Dokument #1051127
IRB – Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada (Autor)
In a telephone interview on 14 February
1995, a professor of Russian and east European studies at the Army
War College in Carlisle Barracks, Pennsylvania, stated that
although he could not provide information on attitudes towards
ethnic Dagestanis, if there was still a category for nationality on
documents such as passports, then "Dagestani" probably would be
indicated.
In a telephone interview on 14 February
1995, a professor emeritus of history and political science at
Harvard University in Cambridge, Massachusetts, stated his belief
that Dagestanis are not a nationality but a conglomeration of
nationalities and ethnic groups, and therefore "Dagestani" would
not appear on cards displaying nationality.
In a telephone interview on 14 February
1995, the chairman of the Department of Social Studies at the
School of Slavonic and East European studies at the University of
London, who specializes in Russian politics, stated his view that
"Dagestani" is an umbrella group designation that encompasses many
nationalities. The word may also be used by those who do not want
their specific nationality indicated. In the former Soviet Union it
was not possible to indicate a specific nationality, so Dagestani
was used as a catch-all category. The chairman stated that it would
still be possible for "Dagestani" to be used on documents
indicating nationality, but it would now be more common for the
specific nationality to be listed.
The chairman added that in light of the
Turkic peoples militaristic traditions, ethnic Russians treat
Turkic minorities such as the Dagestanis with respect and care. The
general population associates the Dagestanis with other peoples of
the Caucasus, and by extension views them as being criminals or
members of the mafia.
In a telephone interview on 15 February
1995, a senior program officer with the Refugee Policy Group in
Washington, which is an independent policy research organization
dealing with refugee issues, stated his view that the Dagestanis,
as a people of the Caucasus, would be subject to the general
prejudice in Russian society toward people from the Caucasus.
Peoples of the Caucasus are often called "blacks" by ethnic
Russians outside of Dagestan. However, individual Dagestanis would
not necessarily be subject to prejudice. Further, within Dagestan,
Russians are a minority and would keep their opinions about the
Dagestanis to themselves.
In a telephone interview on 15 February
1995, the director of the Moscow office of Human Rights Watch
stated that in Moscow there is a distinct anti-Caucasian policy,
and people from the Caucasus are resented. The director stated that
there have been numerous reports of peoples from the Caucasus being
stopped in public by the police, and subjected to interrogation,
body searches, detention or extortion.
This response was prepared after
researching publicly accessible information currently available to
the DIRB within time constraints. This response is not, and does
not purport to be, conclusive as to the merit of any particular
claim to refugee status or asylum.
Chairman of the Department of Social
Sciences, School of Slavonic and East European Studies, University
of London, England. 14 February 1995. Telephone interview.
Human Rights Watch, Moscow. 15 February
1995. Telephone interview with director of Moscow office.
Professor of Russian and east European
studies, Army War College, Carlisle Barracks, Pa. 14 February 1995.
Telephone interview.
Professor emeritus of history and
political science, Harvard University, Cambridge, Mass. 14 February
1995. Telephone interview.
Refugee Policy Group, Washington, DC. 15
February 1995. Telephone interview with senior program officer.