Dokument #1134176
IRB – Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada (Autor)
1) The status of the Ogaden area, regarded
by the Ethiopian government as belonging to its eastern region, has
been disputed by the successive governments of Somalia since that
country's independence in 1960. Somalia regards the Ogaden as a
Somali-inhabited region under Ethiopian colonization, whereas
Ethiopia takes the position that it is an integral part of its
territory. [ENDNOTES
Alan J. Day, ed., Border and Territorial Disputes (London:
Longman Group UK Ltd., 1987), pp. 126-132. ]
As the Horn of Africa observed, "sandwiched between two
competing claimants to the barren, drought-stricken region, the
mainly nomadic population has been all but decimated by the rivalry
over who will control them and their land." [ "Ogaden: The Land But
Not The People", Horn of Africa, Vol. 4, No.1, 1981, pp.
42-45.] Thus, while the people inhabiting the Ogaden region are
predominantly from ethnic Somali origin and have deep-rooted
social, cultural and economic ties with Somalia, their land is
legally part of Ethiopia. [ Ibid.]
In 1975, the Western Somali Liberation
Front (WSLF) was founded with the aim of uniting the Ogaden region
with the Somali Republic. Backed by regular Somali forces, the WSLF
launched a major offensive against Ethiopian government troops in
1977 that led to a direct year-long battle between Ethiopia and
Somalia. During the Ogaden war and particularly following Somalia's
defeat, hundreds of thousands of refugees from the Ogaden fled to
Somalia and Djibouti for fear of the Ethiopian government's
reprisals. [ United States Committee for Refugees, Beyond the
Headlines: Refugees in the Horn of Africa, Washington, 1988, p.
22.]
Precise details of the Ethiopian
government's current treatment of the ethnic Somalis in the Ogaden
are not known to IRBDC. In general, ever since Ethiopia entered a
period of revolutionary change in 1974, thousands of people have
been arrested and imprisoned on suspicion of association with
dissident movements, including the liberation fronts such as the
WSLF. [ George Thomas Kurian, ed., Encyclopedia of the Third
World,
3rd ed., Vol. 1 (New York: Facts on File Publications, Inc., 1987),
p. 665. ] In principle, the 1987 Ethiopian Constitution provides
for the equality of all Ethiopians irrespective of nationality and
religion, among others, and stipulates that such equality is to be
ensured through equal participation in political, economic, social
and cultural affairs. [ Albert P. Blaustein and Gisbert H. Flanz,
eds., Constitutions of the Countries of the World: The People's
Democratic Republic of Ethiopia (Dobbs Ferry, New York: Oceana
Publications, Inc, 1988), Part 2, Chapter 7, Article 35.] In
practice, however, this equality is not ensured. For example,
almost all senior government and political figures are Christians,
although approximately 50 percent of the country's population is
Muslim (ethnic Somalis in the Ogaden are
all followers of Islam). [ U. S. Department of State, Country
Reports on Human Rights Practices for 1988 (Washington: U. S.
Government Printing Office, 1989), p. 118]
2) As discussed above, persons born in the
Ogaden in 1969, or before and after, are considered to be Ethiopian
nationals of ethnic Somali origin. Also, according to the Ethiopian
Constitution, "any person with both or one parent of Ethiopian
citizenship is an Ethiopian." [ Constitution, Part 2,
Chapter 6, Article 31.]
3) Leaving Ethiopia illegally is a serious
offence reportedly punishable by five to 25 years' imprisonment or,
in exceptional cases, by death. [ Kurian, p. 665.] Illegally
leaving or attempting to leave Ethiopia is considered to be an act
of treason against the country, and the Constitution states that
"treason against the Motherland is the gravest crime committed
against the people, entailing severe punishment". [
Constitution, Part 2, Chapter 7, Article 53(2).] According
to Amnesty International's 1988 Report, many Ethiopians were
reportedly imprisoned for attempting to flee the country and some
relatives of those who left the country for political reasons were
arrested in reprisal. [ Amnesty International, Amnesty
International Report 1988 (London: Amnesty International
Publications, 1988), p. 38.]