Dokument #1126605
IRB – Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada (Autor)
According to Najma Chowdhury, author of
"Bangladesh: Gender Issues and Politics in a Patriarchy,"
[A] discussion of the informal political
process [must] include[] a review of women's organizations whose
aim is to raise women's status, create awareness of women's issues,
and build platforms from which women's demands can be made. In
seeking to find a public voice with which to demand change, these
ostensibly nonpolitical organizations do in fact venture into the
realm of politics. ... Women's voluntary groups ... provide women
an important venue for making their demands known and for
transforming the so-called social issues into matters of public
policy (1994, 95).
In addition to raising awareness of women's
issues and articulating them in a public forum, women's
organizations can also serve as a training ground for future women
political leaders (Journal of Social Studies 1985, 50).
One observer has identified three phases in
the development of women's organizations in Bengal and Bangladesh
(Jahan 1975, 23). The first period, 1910-1947, was led by women
from the Calcutta-based landlord class who questioned strict
observance of purdah and demanded improvements in female school
enrolment and literacy (ibid.; Journal of Social Studies 1985, 42).
The movement apparently disbanded in the 1930s and 1940s when
leadership passed to a group of less committed Muslim literary
women (Jahan 1975, 23; Journal of Social Studies 1985, 42).
In the second period, 1947-1970, a number
of women's organizations were established (Jahan 1975, 24; Ahmed
1987, 7). In general these organizations were urban-based, were led
and supported by educated middle-class and elite women, focused on
charity and social welfare activities, and tended to function "more
as social clubs than as political organizations designed to achieve
women's rights" (Jahan 1982b, 13; Quader 1987, 162; Chowdhury 1994,
102). They worked to raise awareness of women's issues, although
their orientation was toward education and legal reform, areas of
concern mainly to middle-class women (Jahan 1982b, 13; Journal of
Social Studies 1985, 45).
Foremost among the women's organizations that developed during this period was the All Pakistan Women's Association (APWA), which was founded in 1949 (Ahmed 1987, 7; Islam 1979, 352; Jahan 1975, 24), and eventually had branches in all districts and subdivisions (ibid.). The APWA membership and leadership were drawn from the urban elite, generally the wives of powerful military, administrative and political figures (ibid.; Ahmed 1987, 7; Journal of Social Studies 1985, 44; Islam 1979, 353). Membership in the APWA was linked to the status of one's husband, not to education, organizing ability or commitment to a particular cause (ibid.). Although the APWA functioned primarily as a neighbourhood "social club of elite women" that arranged "social and cultural get-togethers" (Jahan 1975, 24; Journal of Social Studies 1985, 44), and its activities were largely "limited to supporting welfare and charity-oriented programs through bazaars, fashion shows, and cultural evenings" (Ahmed 1987, 7; Journal of Social Studies 1985, 44; Islam 1979, 353), one notable political success was the promulgation of the 1961 Muslim Family Laws Ordinance, which significantly improved women's legal status (ibid.; Journal of Social Studies 1985, 45). After independence (1971) the Bangladesh APWA was reconstituted as the Bangladesh Mahila Samity (BMS), which continued to offer education and skills training programmes to destitute women (Ahmed 1987, 7; United Nations 8 Apr. 1993, 22; Encyclopedia of Women's Associations Worldwide 1993, 47).
At least nine other women's
organizations were formed in Dhaka in the 1950s and 1960s, and
most, including Gandaria Mahila Samity (1950), Wari Mahila Samity
(1954) and Purana Paltan Ladies Club, were similar to the APWA;
neighbourhood women's clubs of "'enlightened ladies' ... want[ing]
to improve the socioeconomic condition of lower-middle-class and
poor women," but demonstrating little interest in political action
(Jahan 1975, 26; Ahmed 1987, 7). Similar organizations include the
Women's Voluntary Association (WVA), the Lionesses, the Rotary,
Zonta International, Qaibandha, Azimpur Ladies Club and the Young
Women's Christian Associations (ibid., 9; Jahan 1975, 27; Chowdhury
1994, 102).
A second category of women's groups,
professional organizations for business and career women, was
established in the 1960s and 1970s. These organizations also were
urban-based, but were well-funded and had specific goals and
programmes that appealed to westernized career women (Ahmed 1987,
9; Jahan 1975, 27). Among these groups are the Business and Career
Women's Club, Bangladesh Federation of Business and Professional
Women, Bangladesh Federation of University Women, and Bangladesh
National Women Lawyers Association (ibid.; Ahmed 1987, 9; Kabeer
1991, 138; Encyclopedia of Women's Associations Worldwide 1993,
47-48; United Nations 8 Apr. 1993, 21-22). In general, these
organizations also draw their membership and leadership from the
elite and have a social service or welfarist orientation (ibid.;
Chowdhury 1994, 102).
The third phase in the development of
women's organizations began in the post-liberation period (Jahan
1975, 28). Three new types of women's organizations emerged in
these years.
The first category, although not comprising
women's groups specifically, consists of NGOs that promote women's
emancipation with action-oriented development initiatives,
including skills training, health services, cooperatives and
provision of credit for self-employment (Kabeer 1991, 138; Ahmed
1987, 9). Among these organizations are Karika (Bangladesh
Handicrafts Cooperative Federation), Shoptogram Nari Swanirvar
Parishad (Shoptogram Women's Self-Reliant Council), Swanirbhar
Women's Program, Bangladesh Rural Advancement Committee (BRAC),
Proshikha, Nijeri Kori and several others (ibid.; United Nations 8
Apr. 1993, 28-29; Kabeer 1991, 138). Primarily rural-based
grassroots organizations, these NGOs "represent an important break"
with urban-based women's organizations because they reach out to
the vast majority of the population, focus on the long-term
empowerment of the poor and landless rather than just their
immediate needs, and employ a "collective rather than individual
concept of empowerment" (ibid.). For example, Proshikha organizes
landless and poor rural men and women into groups and encourages
them to use their own savings to fund income-generating schemes
United Nations 8 Apr. 1993, 28-29). These activities are
supplemented by a revolving loan fund that provides preferential
terms and interest rates to women (ibid.). Other groups have
similar types of rural loan and credit programmes (ibid.).
The second category consists of research
and/or women's consciousness-raising organizations. In general
these organizations are "middle class, ... actively pro-feminist"
and view the situation of women in Bangladesh as basically a
political issue (Chowdhury 1994, 102). Because of their interest
articulation and activist orientation, however, they appeal only to
"limited sectors of society" (ibid.)
One of the oldest and most prominent of
these groups is Women for Women, a research and study group that
was established in 1973 by a group of women academics. It seeks to
raise awareness of women's issues, influence public policy and
foster "communication and exchange between women's groups and the
government" (Encyclopedia of Women's Associations Worldwide 1993,
48; Chowdhury 1994, 102; United Nations 8 Apr. 1993, 21). Women for
Women also holds workshops and seminars, offers training in social
science research methods, and has produced about 30 books and 4
documentary films on women's issues (ibid.; Ahmed 1987, 9;
Encyclopedia of Women's Associations Worldwide 1993, 48). A 1993
source puts the organization's membership at 46, its staff at 5 and
its budget at about US$30,000 (ibid.).
Another such group is UBINIG (Policy
Research for Development Alternatives), a left-leaning organization
of about 120 researchers, mainly women, founded in 1984 (Ahmed
1987, 9; Women's Movements of the World 1988, 19-20). Opposed to
"patriarchy and imperialism" and "dedicated to the formulation of
alternative development policies" (ibid.), UBINIG is active in
bio-medical research issues such as contraception, sterilization
and drug testing, export-oriented industries and their impact on
women workers, community and preventive health care and violence
against women (ibid.). The organization has several publications
and is affiliated to international organizations with similar aims
and objectives (ibid.). A similar organization is Nari Shonghoti
(Women's Solidarity), established in 1985 by a group of young
social scientists and affiliated to the Asian Research and Action
Network (Ahmed 1987, 9; Kabeer 1991, 138).
Naripokkho (pro-woman) is a group of about
200 professional and career women "committed to the feminist
philosophy and democratic principles" that works to raise
consciousness among women through weekly meetings and monthly
workshops (Ahmed 1987, 9; United Nations 8 Apr. 1993, 21).
Naripokkho seeks to raise awareness in society about sexism,
women's legal rights and dowry problems, and organizes women to
collectively pressure the government on public policy issues
(ibid.; Ahmed 1987, 9). For example, Naripokkho was in the
forefront of opposition to the Eighth Amendment, the Ershad
regime's successful effort in 1988 to have Islam declared the state
religion (ibid.; Kabeer 1991, 139).
The third type of organization to emerge in the post-liberation period is the women's front or umbrella organization, of which there are several. One of the earliest was the Jatiya Mahila Sangstha (JMS, or National Women's Organization), a state-directed organization established in early 1976 under the auspices of the Ministry of Women's Affairs (Chowdhury 1994, 102; Islam 1979, 360-61). As originally envisioned, the Sangstha was to be a grassroots organization with branches in every thana (smallest administrative unit) that would mobilize women, represent their interests and "ensure their social, economic, educational and cultural welfare" through various research, motivational, vocational training and education programmes (ibid., 360; Chowdhury 1994, 102). However, it is not clear how successful the Sangstha was in attaining its goals. Despite setting up branches at the district and subdivision levels, nearly three years after founding it had still to open offices in half of the thanas (Islam 1979, 360). Further, because of the Sangstha's close ties to the state it is under government administrative and budgetary control and at one time the national chairman and executive committee were all government appointees it has often supported the government's policies related to women, but "its contribution to gender awareness and the articulation of women's needs and concerns has been marginal" (Chowdhury 1994, 102-03; Islam 1979, 361).
There have also been several autonomous
umbrella organizations. Nari Nirjaton O Shamajik Onachar Protirodh
Committee (committee for the prevention of social injustice and
violence against women), established in 1985, is a federation of
about 100 organizations fighting violence against women (Ahmed
1987, 9). Bangladesh Nari Odhikar Andolon (Bangladesh Women's
Rights Movement), a similar organization founded in 1984, is
"committed to upholding women's rights against social and economic
exploitation" (ibid.). Information on the current circumstances of
these specific organizations is not available among the sources
consulted, but Chowdhury, who describes the early 1980s as years of
"tentative coalition building," states that "such alliances proved
short lived" (1994, 103).
The late 1980s proved more favourable to
the establishment of a lasting, broad-based coalition of women's
groups (ibid.). In preparation for a proposed world conference on
women to be held in Moscow in June 1987, about 20 Bangladeshi
women's organizations established a national committee to work out
a common programme (ibid.). Later the same year 14 of these groups
formed the Oikkyo Baddha Nari Samaj (United Women's Forum), which
in February 1988 presented a 17-point programme demanding equal
rights for women on a number of legal, economic and social issues
(ibid.). The forum coordinated opposition to the previously
mentioned 1988 Eighth Amendment Bill, participated in several
programmes during the final stages of the democracy movement in
1990, and during the transitional period following Ershad's fall
submitted to the acting president a list of demands from its 1988
platform (ibid.).
At last count the number of United Women's
Forum member organizations had increased to about 20 (ibid.), of
which the Mahila Parishad (Women's Council) is the largest, with an
estimated membership in 1991 of about 35,000, strongest and most
politically active (ibid., 103-04, 111; Jahan 1975, 28; Ahmed 1987,
7; Kabeer 1991, 137; New Left Review Mar.-Apr. 1988, 119).
According to Chowdhury, Mahila Parishad's objectives and strategies
typify those of the current group of women's organizations that are
fighting gender discrimination, raising awareness of women's issues
and organizing women politically (1994, 104).
Mahila Parishad was founded in 1969-70 by
progressive APWA women, Awami League women and Communist Party of
Bangladesh (CPB) activists in the midst of the student movements,
general political unrest and rising nationalism that culminated in
the 1971 war of liberation (Journal of Social Studies 1985, 47;
Chowdhury 1994, 104; New Left Review Mar.-Apr. 1988, 119; Kabeer
1991, 137). Established to mobilize women for the liberation
struggle, following independence Mahila Parishad began working for
the political and socioeconomic advancement of women (United
Nations 8 Apr. 1993, 21; Ahmed 1987, 7). Mahila Parishad has fought
for the rights of female factory and office workers, pressured the
government to implement a 10 per cent quota for women in government
employment and has opposed the practice of reserved seats for women
in parliament (Kabeer 1991, 137; New Left Review Mar.-Apr. 1988,
119). In 1980 Mahila Parishad took a leading role in pressuring the
government to draft antidowry legislation (Kabeer 1991, 137;
Chowdhury 1994, 104), and in 1984-1985, through public meetings,
rallies and press conferences, mobilized women and public opinion
in general in support of government ratification of the UN
Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination
Against Women (CEDAW) (ibid.). In the mid-1980s Mahila Parishad led
a campaign against violence against women, and opened shelters and
established legal aid for women victims of violence (ibid., 105;
Kabeer 1991, 137; New Left Review Mar.-Apr. 1988, 120-21; United
Nations 8 Apr. 1993, 21). In recent years Mahila Parishad has
worked for the protection and rehabilitation of prostitutes (ibid.;
Chowdhury 1994, 105-06), and has organized opposition to
conservative Islamist groups such as the Un-Islamic Activities
Resistance Committee (UARC) (ibid.). In 1994 Mahila Parishad was
providing legal help to women who had been flogged under fatwahs
(religious edicts) issued by conservative Muslim clerics (DPA 17
Nov. 1994; BBC Summary 1 July 1994).
For further information on Mahila Parishad,
please refer to the following sources: Chowdhury 1994, 104-05; New
Left Review Mar.-Apr. 1988, 119-21; Kabeer 1991, 137-38; and Jahan
1975, 28. All of these documents are attached to Response to
Information Request BGD21346.EX of 6 October 1995.
This Response was prepared after researching publicly accessible information currently available to the DIRB within time constraints. This Response is not, and does not purport to be, conclusive as to the merit of any particular claim to refugee status or asylum.
References
Ahmed, Naseem. 1987. "Women in
Bangladesh, Part I: Socio-Economic and Political Status," UFSI
Reports. No. 36. Indianapolis: Universities Field Staff
International.
BBC Summary of World Broadcasts. 1 July
1994. "Teenage Girl Sentenced to 1,000 Broom-Strokes; Women Protest
Over Fatwahs." (NEXIS)
Chowdhury, Najma. 1994. "Bangladesh:
Gender Issues and Politics in a Patriarchy," Women and Politics
Worldwide. Edited by Barbara J. Nelson and Najma Chowdhury. New
Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press.
Deutsche Presse-Agentur (DPA). 17
November 1995. BC Cycle. "Bangla Police Look for Moslem Cleric Who
Flogged Girl." (NEXIS)
Encyclopedia of Women's Associations
Worldwide. 1993. Edited by Jacqueline K. Barrett. London: Gale
Research International.
Halim, Sadeka. PhD candidate
specializing in women and development issues in Bangladesh and
India, Department of Sociology, McGill University, Montréal.
30 May 1995. Telephone interview.
Islam, Mahmuda. 1979. "Women's
Organizations and Programmes for Women," Situation of Women in
Bangladesh. Dhaka: Women for Women Research and Study Group.
Jahan, Rounaq. 1982a. "Purdah and
Participation: Women in the Politics of Bangladesh," Separate
Worlds: Studies of Purdah in South Asia. Edited by Hanna Papanek
and Gail Minault. Delhi: Chanakya Publications.
_____. 1982b. "Bangladesh," Women in
Asia. Report No. 45. Edited by Rounaq Jahan. London: Minority
Rights Group.
_____. 1975. "Women in Bangladesh,"
Women Cross-Culturally: Change and Challenge. Edited by Ruby
Rohrlich-Leavitt. The Hague: Mouton.
Journal of Social Studies [Dhaka]. 1985.
No. 30. Rahnuma Ahmed. "Women's Movement in Bangladesh and the
Left's Understanding of the Women Question."
Kabeer, Naila. 1991. "The Quest for
National Identity: Women, Islam and the State in Bangladesh,"
Women, Islam and the State. Edited by Deniz Kandiyoti. London:
MacMillan Press.
New Left Review [London]. March/April
1988. No. 168. Naila Kabeer. "Subordination and Struggle: Women in
Bangladesh."
Quader, Hassina. 1987. "La condition
féminine au Bangladesh et le rôle des femmes dans le
développement," Les femmes musulmanes à l'ère
des Islamismes : Actes du Colloque international sur les femmes
musulmanes du Tiers-Monde. Edited by Fatima Houda-Pépin.
Montréal: Centre Maghrébin de Recherche et
d'Information (CMRI).
United Nations, Committee on the
Elimination of Discrimination against Women (CEDAW). 8 April 1993.
(CEDAW/C/BGD/3). Consideration of Reports Submitted by States
Parties Under Article 18 of the Convention. Vienna: United
Nations.
Women's Movements of the World: An International Directory and Reference Guide. 1988. Edited by Sally Shreir. London: Longman Group UK.
Information on women and politics, part 4 of 6: Women's organizations [BGD21349.EX] (Anfragebeantwortung, Französisch)