Dokument #1140422
IRB – Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada (Autor)
2. In Djibouti there are two main ethnic groups, the Issa, who are
of Somali origin, and the Afars who are of Ethiopian origin.
[The Europa World Year Book 1989, (London: Europa
Publications Ltd.., 1989), p. 881.] Since the early 1960s, there
has been much tension between the two groups. [ibid.]
In 1975 about 550 Eritrean refugees arrived
in Djibouti and have been living in the Djiboutiville slum of
Balbella. The United Nations High Commission for Refugees (UNHCR)
began assisting these refugees in 1978. There were several thousand
Ethiopian Afars who sought refuge in Djibouti in 1976 and were
afforded assistance from the local population and the French
government. Later in 1978, they began to receive UNHCR assistance
at Dikhil camp. Reports that some of the Afar refugees were
involved in armed opposition against the Ethiopian government had
created much tension between the local population and the refugees
in Djibouti. [ "Country Reports on Five Key Asylum Countries in
Eastern and Southern Africa", Migration News, (Geneva:
International Catholic Migration Commission, 1987), pp. 24-25.]
The largest group of Ethiopians to enter
Djibouti were Ogaden war refugees between 1977-79. Most of these
refugees were ethnic Somali. [ibid. p. 26] There are unconfirmed
reports that some Ethiopians who attempted to enter Djibouti
through Afar lands, were killed by local tribesmen. However, the
majority of the war refugees were placed in 2 UNHCR camps; Sabieh
and Dikhil. [ibid. p. 26]
According to the UNHCR, about 1,800 urban
Ethiopians entered Djibouti in an attempt to avoid military
conscription, political persecution and the lack of economic
opportunities. They are living clandestinely in Djibouti. This
group, known as "political refugees", must qualify for refugee
status on an individual basis. [ibid. p. 26]
Between 1984 and 1985 about 10,000
displaced drought victims were placed into As Eyla camp. The
Djibouti government did not consider this group as refugees. There
was minimal assistance provided at the camp and in 1985, it was
closed down entirely. This was viewed as the pivotal point in
Djibouti's change of attitude towards the situation in the country.
An initially sympathetic attitude in the 1970s was eventually
transformed into a sense of frustration at the continued burden of
refugee care. [Ibid. p.26.]
In April 1984 the Djiboutian and Ethiopian
governments agreed on a voluntary repatriation program for
Ethiopian refugees. The UNHCR was charged with overseeing the
program. At that time, there were approximately 35,000 refugees in
Djibouti. [The Europa World Year Book 1989, p.881.] By
December 1984 it was estimated that 16,000 had returned to
Ethiopia. [ibid.]
UNHCR staff, numerous non-government
organizations (NGO) staff and refugees speaking off-the-record,
suggest that the repatriation programme was not entirely voluntary.
It was suspected that the government appointed head of Ali Sabieh
camp pressured and coerced the refugees through arrests,
imprisonment and threats to encourage them to return to Ethiopia.
[Migration News, p. 26.] "UN Body Accused of Failing
Refugees" in Times of London,3 February 1987, also addresses
the issue of forced repatriation.
There are an estimated 50-150,000 illegal
aliens in Djibouti, and their presence exacerbates the sixty
percent unemployment rate in Djibouti. [U.S. Committee for
Refugees, Beyond the Headlines: Refugees in the Horn of
Africa, (Washington, January 1988), p. 26.] The refugees and
the illegal immigrants are often seen as one and the same by the
government, the media and the general public. [Migration
News, p. 26.] Therefore complaints regarding the rising crime
rate, unemployment, deteriorating government services and other
social problems are directed against both groups of foreigners
indiscriminately. [ibid.] Fear of being recognized as foreigners
keeps many refugees from utilizing government services; schools and
health clinics. [Migration News, p. 28.]
The government routinely orders round-ups
called "toughs", where the police detain aliens for deportation,
but permit those who claim to be refugees to present their Djibouti
government issued refugee registration cards. [U.S. Department of
State, Country Reports on Human Rights Practices for 1988,
(Washington: U.S. Department of State, 1989), p.98.] In one
incident in 1987, at least four persons who had been granted
refugee status were deported to Ethiopia, along with approximately
100 illegal aliens, for demonstrating against the strict
application of the Convention definition and the denial of refugee
status to those who could not individually prove "persecution".
[Beyond the Headlines, pp.30-31.] Amnesty International
reports that seven Ethiopians with refugee status were deported in
this incident in June 1987. [Amnesty International Report
1988, p. 37.]
The recurrence of drought and the political
situation in Ethiopia caused some refugees to return to Djibouti,
and by June 1987 the number of official refugees was 17,200.
[The Europa World Year Book 1989, p.881.] In mid-1986, the
Djibouti government resumed pressure on Ethiopian refugees to
return home. It issued a circular advising the refugees that
Djibouti did not have the resources to facilitate the refugees
indefinitely; that permanent resettlement was no longer an option,
that Ethiopia had granted them amnesty to return and that the UNHCR
would assist them. [ C. Legum, ed. African Contemporary Record,
Annual Survey ans Documents 1986-1987., vol. X1X, (New York:
Africana Publishing Company., 1987), p. B280]
Originally there were two main camps in
Djibouti; Dikhil and Ali Sabieh. Ali Sabieh camp was closed down in
1986 and the refugees were moved to Dikhil because the government
found the former camp to have been too easily accessible to
potential refugees across the border. ["Djibouti Moves Its
Refugees", New African, May 1986.] All refugees were ordered
to sign up by September 1, 1986. Food and water services were
terminated at Dikhil camp at the end of 1986, when several dozen
Ethiopians were forcibly deported to Ethiopia. Officially
recognized refugees, mostly of Somali origin, were permitted to
reside at Obock camp. [African Contemporary Record,
p.B281.]
This new camp is in an isolated and inaccessible part of Afar
lands. [New African, May 1986.] From 1986 to 1987 the
Djibouti government estimated that 2000 refugees were voluntarily
repatriated to Ethiopia. [The Europa World Year Book 1989,
p. 881.]
The Djibouti government announced tighter
controls on border crossings and identification papers in 1987.
Ethiopia and Djibouti agreed in February 1988 to control border
movements. [ibid.]