Document #1263832
IRB – Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada (Author)
Having consulted several sources, it seems
clear that in fact there are no set rules for following the
conscription laws of Somalia. During 1986 and 1987, Amnesty
International reports that substantial numbers of Ethiopian
refugees were forcibly conscripted into the military. The Somali
government has been fighting opposition groups, mainly the SNM and
the DFSS, on different fronts for several years. [
ENDNOTES:
Colin Legum, ed., Africa Contemporary Record, (New York:
Africana Publishing Company, 1987), p.B410.] The DOS report for
1986 states that press gangs are often used to provide recruits for
the military [Country Reports on Human Rights Practices for
1986, (Washington: U.S. Department of State, 1986), p.269.]
which is the ultimate source of the President's political power.
[ibid. p.267.] It is important to note that "the Somali Armed
Forces were virtually wiped out in the Ogaden conflict, and their
personnel and equipment were totally shattered...it may take years,
even decades to rebuild the armed forces to their pre-war levels".
[ George T. Kurian, Encyclopedia of the Third World, Third
Edition, vol.III, (New York: Facts On File, Inc. 1987),
p.1805.]
Mr. Mohammed Abdulrashid Sharmarke, manager
of COSTI (Italian Scolastic and Technical Organizational Centre) at
the Wallace Emerson Centre in Toronto, states that although the
length of military service in Somalia is supposed to be 2 years, in
reality the authorities can and do keep people as long as the
demand is there. In support of this, Amnesty International reports
that "military conscription does not appear to have been applied
systematically". [ Conscientious Objection to Military
Service, (London: Amnesty International Publications, 1988),
p.17.] Mr. Sharmarke states that only about 10% of the military,
primarily in the higher ranks, leave after the initial 2 years of
service, usually because of their personal or financial
connections. A person's clan and political alliance play a major
role in the type and length of Military and National service
expected of Somali citizens. Dr. Saeed Sheikh Mohammed, a prominent
member of the Somali Canadian community in Toronto, states that
determining the length of military service in Somalia is a
difficult matter and corroborates the information given by Mr.
Sharmarke. The latter also reports that selective groups of
students are recruited into the military before they complete high
school. Among this group, the favoured ones are sent for training
as officers, others are recruited as rank and file soldiers and
still others may be employed into the civil service; depending on
the demand at the time. Some are even pulled out of Halane or
National Service and recruited into the military.
Attached please find excerpts from the
following documents:
Colin Legum, ed., African Contemporary Record Annual Survey and
Documents 1986-1987, New York: Africana Publishing Company,
1987, pp.B410-B411.
Country Reports on Human Rights Practices for 1986,
Washington: U.S. Department of State, 1987, pp.267-273.
Conscientious Objection to Military Service, London: Amnesty
International Publications, 1988, pp.16-17.
George T. Kurian, Encyclopedia of the Third World, Third
Edition, vol.III, New York: Facts on File Inc., 1987, p.1805.
Critique A Review of the Department os State's Country Reports
on Human Rights Practices for 1986, New York: Lawyers Committee
for Human Rights, 1987, pp.122-123.
2. According to Mr. Abdullah Adam, a
prominent member of the Arab Canadian community, Halane was the
name of a young Somali soldier who died during the Ogaden war. [
I.M. Lewis, A Modern History of Somalia, (Boulder: Westview
Press, 1988), p.212.] Halane is the name given to the military
training camp located in Mogadishu. Mr. Adam stated that it is
compulsory for high school graduates to attend the Halane for a
mandatory 6 month term. This information was corroborated by Mr.
Ismael Abdullahi, the president of the Northern Somali Association
in Montreal, who noted that it is not possible to secure work or
attend university without proof of completion of Halane. He also
stated that Halane refers not only to the name of the place and the
school but also to the actual military training program. It is
after Halane that high school graduates embark on the mandatory
National Service for a year. Secondary schools end around July and
Halane starts in October.
Mr. Abdullahi notes that the Halane,
previously the Military Academy, was opened in 1971 to provide
political orientation and military training for the military
cadres. The next year, the Halane catered to the top government
directors and chiefs, and in 1973, it was mandatory for all working
people in Mogadishu to attend. After 1973, working people in all
regions of Somalia were obliged to undergo the training program.
Between 1971 and 1975, the training program at Halane lasted 3
months, however, after that it was extended to 6 months.
Although I.M. Lewis addresses the issue of
the Halane, he writes about its function only as a national
top-level orientation centre for the higher public service cadres.
Attached is an excerpt from I.M. Lewis, A Modern History of
Somalia, Boulder: Westview Press, 1988, pp.212-213.
Both Mr. Adam and Mr. Abdullahi state that
"Gourmed" is a term that means "supporting force". It is the help
or support that is provided when someone is in danger or in need.
It is also applicable to the support that is given when the army is
besieged and needs assistance. Mr. Abdullahi states that Gourmed is
the Somali emergency relief service, consisting of firefighters,
para-medics, and general relief workers in a variety of areas such
as health, agriculture and education.
Apparently Gourmed is the parallel system
to the military in Somalia. The Gourmed is made up of the lower
ranks of party members, who also attend the Halane for the 6 month
term. Upon graduation, a person may choose to go to Gourmed instead
of participating in the National Service. Once a person has chosen
the Gourmed, then they are given basic disaster relief training and
are then put into the Gourmed reserve. They remain a part of the
reserve for about five years and must proceed to any part of the
country that is experiencing a catastrophe. In such cases, the top
administration for a region would summon all the Gourmed to deal
with the situation. Information given by oral sources on Gourmed
can not be corroborated by published sources currently available to
the IRBDC.
According to Mr. Abdullahi Adam, a
prominent member of the Arab Canadian community, the Somali
National Service is two pronged; the Halane on the one side and the
National Service on the other. Once students graduate from high
school in June or July, they are obliged to report to the Halane, a
political and military training school, for a mandatory 6 month
course. Following that, through the National Service, the young
adults are sent to different parts of the country to work in
various fields, be it educational, agricultural, medical and
social. Apparently it is the government's way of indirectly
recovering payment for the education it provided to these young
adults. Mr. Adam states that one does not have any choice regarding
the region of their posting. Most of the postings, lasting between
one and one and a half years, are situated in the rural areas. The
president of the North Somali Association in Montreal corroborates
the above information, but states that choice is permitted
regarding the field of service and the region.
The director for Research Resource Division
for Refugees at Carleton University stated that the persons
participating in the National Service have no choice in determining
the region of their posting.
According to Mr. Allan Egbert, a lawyer,
aspects of the National Service are transformed as the political
and military situation in the country changes. Therefore it is
difficult to treat it as an organization with a firm set of rules
and terms of service. Mr. Ebert states that high school graduates,
both male and female, commence the Halane program in August for a
period of 3 months. At Halane, students follow a regimen of
political socialist training along with military training, which
entails much physical exertion and weapon use. On the average, Mr.
Ebert states that the daily program consists of 16 hours of
training, 2 hours free-time and 4 hours sleep. Food is generally
served twice daily and consists of meagre portions of tea, bread
and rice or porridge.
Upon graduating from Halane, the students
are either assigned to a school any where in the country or are
sent to military service in the army. According to Mr. Ebert, the
latter situation has been more frequent since the military
operations of the SNM. Should they be sent to teach in a school,
the duration of their terms is usually for 9 months. Once the
National Service is completed, then the students are ostensibly
permitted to choose between military service and university.
However, according to Mr. Ebert, students must not only complete
Halane before they may receive their high school diploma, but must
also pay an extra fee. Completing the required documentation from
various government offices for acceptance and finally for
registration in a university, is time consuming and unpredictable.
Mr. Ebert states that anyone suspected of ties to opposition groups
or holding political views different from those of the ruling
party, would not be granted access to university.