Dokument #1231586
IRB – Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada (Autor)
When Major General Siad Barre assumed
power, one of the goals he proclaimed for the nation was the
elimination of Somali tribalism, which he believed constituted a
major obstacle to national unity and development. [ ENDNOTES: I.M.
Lewis, A Modern History of Somalia: Nation and State in the Horn
of Africa, (Boulder: Westview Press, 1988), pp.221-223., David
D. Laitin and Said S. Samatar, Somalia: Nation in Search of a
State, (Boulder: Westview Press, 1987), pp.92-94.] Despite his
vitriolic attacks on clan affiliation and on nepotism, however, the
President has been accused of surrounding himself with kinsmen of
three particular clans of the Darood clan-family: his own Marehan
clan, his mother's Ogaden clan, and the Dulbahante clan of his
son-in-law. Many critics maintain that while this clan-based
political alliance, code-named MOD, has provided the President with
a reliable power base that offers external as well as internal
security, it has had the effect of perpetuating and exacerbating
clannism in Somalia. [ibid.]
Despite the common commitment of the
Ethiopian and Somali regimes to military socialism, Siad Barre had
reportedly found the "liberation" of the Ogaden crucial to the
legitimacy of his rule. The majority of Ogaden Somalis belong to
the Ogadeen clan, one of the three leading clans in the power
structure of the Siad Barre government. By playing a significant
role in Siad Barre's tribal coalition, the Ogadeen clan saw the
liberation of the Ogaden region as the highest goal for the Somali
government. [David D. Laitin and Said S. Samatar, Somalia:
Nation in Search of a State (Boulder: Westview Press, 1987), p.
140. ]
Siad Barre's war against Ethiopia in
1977-78 had kept the country briefly united around the long-held
dream of "Greater Somalia", which would have incorporated the
ethnic Somalis in the Ogaden. Nevertheless, Somalia's humiliating
defeat in the war and the resulting economic collapse were soon
added to the pre-war silent disenchantment with Siad Barre's
autocratic regime. Somalis shifted their priorities to domestic
politics, and open dissent and organized opposition to the
government emerged. [Samatar, pp. 137-139.]
In 1986, a flurry of accelerated promotions
and a cabinet reshuffle consolidated the Marehan position in the
army and strengthened their control of the Ministry of Defence.
[I.M. Lewis, A Modern History of Somalia, Nation and State in
the Horn of Africa, (Boulder: Westview Press, 1987), p.252.] It
was estimated in 1987, that half the senior officer corps belonged
to the President's clan (Marehan) or the related Marehan, Ogaden
and Dulbahante clans.
On 4 June 1984, the BBC Summary of World
Broadcasts reported on the Cabinet reshuffle within the Somali
Government. Adan Abdullahi Nur was named Deputy Minister of Defence
on 31 May 1984. [ Keesing's Record of World Events, vol.
XXXIII, (London: Longman Publishing Group), April 1987, p.35042.]
It was not until the Cabinet reshuffle of 22 December 1987 that
Maj.-Gen. Adan Abdullahi Nur, was appointed to the post of Minister
of Defence. [Keesing's Record of World Events, vol.XXXIV
(London: Longman Publishing Group), July 1988, p. 36004.; BBC
Summary of World Broadcasts, 24 December 1987.] Several sources use
the Defence Minister's nick name, Adan Gabiyow, meaning poet. [BBC
Summary of World Broadcasts, 8 February 1988.] Africa
Confidential, 20 January 1989, reports that there was a noted
rise in the number of the military elite from the Ogadeni clan,
under the leadership of Somali Defence Minister Major-General Adan
Abdullah Nuur Gabiyu. [Africa Confidential, (London:
Miramoor Publications, 20 July 1989).] Within the military there
are separate units staffed by officers predominantly from specific
clan groups. According to Africa Confidential, 23 September
1988, there were allegations that units made up of Ogadeni officers
were continuously given front line attack duties, while Marehan
officers were the first to leave the Hargeisa area when the
fighting started. [ibid. 23 September 1988.]
The Tuutaley, "the camouflaged ones", a
special military unit run by the president's son, Maslah Mohamed
Said Barre, is made up of Marehan officers and actually holds the
day-to-day power in Mogadishu. ["Somali: Generals Fall Out",
Africa Confidential, 23 September 1988.] The same article
further states that the military police is made up mainly of
Marehan members, with Brig.-Gen. Uthman Ahmed Uthman, a Marehan, as
its new deputy. Uthman Ahmed Uthman is a close relative of the
president and a former commander of the Criminal Investigation
Department (CID). [ibid.]
In its effort to maintain power, the ruling
family has been trying to get other clans involved in the fighting
through the creation of clan militias. The fluidity of these clan
relationships during the present conflict, makes it difficult to
pinpoint any movement as anything but temporary. "Somalia: Showdown
in the North", an article in the 29 July 1988 issue of Africa
Confidential, explains in detail the complex relationship that
the different clans have towards each other.
In the complicated clannism that makes up
Somali politics, President Siad Barre has recently ended his
long-held alliance with the Ogaden clan. [ "Disintegrating Tribal
Alliance", Africa Research Bulletin, (Nr. Crediton: Africa
Research Ltd., 15 September 1989), pp. 9390-9391.] Mogadishu radio
reported on 1 February 1989, that a government reshuffle had
resulted in Adan Abdullahi Nur being moved from the Ministry of
Defence to become the Minister of Information and Tourism. [ BBC
Summary of World Broadcasts, 1 February 1989.]
The President of Somalia announced further
changes to his government (on 21 April 1989) with the appointment
of Adan Abdullahi Nur (formerly the Minister of Information and
Tourism) as the Minister in the President's Office responsible for
Social Affairs. [BBC Summary of World Broadcasts, 24 April 1989.]
However, on 24 July 1989 a statement issued by the President's
Office reported that Adan Abdullahi Nur had "been relieved" of his
post as Minister in the Office of the President. The reason
disclosed in the official statement was that both Adan Abdullahi
Nur and Muhammad Abdullah Bacadleh, also a Minister in the
President's Office, had "been accused of acts which threatened the
sovereignty, unity, security and cohesion of...the Somali people".
In addition they had been relieved of their duties as members of
the People's Assembly and Adan Abdullahi Nur had been sacked from
the Party Central Committee and had his rank as a major-general in
the armed forces taken away. [BBC Summary of World Broadcasts, 26
July 1989.]
The Africa Confidential, reports
that Adan Abdullahi Nur, an Ogadeni, was arrested in July 1989. As
a result, Ogadeni soldiers in Kismayo, who had mutinied in March
1989 in protest against the demotion of the Minister of Defence,
formed the Somali Patriotic Movement (SPM) under the leadership of
Col. Bashir Ali Bililqo, Adan Gabiyow's son-in-law. The government
has rejected Ogadeni demands, including the release of Adan
Abdullahi Nur. [ "Somalia: The End In Sight For Siad", Africa
Confidential, (London: Miramoor Publications Ltd., 8 September
1989), pp.4-5.]
Hundreds of people are reported to have
died in southern Somalia in the first two weeks of October 1989, as
government troops launched assaults on territory controlled by the
SPM. [Africa Research Bulletin, (Nr. Crediton: Africa
Research Ltd., 15 November 1989), pp.9457-9456. ] It is reported
that the SNM and the SPM have issued a joint communique announcing
their adoption of "a unified stance on internal and external
political policy" and their decision to cooperate militarily.
[Africa Research Bulletin, vol.26 No.11, (Nr. Crediton:
Africa Research Ltd., 15 December 1989), pp.9496-9497.] The call
for government troops to join them has reportedly resulted in the
defection of several officers as well as troops to the rebel
movements. [ibid.] The SPM also assert that local nomads have been
more willing to join their movement after the army reportedly
killed 35 civilians on 20 September 1989. [ibid.]
Attached please find excerpts from the
following documents:
"Kenyan Policemen Killed", Africa Research Bulletin, London:
Africa Research, 15 October 1989, p.9425.
"Somali Democratic Republic", Africa Research Bulletin,
London: Africa Research, 15 September 1989, pp. 9389-9391.
"Somali Democratic Republic: Fighting Flares", Africa Research
Bulletin, London: Africa Research, 15 November 1989,
pp.9457.
"Somalia: An Update on Human Rights Developments Since Mid-July",
News from Africa Watch, Washington: Human Rights Watch, 22
September 1989, pp.9-11.