в Казахстане: все, что нужно знать [New Rules of Mobile Phone Registration in Kazakhstan],” Sputnik News, June 14, 2018, https://ru.sputniknews.kz/society/20180614/6021664/kazakhstan-registrac….
- 192Julia Sarachakova and Rashit Ilaysov, "Казахстанцы массово жалуются на отключение связи [Users complain of en masse disconnections]," Tengri News, October 24, 2019, https://tengrinews.kz/kazakhstan_news/kazahstantsyi-massovo-jaluyutsya-….
- 193Ibid.
- 194Vyacheslav Polovinko, “В Казахстане взошли свои яровые [Spring crops have sprung up in Kazakhstan],” Novaya Gazeta, November 2, 2018, https://novayagazeta.ru/articles/2018/11/02/78449-v-kazahstane-vzoshli-….
- 195Assem Zhapisheva, @zhapisheva, “Мне и нескольким журналистам сегодня тупо отключили симки [Me and several journalist today stupidly disabled SIM cards],” June 12, 2020, Twitter post, https://twitter.com/zhapisheva/status/1138842579833802755?s=21; Новости Молодежной сети наблюдателей, “Новости Молодежной сети наблюдателей “Next.kz” [News of the “Next.kz” Youth Oberserver Network],” June 10, 2019, Facebook post, https://perma.cc/8RAN-DFGG.
- 196“Казахстан ввел новые правила раздачи интернета в общественных местах [Kazakhstan introduced new rules for public points of internet access],” Digital.Report, March 16, 2016, https://digital.report/novyie-pravila-razdachi-interneta-v-obshhestvenn….
- 197Serikzhan Mauletbay, "За подключение к общественному Wi-Fi без SMS-регистрации грозит штраф [Connecting to public Wi-Fi without SMS-registration may cause penalty],” Tengri News, January 27, 2017, https://tengrinews.kz/internet/podklyuchenie-obschestvennomu-wi-fi-sms-….
- 198Daniyar Moldabekov, “Евразийский киберсоюз [Eurasian Cyberunion],” Vlast, February 19, 2019, https://vlast.kz/obsshestvo/31791-evrazijskij-kibersouz.html.
- 199“Activist Inga Imanbai reported the discovery of Hermit spy virus on her phone [in Kazakh],” Azattyq, June 27. 2022. https://rus.azattyq.org/a/31916498.html.
- 200Justin Albrecht and Paul Shunk, “Lookout Uncovers Hermit Spyware Deployed in Kazakhstan,” Lookout, June 16, 2022, https://www.lookout.com/blog/hermit-spyware-discovery.
- 201“After the January events, the authorities target activists with spy software,” Vlast.kz, June 24, 2022, https://vlast.kz/novosti/50539-s-nacalom-anvarskih-sobytij-vlasti-kazah…
- 202Miranda Patrucic and Vyacheslav Abramov, “Trust No One: Top Kazakh Oligarchs And Dozens of Government Officials May Have Been Spied On With Pegasus,” Organized Crime and Corruption Reporting Project (OCCRP),” July 23, 2021, https://www.occrp.org/en/the-pegasus-project/trust-no-one-top-kazakh-ol….
- 203Andrei Soshnikov, “Azerbaijan, Kazakhstan Rank As Standouts In Pegasus Spyware Investigation,” Current Time TV, July 28, 2021, https://en.currenttime.tv/a/azerbaijan-kazakhstan-rank-as-standouts-in-….
- 204“Oyan Kazkahstan activists received warnings that their phones might be wiretapped,” Vlast.kz, November 24, 2021, https://vlast.kz/novosti/47580-aktivisty-oyan-qazaqstan-polucili-podtve….
- 205Catherine Putz, “Kazakh Activists’ Phones Infected With Pegasus Spyware,” The Diplomat, December 10, 2021, https://thediplomat.com/2021/12/kazakh-activists-phones-infected-with-p….
- 206"Об утверждении технического регламента "Общие требования к телекоммуникационному оборудованию по обеспечению проведения оперативно-розыскных мероприятий, сбора и хранения служебной информации об абонентах [General requirements for telecommunication equipment to ensure the conduct of operational-search measures, collection and storage of official information about subscribers]," Tengri News, January 16, 2017, https://tengrinews.kz/zakon/komitet_natsionalnoy_bezopasnosti_respublik….
- 207“Большой брат хочет иметь удобные технологии для слежки [Big brother wants new technologies for surveillance],” Kazakhstan International Bureau for Human Rights and Rule of Law, November 23, 2018, https://bureau.kz/novosti/iz_drugikh_istochnikov/brat_khochet_imet_udob….
- 208“Утверждены единые Правила взаимодействия и централизованного управления сетями телекоммуникаций [Rules of interaction and centralized management of telecommunication networks],“ Kazinform, December 11, 2011, https://www.inform.kz/ru/utverzhdeny-edinye-pravila-vzaimodeystviya-i-c….
- 209Anur Tape, “Вот мы и получили официальное подтверждение об использовании DPI от Казахтелекома [So we received an office confirmation of the use of DPI from Kazahktelecom],” Yvision, March 2, 2012, https://yvision.kz/post/219289.
- 210Rabiga Dysengulova, “Можете не устанавливать - вице-министр о сертификате безопасностиp [Do Not Install - Vice minister commented on the security certificate]," Tengri News, July 19, 2019, https://tengrinews.kz/kazakhstan_news/mojete-ustanavlivat-vitse-ministr…
- 211“Никто не следит за пользователями,” Tengrinews.kz, December 7, 2020, https://tengrinews.kz/kazakhstan_news/nikto-sledit-polzovatelyami-minis….
- 212“Перед казахстанцами извинились за проблемы с Интернетом,” Tengrinews.kz, December 7, 2020, https://tengrinews.kz/kazakhstan_news/pered-kazahstantsami-izvinilis-za….
- 213Rabiga Dysengulova, "Специальный сертификат попросили установить на смартфоны казахстанцев [Special certificate needs to be installed on smartphones]," Tengri News, July 18, 2019, https://tengrinews.kz/internet/spetsialnyiy-sertifikat-poprosili-ustano…
- 214Rabiga Dysengulova, “Можете не устанавливать - вице-министр о сертификате безопасностиp [Do Not Install - Vice minister commented on the security certificate]," Tengri News, July 19, 2019, https://tengrinews.kz/kazakhstan_news/mojete-ustanavlivat-vitse-ministr…
- 215" Переписку казахстанцев, пароли и историю посещений сайтов КНБ хранить не собирается [NSC not to store correspondence, passwords and history of users]," Vlast.kz, July 26, 2019, https://vlast.kz/novosti/34516-perepisku-kazahstancev-paroli-i-istoriu-….
- 216"КНБ завершил тестирование сертификата безопасности [NSC finishes testing of the security certificate]," Tengri News, August 6, 2019, https://tengrinews.kz/kazakhstan_news/knb-zavershil-testirovanie-sertif….
- 217Catalin Cimpanu, “Apple, Google, and Mozilla block Kazakhstan’s HTTPS intercepting certificate,” Zdnet, August 21, 2019, https://www.zdnet.com/article/apple-google-and-mozilla-block-kazakhstan….
- 218“Apple, Google, Microsoft, and Mozilla ban Kazakhstan's MitM HTTPS certificate,” ZDNet, December 18, 2020, https://www.zdnet.com/article/apple-google-microsoft-and-mozilla-ban-ka….
- 219“Как и почему власти Казахстана отслеживают в Интернете критику в свой адрес? [How and why do the authorities of Kazakhstan monitor criticism on the Internet?].” Radio Azattyk, May 21, 2020, https://rus.azattyq.org/a/kazakhstan-information-security-government-cr….
- 220iMAS, “Most advanced monitoring system of mass media, social networks, blogs and web resources in Kazakhstan],” https://imas.kz/eng.html.
- 221“MIA purchased equipment that allow to identify social media users,” Tengrinews.kz, May 18, 2022, https://tengrinews.kz/kazakhstan_news/mvd-kupilo-oborudovanie-ustanovle…
- 222" В Алматы перед митингом задерживают активистов [Activists detained ahead of rally in Almaty]," Vlast.kz, March 1, 2020, https://vlast.kz/novosti/37484-v-almaty-pered-mitingom-zaderzivaut-akti….
- 223“Создавшего WhatsApp-группу "Небольшое насыха" мужчину осудили в Акмолинской области [WhatsApp group chat admin sentenced for extremism],” Tengri News, January 12, 2017, https://tengrinews.kz/kazakhstan_news/sozdavshego-whatsapp-gruppu-nebol…; “В Алматы активистов предупредили о недопустимости акций 6 июля [Activists in Almaty warned against unsanctioned rallies],” July 5, 2016, Radio Azattyq, http://rus.azattyq.org/a/27839704.html; Ali Askar, “Суд в Актобе вынес приговор по делу о пропаганде терроризма в WhatsApp'е [Aktobe court passed a sentence on terrorist propaganda in WhatsApp],” Radio Azattyq, August 11, 2016, https://rus.azattyq.org/a/27914406.html.
- 224http://adilet.zan.kz/rus/docs/V2000021693
- 225“On amendments and additions to some legislative acts of the Republic of Kazakhstan on the regulation of digital technologies,” http://adilet.zan.kz/rus/docs/Z2000000347.
- 226Tele2 Kazakhstan, “Exit Report on Ethics and Compliance,” https://www.tele2.com/globalassets/documents/sustainability/tele2-kz-ex….
- 227Ksenia Bondal, “Обязывает ли АИС и КНБ сотовых операторов создать систему прослушки? [Do AID and KNB oblige cellular operators to create a wiretapping system?],” Zakon, November 5, 2009, https://www.zakon.kz/top_news/152528-objazyvaet-li-ais-i-knb-sotovykh.h….
- 228“Правила оказания услуг доступа к сети Интернет от 30 декабря 2011 года № 1718 [Rules of rendering internet access services],” Media Law CA, http://medialawca.org/old/document/-11242.
- 229“Статья 637. Нарушение законодательства Республики Казахстан в области связи [Article 637.9.5 of the Administrative Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan],” Zakon, https://online.zakon.kz/Document/?doc_id=31577399#sub_id=6370000,
- 230Tele2 Kazakhstan, “Exit Report on Ethics and Compliance,” https://www.tele2.com/globalassets/documents/sustainability/tele2-kz-ex….
- 231Brett Cohen, Britanie Hall, and Charlie Wood, American Bar Association, “Data Localization Laws And Their Impact on Privacy, Data Security And the Global Economy,” Fall 2017, https://www.americanbar.org/content/dam/aba/publishing/antitrust_magazi…; Nigel Cory, “Cross Border Data Flows: Where are the barriers, and what do they cost?” ITIF, May 1, 2017, https://itif.org/publications/2017/05/01/cross-border-data-flows-where-….
- 232Aset Shyngyssov, Bakhytzhan Kadyrov, and Zhamilya Bilisbekova, Morgan Lewis, “Data Localization Laws: Overview (Kazakhstan),” May 29, 2019, https://www.morganlewis.com/-/media/files/publication/outside-publicati….
- 233“Зарубежным соцсетям выдвинут требования по размещению серверов в РК [Requirements for server placement in the Republic of Kazakhstan have been put forward for foreign social networks],” Profit, November 2, 2017, https://profit.kz/news/42724/Zarubezhnim-socsetyam-vidvinut-trebovaniya….
- 234“On approval of the Rules for registration, use and distribution of domain names in the space of the Kazakhstani segment of the Internet,” http://adilet.zan.kz/rus/docs/V1800016654.
- 235Rules: https://adilet.zan.kz/rus/docs/V2100022689.
- 236Article 637, Administrative Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan, accessed April 4, 2021.
- 237“Анонимные комментарии запретили: Назарбаев подписал закон [Anonymous comments are banned: Nazarbayev signed the law],” Tengri News, December 28, 2017, https://tengrinews.kz/kazakhstan_news/anonimnyie-kommentarii-zapretili-….
- 238“We’ve got the pig’s head,” Orda.kz, October 5, 2022, https://orda.kz/redakczii-orda-kz-podlozhili-svinyu-bukvalno
- 239Elmedia Telegram channel, January 13, 2023, accessed February 28, 2023, https://t.me/elmedia_kz/971
- 240“Journalist Dinara Yegeubayeva’s car set on fire in Almaty,” Azattyq, January 14, 2023, https://rus.azattyq.org/a/32223024.html.
- 241“Two cars of journalist Boreyko’s cameraman blown up,” Azattyq, February 20, 2023, https://rus.azattyq.org/a/32278946.html.
- 242“Apartment of journalist Boreyko’s glued in Almaty,” Azattyq.org, January 19, 2023, https://rus.azattyq.org/a/32229958.html.
- 243“Journalist Daniyar Moldabekov says he has been attacked,” Vlast.kz, February 22, 2023, https://vlast.kz/novosti/54017-zurnalist-daniar-moldabekov-soobsil-o-na….
- 244“Four accomplices of the organizer of attacks on journalists defined,” Vlast.kz, March 2, 2023, https://vlast.kz/novosti/54142-ustanovleny-cetvero-soobsnikov-organizat….
- 245“Seven suspects in attacks against journalists are under arrest,” Vlast.kz, March 7, 2023, https://vlast.kz/novosti/54187-semero-zaderzannyh-za-napadenia-na-zurna….
- 246“Coordinator of attacks on journalists detained in Almaty, MIA says,” Vlast.kz, February 28, 2023, https://vlast.kz/novosti/54108-v-almaty-zaderzan-koordinator-atak-na-zu…; “Person suspected of torching the car of Boreyko’s cameraman arrested,” Tengrinews.kz, February 23, 2023, https://tengrinews.kz/kazakhstan_news/arestovan-podozrevaemyiy-podjoge-….
- 247“18 people detained for crimes against journalists and bloggers in Kazakhstan,” Tengrinews.kz, February 21, 2023, https://tengrinews.kz/kazakhstan_news/18-zaderjali-prestupleniya-protiv….
- 248“Almaty police detained two suspects who broke windows in Elmedia office,” Vlast.kz, November 25, 2022, https://vlast.kz/novosti/52735-policia-almaty-zaderzala-dvuh-podozrevae….
- 249“Violence against journalists – without borders,” Vlast.kz, January 25, 2023, https://vlast.kz/obsshestvo/53594-nasilie-protiv-zurnalistov-bez-granic….
- 250“Tokayev ordered to investigate the attacks on Elmedia office,” Informburo.kz, November 25, 2022, https://informburo.kz/novosti/tokaev-porucil-rassledovat-slucai-napaden…; “Toqaev ordered to find masterminds behind crimes against journalists,” Tengrinews.kz, January 20, 2023, https://tengrinews.kz/kazakhstan_news/tokaev-poruchil-nayti-zakazchikov…; “Toqaev ordered to solve the crimes against journalists,” Kursiv, February 9, 2023, https://kz.kursiv.media/2023-02-09/zhnr-jurnalisti/.
- 251Committee to Protect Journalists, “Kazakhstan journalist Olesya Vertinskaya threatened, beaten,” July 22, 2022, https://cpj.org/2022/07/kazakhstan-journalist-olesya-vertinskaya-threat….
- 252"Journalists at protests. Chronicle of events 4-10 January. Add-ons,” Adil.soz, January 11, 2022, http://www.adilsoz.kz/news/show/id/3458; “Kazakhstan authorities block news sites, detain journalists during nationwide protests,” Committee to Protect Journalists, January 6, 2022, https://cpj.org/2022/01/kazakhstan-authorities-block-news-sites-detain-….
- 253“Kazakhstan authorities block news sites, detain journalists during nationwide protests,” Committee to Protect Journalists, January 6, 2022, https://cpj.org/2022/01/kazakhstan-authorities-block-news-sites-detain-….
- 254Filip Noubel, “How Kazakhstan's youth are forging their own national identity,” Global Voices, June 10, 2020, https://globalvoices.org/2020/06/10/how-kazakhstans-youth-are-forging-t….
- 255“Orda.kz DDoS’ed, starting last night,” Vlast.kz, July 22, 2022, https://vlast.kz/novosti/50917-izdanie-ordakz-soobsilo-o-ddos-atake-pro….
- 256UlysMedia Telegram Channel, July 28, 2022, accessed March 1, 2023, https://t.me/ulysmediatg/3887.
- 257Factcheck.kz Telegram channel, March 15, 2023, accessed May 23, 2023., https://t.me/factcheckkz/4658.
- 258“Kazakhtelecom confirms a DDoS attack on several Kazakh media,” Tengrinews.kz, September 25, 2022, https://tengrinews.kz/kazakhstan_news/kazahtelekome-podtverdili-ataku-i….
- 259“A number of Kazakhstani media reported on DDoS-attackes from abroad,” Tengrinews.kz, September 25, 2022, https://tengrinews.kz/kazakhstan_news/ryad-kazahstanskih-smi-zayavili-o….
- 260UlysMedia Telegram Channel, October 7, 2022, accessed March 1, 2023, https://t.me/ulysmediatg/4664.
- 261KazTAG Telegram Channel, October 7, 2022, accessed March 1, 2023, https://t.me/kaztag_tg/6998.
- 262UlysMedia Telegram Channel, January 18, 2023, accessed March 1, 2023, https://t.me/ulysmediatg/5506.
- 263Factcheck.kz Telegram channel, March 15, 2023, accessed May 23, 2023, https://t.me/factcheckkz/4658.
- 264“STS notes large-scale attacks on Kaznet,” Tengrinews.kz, September 25, 2022, https://tengrinews.kz/kazakhstan_news/gts-fiksiruet-masshtabnyie-ddos-a….
- 265“Musin on attacks against Kaznet: This is definitely from abroad,” Tengrinews.kz, October 4, 2022, https://tengrinews.kz/kazakhstan_news/eto-tochno-s-vneshnego-kontura-mu….
- 266“20 million cyberattacks repelled in Kazakhstan,” Tengrinews.kz, October 6, 2022, https://tengrinews.kz/kazakhstan_news/otrajeno-20-millionov-atak-na-kaz….
- 267“They want to sow chaos – Toqaev comments about attacks on Kaznet,” Tengrinews.kz, September 30, 2022, https://tengrinews.kz/kazakhstan_news/namerenyi-poseyat-smutu-tokaev-pr…
- 268“Slomat Kaznet,” Vlast.kz, November 7, 2022, https://vlast.kz/obsshestvo/52416-slomat-kaznet.html
- 269“Foreign cyberspies got inside the government computers,” Tengrinews.kz, March 7, 2023, https://tengrinews.kz/kazakhstan_news/inostrannyie-kibershpionyi-pronik….