Document #1178199
IRB – Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada (Author)
The Somali nation has evolved from a
pastoral society divided into six main clan-families, which are, in
turn, divided into many more sub-clans (see attached chart). The
Majerteen is one of Somalia's major clans. The Majerteen held the
main pre-colonial kingdom, the Sultanate of Boqor Ismaan Mahamoud,
on the East coast of the country. [ David D. Laitin and Said S.
Samatar, Somalia: Nation in Search of a State, (Boulder:
Westview Press, 1987), p. 48.] As an Italian protectorate, the clan
continued to hold a predominant position. [ Ibid, p. 52.]
During the civilian rule preceding the present dictatorship, which
seized power in 1969, all clans participated and were represented
in government; this participation reportedly tended to ease clan
rivalries and conflicts. [ Ibid, pp. 90-91.]
Since the early years of his dictatorship,
General Siyaad Barre has limited the participation in government of
members of the Majerteen clan, the predominant group during the
civilian era. This has led to a confrontation, with Barre alluding
to the Majerteen as his enemies, and ultimately identifying enemies
to his regime according to clan membership. [ Ibid, p. 91.]
Barre is, according to a report, particularly paranoid of the
Majerteen, mostly because of their past influence.
[Ibid,p.156.]
In retaliation for a coup attempt in 1971,
Barre executed members of the three leading clans (Majerteen being
one of them) and has since institutionalized clan membership as the
predominant feature of Somali politics. [ Ibid.] Barre has
also reportedly promoted interclan divisions and in-fighting to
maintain himself in power. Members of the Majerteen, Isaaq and
Hawiye clans have voiced uncertainty about their status under
Siyaad Barre's rule as he has formed a ruling coalition of the
Mareehan, Ogadeen and Dolbahanta clans (an alliance often referred
to as MOD). [ Ibid, pp. 91-92.] Presently, the Marehan clan,
to which Barre belongs, dominates Somalia's political and economic
system. [ Critique to the U.S. Department of State's Country
Reports on Human Rights Practices for 1987, (Washington: Human
Rights Watch, 1988), pp. 133-134.]
Tensions between the Somali government and
the two main opposition groups, the Somali National Movement (SNM),
a mainly Isaaq-clan organization, and the Democratic Front for the
Salvation of Somalia (DFSS), linked to the Majerteen clan, arose
about a decade ago. This apparently gave the government an excuse
to increase its abuses, which reportedly have increased sharply
since the start of the civil war. [ Somalia: Imprisonment of
Members of the Isaaq Clan since Mid-1988, various pages;
"Somalia: Showdown in the North", in Africa Confidential, 29
July 1988, pp. 1-3, and Beyond the Headlines: refugees in the
Horn of Africa, (American Council for Nationalities Service,
1988), p. 38.] Reprisals against the Majerteen were evidenced by
the government's use of extra-judicial executions, rape, the
killing of livestock and the destruction of reservoirs. [
Somalia: A Government at War with its Own People, An Africa
Watch Report, Washington: Human Rights Watch, January 1990,
pp.28-29.] This scorched-earth government policy was reportedly
intended to deprive the SSDF of political and social support from
Majerteen civilians. [ Africa Watch, ibid.] At the present time,
interclan enmity is reported to be worse and potentially more
violent than in any period of Somalia's history. [ Somalia:
Nation in Search of a State, p.94.] Feuding clans often resort
to reciprocal assassination of one another's elders in order to
deprive a rival clan of its able leadership. [ Ibid, p.
161.] The SNM has allegedly killed members of rival clans
(non-Isaaq), often on the suspicion that they were opposed to the
SNM. [ Country Reports on Human Rights Practices for 1988,
(Washington: U.S. Department of State, 1989), p. 308.] Although a
report states that many Majerteen military officers do not actively
participate in clan politics, [ Somalia: Nation in search of a
state, p. 156.] the army has also been riddled with internal
clan-based divisions, resulting in desertions and arbitrary
detentions. [ "Somalia; Generals fall out", in Africa
Confidential, 23 September 1988, pp. 1-2, and "Somalia:
Showdown in the North", 29 July 1988, p. 2.] Moreover, since the
outbreak of the civil war, the government has increased its efforts
to eliminate opposition throughout the country. [ Amnesty
International (1988): Somalia: A long term human rights
crisis and Somalia: Imprisonment of members of the Isaaq
clan since mid-1988; Africa Confidential, 16 December
1988, 6 January 1989, 20 January 1989.] Amnesty International
reports that being a member of a particular clan can be enough to
arise suspicion among Somali authorities, who work on the
assumption that many clan-members support particular opposition
groups. [ Somalia: A long term human rights crisis and
Somalia: Imprisonment of members of the Isaaq clan since
mid-1988, various pages.]
The Democratic Front for the Salvation of
Somalia (DFSS; sometimes referred to as the Somali Salvation
Democratic Front or SSDF), one of the two major armed opposition
groups, is reportedly based in Addis Ababa and derives most of its
support from the Majerteen clan. [ "Somalia: Showdown in the
North", in Africa Confidential, 29 July 1988, pp. 1-3;
Somalia: Nation in search of a state, p. 157; Somalia:
Imprisonment of Members of the Isaaq Clan since Mid-1988,
(London: Amnesty International, 1988).] Ethiopian forces reportedly
imprisoned the leader of the DFSS, Colonel Yuusuf, in 1987 after a
power struggle within the DFSS which resulted in Yuusuf's executing
of four high-ranking members of the Front. [ Somalia: Nation in
search of a state, p. 158.]
The DFSS has been recently described as
virtually inactive, in spite of having over 1,000 fighters
reportedly armed with Libyan-supplied weapons in bases which,
according to recent reports, were still located in Ethiopian
territory, [ Africa Confidential, 29 July 1988 and 18
November 1988, p. 3.] despite the 1988 agreement between Ethiopia
and Somalia to cut off support and bases in neighbouring countries
for rebel forces. [Keesing's Record of World Events (London,
Longman Publishing Group), p. 36007.]
After Somalia's defeat in the Ogaden war
with Ethiopia, many Ogadeni felt cheated that the intervention of
the Somali army contributed to their defeat in the war and in their
need to seek refuge in Somalia. Furthermore, the Somali army felt
humiliated by President Siyaad Barre's policies. [ "Somali:
Ogadeni's Misfortune", Africa Confidential, (London:
Miramoor Publications Ltd., 17 October 1984), p.6.] Consequently in
1978, in a bid to oust Siyaad Barre, Colonel Abdullahi Yusuf Ahmed
and Col. Mohamed Osman led an unsuccessful coup attempt, [ibid.] in
which 20 army officers were killed. [George T. Kurian,
Encyclopedia of the Third World, vol.II, (New York: Facts On
File, Inc., 1978), p.1304.] Col. Mohamed Osman was executed along
with several other officers, but Col. Abdullahi Yusuf was able to
flee to Kenya and eventually to Ethiopia. [ibid.] There he formed
the first anti-Barre front, the Somali Salvation Front (SOSAF)
which started armed struggle in 1979. [ibid.] Its name was changed
to the Democratic Front for the Salvation of Somalia (DFSS).
[ibid.]
The major weaknesses of the DFSS was its
domination by Majerteen people from central Somalia and the
negative Somali view of the group's reliance on Ethiopia, the
arch-enemy. [ibid.] In 1984 many members of DFSS took advantage of
the amnesty offer made by Siyaad Barre, reportedly following a
split within the group over the question of Col. Abdullahi's
leadership. [ C. Legum, ed., African Contemporary Record: Annual
Survey and Documents 1984-1985, (New York: Africana Publishing
Company 1985), p.B353.] This split is evidenced in the breakaway
group that formed the Somali Popular Liberation Front in Aden in
1983. [Africa Confidential, 13 November 1985, p.7.]
The Ethiopian Government "lost patience"
with divisions in the DFSS and on 1 October 1985, Ethiopian
security forces shot four of Col. Abdullahi's closest supporters
and then detained the Colonel in Addis Abeba. ["Somalia: Opposition
Bust-Up", Africa Confidential, 13 November 1985, p.7.] The
president of the Northern Somali Association in Ottawa, asserts
that, to his knowledge, Col. Abdullahi Yusuf was still in detention
in Ethiopia in February 1988.
Little SSDF military activity has been
reported in the last few years. According to an 18 November 1988
Africa Confidential report, the SSDF has been in disarray
since Ethiopia detained its head, Colonel Abdullahi Yusuf, in 1985.
The report further noted that "although racked by desertion, the
Front does still have well over 1,000 fighters" and recently the
front was reportedly still located in Ethiopian territory, [
Africa Confidential, 29 July 1988, and 18 November 1988, p.
3.] despite an agreement in April 1988 between Ethiopia and Somalia
to cut off support and bases in neighbouring countries for rebel
forces. [ Keesing's Record of World Events, (London, Longman
Publishing Group), p. 36007., "Somalia: Wounded North, Bruised
South", Africa Confidential, 18 November 1988, p.3.]
Although the SSDF is said to have been fairly moribund throughout
1989, Africa Events reported in December 1989 that "efforts
are now being made to reactivate [the Front]". [ "Hanging by Their
Nails", Africa Events, December 1989, p. 24.]
For more information on the DFSS please
consult the attached excerpts from the following documents:
"Somalia: Opposition Bust-Up", Africa
Confidential, London: Miramoor Publications Ltd., 13 November
1985, p.7.
"Somalia: The Ogadeni's Misfortune",
Africa Confidential, 17 October 1984, pp. 1, 5-7.
"Somalia: Generals Fall Out", Africa
Confidential, 23 September, 1988, pp. 1-2.
George T. Kurian, Encyclopedia of the
Third World (2nd Edition), vol.II, New York: Facts On File,
Inc., 1978, p.1304.
David D. Laitin and Said S. Samatar,
Somalia: Nation in Search of a State, London: Westview
Press, 1987, pp. 92-93, 142.
I.M. Lewis, A Modern History of Somalia:
Nation and State in the Horn of Africa, Boulder: Westview
Press, 1988, pp. 244-247, 250-255.
For background information on the DFSS,
please consult the copy of Revolutionary and Dissident
Movements, (London: Longman Publishing Group, 1988), p. 324,
available at your regional Documentation Centre.