Document #1294339
IRB – Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada (Author)
In a telephone interview, a representative
of the Somali Immigrant Organization in North York supplied the
following information on the Duroqbo subclan (8 Feb. 1995). The
Duroqbo is a small subclan of the Reer Hamar. Both are described as
an urban-based people located in Mogadishu, although scattered
numbers would have been found in nearby coastal cities before the
civil war (ibid.). The Reer Hamar do not trace their lineage
through one of the principle clan families of Somalia (ibid.).
According to the source, the Duroqbo, like
other subclans of the Reer Hamar, can be distinguished from Somalis
who trace their lineage through the principle clan families by
their dialect and accent when they speak standard Somali (ibid.).
In addition to these differences, the Reer Hamar's heritage is
non-pastoral and non-nomadic. Their tendency to keep to their own
people socially, except for business transactions, has meant that
some Somalis do not consider the Reer Hamar people to be Somali
(ibid.). The source stated that it is believed that the Reer Hamar
are of mixed ancestry, possibly of Arab, Arabian or Persian blood,
although they have lived in Mogadishu and the surrounding area for
centuries (ibid.).
In Mogadishu the Duroqbo resided in a
distinct quarter of the old city, where before the civil war they
ran small businesses and shops and engaged in trading and other
related commercial activities (ibid.). The source stated that
neither the Duroqbo nor the Reer Hamar are aligned with any
principle clan nor do they have any protective relationship with
any other clan. Traditionally the Reer Hamar have not been involved
in political affairs. However, during the tenure of the Siad Barre
government, officials extorted bribes from the Duroqbo and other
Reer Hamar people, which allowed the groups to survive largely
unmolested while public order was upheld (ibid.). Following the
downfall of the Barre government in 1989, the source stated, all
Reer Hamar people were extremely vulnerable to attacks from
non-Reer Somalis (ibid.). When the civil conflict started, Reer
Hamar people were attacked, raped, and killed, and their property
was looted and destroyed (ibid.). Unlike the other clans in Somalia
who all have distinctive home areas or regions, the Mogadishu-based
Duroqbo had nowhere within Somalia to flee when the civil conflict
erupted (ibid.)
In telephone interviews, sources at the
University of Pennsylvania and the University of Minnesota, in
addition to an anthropologist from Somalia now based in Canada and
a community worker in Toronto from Somalia corroborated the
information provided above (8 Feb. 1995; 6 Feb. 1995; 6 Feb. 1995;
7 Feb. 1995).
The representative of the Somali Immigrant
Organization also stated that members of the Hawiye clan were those
primarily responsible for attacks on the Duroqbo and other Reer
Hamar subclans once the Hawiye took over Mogadishu from government
loyalist troops (8 Feb. 1995). The anthropologist stated that the
Reer Hamar people "suffered immensely" and were "annihilated in
attacks from all sides" (6 Feb. 1995).
The community worker stated that the
Duroqbo, as with all the Reer Hamar subclans were a minority group,
but were never perceived by the Barre government as a threat
precisely because of their small numbers (7 Feb. 1995). According
to the community worker, the Duroqbo were perceived to be wealthy
because of their commercial activity, and were frequently the
victims of attacks perpetrated by soldiers or fighters from clans
based in the interior of Somalia (ibid.). The source stated that it
was quite possible the soldiers would not know the Duroqbo people,
except for having heard the fact, that Duroqbo were a defenceless
people with no clan allies, thereby ensuring there would be no
retaliation for attacks (ibid.).
The University of Minnesota specialist on
Somalia corroborated the information that attacks were made against
Reer Hamar because of the perception that the Duroqbo and other
Reer Hamar subclans were wealthy, noting that they were also
goldsmiths in the community (6 Fe. 1995). The source stated that
the "worst period for atrocities against the Reer Hamar" was
between fall 1990 and spring 1991 (ibid.). The source stressed that
all Reer Hamar people, individually and collectively, were at risk
because of the perception of their wealth and the fact that it was
known that they had no clan protection (ibid.). In addition, since
the 1989 breakdown in public order, the competing Somali clans
treated Reer Hamar as enemies simply because they were not
considered to be allied with any of the competing clans
(ibid.).
The University of Pennsylvania history
professor stated that the Duroqbo belonged to a federation
involving a number subclans of the Reer Hamar (7 Feb. 1995). The
professor identified the federation, entitled Iskashato, as a
grouping of "well known, old families" joined together for
economic, or real estate reasons or to arrange marriages so as to
keep property within the group. Besides the Duroqbo, the federation
included the Reer Manyo, Sheik Mumin, Ieydarus, Shamsi, Hatimi and
Baxamesh subclans (ibid.). The federation had no military purpose
(ibid.). The professor added that some individuals among the Reer
Hamar subclans fled Somalia soon after the fall of the government,
but these individuals had connections outside the country and left
previous to the attacks that destroyed the Reer Hamar
community.
For general information on the conditions
in Mogadishu since 1989, please consult News From Africa
Watch [New York]. Vol. 5 No. 2. "Somalia: Beyond the Warlords:
The Need for a Verdict on Human Rights Abuses;" 26 March 1992.
"Somalia: No Mercy in Mogadishu: The Human Cost of the Conflict and
the Struggle for Relief;" 13 February 1992. Vol. 4. No. 2.
"Somalia: A Fight to the Death? Leaving Civilians at the Mercy of
Terror and Starvation" available in Regional Documentation
Centers.
This response was prepared after
researching publicly accessible information currently available to
the DIRB within time constraints. This response is not, and does
not purport to be, conclusive as to the merit of any particular
claim to refugee status or asylum.
Anthropologist from Somalia, Ottawa. 6
February 1995. Telephone interview.
Community worker from Somalia, Toronto.
7 February 1995. Telephone interview.
Somali Immigrant Organization, North
York. 8 February 1995. Telephone interview with representative.
University of Minnesota, Minneapolis. 6
February 1995. Telephone interview with specialist on Somalia.
University of Pennsylvania,
Philadelphia. 7 February 1995. Telephone interview with history
professor.