Document #1276646
IRB – Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada (Author)
No information on student uprisings in
Karachi during the last two years could be found among the sources
currently available to the IRBDC. There have, however, been many
intercommunal riots and demonstrations in the city in the past few
years. Many of the gunmen have reportedly been youths. [ "Pakistan
Death Toll Hits 222 as Gun-Toting Youths Clash", The Ottawa
Citizen, 2 October 1988.] One source indicates that unemployed
youths in Karachi "play a predominant role in bank and highway
robberies and abductions under the guise of political activism". [
Salamat Ali, "Polarised Politics", p. 20.]
During 1985 and 1986, intercommunal riots
broke out between the Mohajirs (the people who fled India after the
partition in 1947) and the Pathans (Pushtuns) who had grown in
influence since 1979 with the influx of Afghan Pathans fleeing the
conflict in their own country. [ Keesing's Record of World
Events, Volume XXXIII, March 1987, p. 34995.] The Mohajirs
believe themselves to be deprived of employment opportunities and
economic privileges on the basis of their ethnic identity. [ Henry
Kamm, "By the Sea, a City Bursts With Squalor and Rage", The New
York Times, 19 April 1988.] Other ethnic groups, such as the
Sindhis and the Pathans, believe that they face the same
deprivations in Karachi, a city with a growth rate of seven percent
and an inadequate infrastructure to meet the needs of its eight to
ten million residents. [ Ibid.; Salamat Ali, "Polarised Politics:
The Sindh Government is Paralysed by Ethnic Disorder", Far
Eastern Economic Review, 21 September 1989, p. 20]
A political organization, the Mohajir Quami
Mahaz, leads the fight to secure rights for the Urdu-speaking
Mohajir community of Karachi, and, though characterized by at least
one source as a "militant youth organisation", won 96 of the 204
seats in local government elections in January 1988. [ Ahmed
Rashid, "Life Among the Ruins of a Karachi Slum", Far Eastern
Economic Review, 14 April 1988, p. 49.]
Some of the worst intercommunal rioting
occurred in December 1986, when 195 people died in Karachi. [
Hussain Haqqani, "Karachi Ethnic Riots Leave 25 Dead", Far
Eastern Economic Review, 19 May 1988, p. 12.] Sporadic
incidents of ethnic clashes have continued. For example, ethnic
riots in the western district of Karachi between Mohajirs and
Pathan settlers from North-West Frontier Province led to the death
of 25 people and the injury of 120 others on 8 May 1988. [ Ibid. ]
Massacres of hundreds of people in Hyderabad and Karachi in October
1988 were carried out by "thousands of gun-toting youths". [
"Pakistan Death Toll Hits 222 as Gun-Toting Youths Clash", The
Ottawa Citizen, 2 October 1988.] And, after ethnic rioting in
Karachi led to scores of deaths in November and December 1988, the
Government put an indefinite curfew on the city on 16 December
(which lasted until 26 December). [ "The Week: Pakistan", Far
Eastern Economic Review, 29 December 1988, p. 9.] This followed
a curfew which had been lifted two weeks earlier, on 4 December
1988. [ "Curfew Lifted in Karachi Areas 4 December"
FBIS-NES-88-233, 5 December 1988, p. 72.] Ethnic violence in
Karachi has continued into 1989.
2.
The Islamicization of the legal code
initiated by the Pakistan Government in June 1980 generated
opposition from women's groups and minority religious groups. [
Keesing's Record of World Events, Volume XXXIII, March 1987,
p. 34992.] The adoption of Shari'a (Islamic) Law reduces the value
of a woman's evidence in court to half that of a man's; likewise,
two women's signatures equal the signature of one man on a business
contract. [ "The Lady Tops the Men", The Economist, p. 35.
Keesing's, p. 34992.] On 15 June 1988, Zia-ul Haq announced
the enforcement of Koranic-Shariah law through an ordinance which
permitted courts to eliminate laws contrary to Islamic injunctions.
[ Hussain Haqqani, "Legal Entanglements", Far Eastern Economic
Review, 30 June 1988, p. 30.] Despite promises to change
discriminatory laws, [ Ahmed Rashid, "War of Nerves: Islamic
Fundamentalists Take Aim at Bhutto", Far Eastern Economic
Review, 16 March 1989, p. 24.] Prime Minister Bhutto has failed
to make significant alterations to the status of women since she
was elected almost a year ago. One article discussing the rights
observes that, "From birth to death, no matter what is being
measured, females in Pakistan are less likely than males to survive
infancy, receive an education, earn money or reach old age." [
Farida Shaheed and Khawar Mumtaz, "Bhutto Inherits Laws Which
Restrict the Rights of Women: Veils of Tears", Far Eastern
Economic Review, 28 September 1989, p. 129.]
The religious group most severely affected
by the Islamicization of the State, has been the Ahmaddiya
movement. According to the U.S. Department of State Country
Reports, "minorities can practice their own religion openly",
but proselytizing among Muslims is prohibited. [ U.S. Department of
State, Country Reports on Human Rights Practices for 1988,
(Washington: U.S. Government Printing Office, February 1989), p.
1468.] Please refer to the section in the Country Reports
1988 on Freedom of Religion (pp. 1468-9). A mission of the
International Commission of Jurists reported that at least one
Christian church had ben attacked. [ International Commission of
Jurists, Pakistan: Human Rights After Martial Law, (Geneva:
ICJ, 1987), p. 102.] The mission also reported on the feelings of
insecurity among religious minorities engendered by laws which set
them apart from the majority Muslim population. For a discussion of
the treatment of minority religious groups in Pakistan, see the
attached:
-
International Commission of Jurists,
Pakistan: Human Rights After Martial Law, Geneva: ICJ,
1987
-
Christian Conference of Asia, Pakistan:
Struggle for Human Rights, Pakistan International Affairs,
1986.
Please refer to the following attachments for more information on
the position of women in Pakistani society and on intercommunal
rioting:
-
Husain Haqqani, "Judges Clear the Way:
Supreme Court Orders Election to be Held as Planned", Far
Eastern Economic Review, 13 October 1988.
-
"The Ethnic Melting Pot: Minorities Resent
the Dominance of Populous Punjab", Far Eastern Economic
Review, 10 November 1988.
-
Hamish McDonald, "A New Ethnic Force Flexes
its Muscles", Far Eastern Economic Review, 1 December
1988.
-
Anis Haroon, "Islamisation and Women in
Pakistan", Religion and Asian Politics National Dialogue -
Pakistan, Hong Kong: Christian Conference of Asia International
Affairs, June 1987.
-
Ahmed Rashid, "War of Nerves: Islamic
Fundamentalists Take Aim at Bhutto", Far Eastern Economic
Review, 16 March 1989.
-
"Pakistan Death Toll Hits 222 as Gun-Toting
Youths Clash", The Ottawa Citizen, 2 October 1988.
-
Salamat Ali, "The Great Ethnic Divide",
Far Eastern Economic Review, 14 January 1988.
-
"Hitting at Punjabi Hegemony", Far
Eastern Economic Review, 14 January 1988.
-
"Ethnic Rioting in Karachi Kills 46 and
Injures 50", The New York Times, 2 October 1988.
-
"Rooftop Gunmen Kill 5 as Curfew Briefly
Lifted", The Toronto Star, 3 October 1988.
-
Mark Fineman, "Pakistanis Mystified by Wave
of Ethnic Violence Sweeping Country", The Ottawa Citizen, 4
October 1988.
-
William MacLean, "Pakistani Women Hope
Benazir Bhutto Will Free Them from Virtual Slavery", The Toronto
Star, 21 November 1988.
-
Barbara Crossete, "Bhutto Pledges Aid to
Women, Students and Labor", The New York Times, 3 December
1988.
-
Ahmed Rashid, "Life Among the Ruins of a
Karachi Slum", Far Eastern Economic Review, 14 April
1988.
-
Hussain Haqqani, "Legal Entanglements",
Far Eastern Economic Review, 30 June 1988.
-
Henry Kamm, "By the Sea, a City Bursts With
Squalor and Rage", The New York Times, 19 April 1988.
-
Farida Shaheed and Khawar Mumtaz, "Bhutto
Inherits Laws Which Restrict the Rights of Women: Veils of Tears",
Far Eastern Economic Review, 28 September 1989.
-
Keesing's Record of World Events,
Volume XXXIII, March 1987.
-
Salamat Ali, "Polarised Politics: The Sindh
Government is Paralysed by Ethnic Disorder", Far Eastern
Economic Review, 21 September 1989.