Document #1254551
IRB – Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada (Author)
Information on the Tuenis clan [also spelt
Tunni] is contradictory. A document entitled Barawan Refugees
from Somalia published by the Migration and Refugee Services
(MRS) of the United States Catholic Conference in Washington, DC,
states that Barawans comprise the following eight clans: "Dafard,
Werile, Daqtira, Hajuwa, Goygal, Hatimi, Bidda and Asharaf" (1997,
2). In an 11 August 1997 telephone interview with the DIRB, a
representative of the Toronto-based Benadir Somali Association, who
has done extensive research on the cultural history of the Benadir
coast, corroborated this information but clarified that the Dafard,
Werile, Daqtira, Hafuwa and Goygal are Tunnis-Barawans or urban
Tunnis who live in Merka and Barawa and speak the Barawan language
(ibid.). However, he emphasized that there is a difference between
urban Tunnis who are Barawans and rural Tunnis who are not
Barawans. He explained that the difference between urban Tunnis and
rural Tunnis is linguistic, with the rural Tunnis speaking the
Tunni language, which is not comprehensible to the majority of
urban Tunnis (ibid.).
Author Lee Cassannelli in Victims and
Vulnerable Groups in Southern Somalia, states that the Tunni
are one of the seven subclans of the minority Digil clan (May 1995,
24). Together, the Digil and Mirifle comprise the Rahanweyn
(Reewin) clan, which is one of Somalia's minority clans
(ibid.).
According to the MRS, the formal Barawan
language of Chimbalazi, written with an Arabic script, is spoken
mostly by older Barawans. Chimini, which is different from both
Somali and other Benadir languages, incorporates some Somali,
Swahili, and even Portuguese vocabulary and is the Barawans' common
language (1997, 3).
However, the representative of the Benadir
Somali Association insisted that while Chimbalazi is the archaic
poetic version of Chimini, the two languages are one and the same.
He agreed, however, that Chimini is the language commonly spoken by
the Barawans (ibid.). For additional information on the Barawans,
please consult the attached document.
This Response was prepared after
researching publicly accessible information currently available to
the DIRB within time constraints. This Response is not, and does
not purport to be, conclusive as to the merit of any particular
claim to refugee status or asylum.
References
Benadir Somali Association, Toronto. 11
August 1997. Telephone interview with representative.
Cassanelli, Lee. May 1995. "Victims and
Vulnerable Groups in Southern Somalia." Ottawa. Documentation,
Information and Research Branch (DIRB), Immigration and Refugee
Board.
Migration and Refugee Services, United
States Catholic Conference, Washington, DC. 1997. Barawan
Refugees from Somalia.
Attachment
Migration and Refugee Services, United
States Catholic Conference, Washington, DC. 1997. Barawan
Refugees from Somalia, pp. 1-5.
According to Patrick Gilkes, the author of
The Price of Peace: Somalia and the United Nations, the
Saad are the most important "clan" of the Habr Gidir, "both
historically and because of the political importance of General
Aydeed in the last three years [1991-1994]" (1994, 116-117). The
Saad, according to Gilkes, are divided into two groups: "the
Awarere, which is based in the Mudug region, and the very much
smaller Abdullah" (ibid.). The source further states that with the
exception of a few individuals, the Saad supported General
Aydeed.
According to a 12 May 1997 Africa
News report, heavy clashes between militias of faction leaders
Hussein Mohamed Aydeed and Osman Hassan Ali Atto on 2, 6, and 7 May
left at least 30 people dead and 50 others injured in Mogadishu.
The article states that both faction leaders belong to the Saad
subclan of the Habr Gidir.
The Saad's support for Aydeed is covered in
several responses to Information Requests available at Regional
Documentation Centres. For details please consult Responses to
Information Requests SOM24649.E of 26 September 1996, SOM23634 of
18 April 1996, SOM23029.E of 7 March 1996, SOM20144.E of 13 April
1995 and SOM10348 of 20 February 1992.
Information specific to the current
situation of the Habr Gidir-Saad-Abdalla subclan cound not be found
among the sources currently available to the DIRB. However, the
attached documents indicate that fighting continues between
militias loyal to Mohamed Hussein Aydeed and those loyal to Ali
Atto. For additional information on this topic, please consult the
attached documents.
This Response was prepared after
researching publicly accessible information currently available to
the DIRB within time constraints. This Response is not, and does
not purport to be, conclusive as to the merit of any particular
claim to refugee status or asylum.
References
Africa News [Durham, NC]. 12
May 1997. "Somalia: Fighting Mars Peace Efforts in Somalia."
(NEXIS)
Gilkes, Parick S. September 1994. The Price of Peace: Somalia
and the United Nations 1991-1994. Bedfordshire, UK: Save the
Children's Fund.
Attachments
Africa News [Durham, NC]. 12
May 1997. "Somalia: Fighting Mars Peace Efforts in Somalia."
(DIRB Indexed Media Review [Ottawa], 27 May 1997, Vol. 13,
No. 20)
Agence France Press (AFP). 7 May 1997.
"Quatre morts et sept blessés dans des combats à
Mogadiscio." (DIRB Indexed Media Review [Ottawa], 20 May
1997, Vol. 13, No. 19)
_____. 26 April 1997. "Combats entre
factions à Mogadiscio: trois morts et sept blessés."
(DIRB Indexed Media Review[Ottawa], 6 May 1997, Vol. 13,
No. 17)
_____. 17 March 1997. "Au monis 11
tués dans des combats entre factions rivales en Somalie."
(DIRB Indexed Media Review [Ottawa], 25 March 1997, Vol.
13, No. 11)
Additional Sources Consulted
Africa Confidential [London].
Weekly.
Africa Research Bulletin: Political,
Social and Cultural Series [London]. Monthly.
Country Reports on Human Rights
Practices for 1996. 1997.
The Europa World Year Book
1996. 1996. 37th ed. Vol. 2. London: Europa Publications.
Foreign Broadcast Information Service
(FBIS) Daily Reports. 1993-1997.
Gilkes, P.S. September 1994. The
Price of Peace: Somalia and the United Nations 1991-1994.
Bedfordshire, U.K.: Save the Children's Fund.
Human Rights Watch World
Report. 1996, 1997.
Horn of Africa Bulletin
[Uppsala]. Bimonthly.
The Invention of Somalia.
Edited by Ali Jamale Ahmed. 1995. Lawrenceville, NJ: The Red Sea
Press.
Keesing's Record of World
Events [Cambridge]. 1996-1997.
Lewis, I. M. 1994. Blood and Bone:
The Call of Kinship in Somali Society. Lawrenceville, NJ: The
Red Sea Press.
_____. 1988. Rev. ed. A Modern
History of Somalia: Nation and State in the Horn of Africa.
Boulder, Col.: Westview Press.
New African [London].
Monthly.
On-line search on NEXIS database.
Two oral sources consulted did not
provide information on the requested subject.