Document #1131595
IRB – Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada (Author)
Media reports state that on 18 December
1997 about 500 Lebanese university students, mostly Christians,
walked through Beirut's streets to protest the Lebanese
government's media policy following the government's banning of a
TV broadcast of an interview with Michel Aoun on 14 December (DPA
18 Dec. 1997; AFP 16 Dec. 1997). Deutsche Presse-Agentur (DPA)
added that about 66 of Aoun's supporters were arrested at a
demonstration in front of the offices of the private MTV television
network on 14 December, but they were all released on 16 December
(18 Dec. 1997). The demonstrations were part of a widespread public
reaction against the government's media policy after the
cancellation of the Aoun interview, including a one-day strike by
the Beirut Engineers' Union and a three-day strike by the Lawyers'
Union (ibid.; AFP 15 Dec. 1997). The DPA dispatch also stated that
"[m]embers of the [Lebanese] government were unanimous in agreeing
that the Aoun interview should not have been banned" (DPA 18 Dec.
1997). The dispatch did not state whether any demonstrators were
arrested on 18 December.
According to a 17 December 1997 Agence
France Presse (AFP) dispatch, the banning of the Aoun interview led
to strikes and student rallies at several Lebanese universities,
including the American University of Beirut, the Lebanese
University and St. Joseph's University, where hundreds of students
staged a sit-in and chanted anti-Syrian slogans. On 16 December
students from four Christian universities sent delegations to the
Maronite patriarchate, where they met with the Patriarch Nasrallah
Sfeir. According to the AFP dispatch, the number of Aoun supporters
arrested on 14 December was 63, of whom 30 were released the
following day. The remaining 33 were released at the request of
Lebanese Prime Minister Rafiq (Rafic) Hariri on 16 December after
the cases of 23 were referred to a civil court and 10 were referred
to a military court (ibid; AFP 16 Dec. 1997). According to AFP, the
demonstrations marked "the first time since the end of Lebanon's
1975-1990 civil war that Lebanese demonstrators shouted slogans
hostile to Syria in a public place" (ibid.). Neither AFP dispatch
stated whether any demonstrators were arrested after the initial
incident on 14 December (16, 17 Dec. 1997).
On 13 March 1997 AFP reported that 13
supporters of Michel Aoun were sentenced on 12 and 13 March to
prison sentences varying from ten days to one year. The sentences
were handed down by a military court after the defendants were
convicted of distributing literature which called for sedition and
was likely to harm relations with a friendly country ("distribution
de tracts appelant à la sédition et portant atteinte
aux relations avec un pays ami"). The convictions stemmed from a
September 1994 incident when leaflets were distributed in the areas
of Metn and Kesrouan calling on Lebanese citizens to practice civil
disobedience against "pro-Syrian" power. Among those sentenced was
the secretary-general of the Engineers' Union, Hikmat Dib, who
received a three-week sentence. According to the dispatch,
supporters of Michel Aoun had succeeded in being elected as
officers in the professional associations of Lebanon's lawyers,
engineers, and doctors, as well as in student councils (ibid.).
In the wake of an 18 December 1996
machine-gun attack on a Syrian minibus in Tabarja, north of Beirut,
which left one dead and one wounded, "48 members of the Christian
opposition, most of them supporters of General Michel Aoun or Dory
Chamoun's National Liberal Party, were arrested. Eleven of them are
believed to be still behind bars" (Manchester Guardian
Weekly 12 Jan. 1997; Mideast Mirror 23 Dec. 1996). It
was reported that Christian opposition had estimated the numbers of
those arrested at between 200 to 500, and the Maronite Patriarch
Nasrallah Sfeir, while condemning the Tabarja attack, criticized
the arrests, which he said had the effect of making Lebanese "feel
undesirable in their own country" (Manchester Guardian
Weekly 12 Jan. 1997; Mideast Mirror 23 Dec.
1996).
On 5 April 1996 Reuters reported that about
50 supporters of Michel Aoun staged an anti-Syrian demonstration at
the Maronite patriarchate in Bkerke, Lebanon, where visiting French
President Jacques Chirac was attending a mass held by Maronite
Patriarch Nasrallah Sfeir. The demonstrators had passed several
military roadblocks on the route to the patriarchate with the help
of a priest. About 30 buses full of protesters had not been allowed
past the army roadblocks, according to witnesses (ibid.).
Specific information on low-ranking or
Muslim supporters of Michel Aoun could not be found among the
sources consulted by the Research Directorate.
This Response was prepared after
researching publicly accessible information currently available to
the Research Directorate within time constraints. This Response is
not, and does not purport to be, conclusive as to the merit of any
particular claim to refugee status or asylum.
References
Agence France Presse (AFP). 17 December
1997. Najib Khazzaka. "Interview Aoun: le mouvement de protestation
se poursuit au Liban." (Internet: AFP MAIL topic@alc1.par.afp.com )
_____. 16 December 1997. "Pro-Aoun
Demonstrators Freed." (NEXIS)
_____. 15 December 1997. "Arrestation de
partisans du général Aoun: grève de 3 jours
des avocats." (Internet: AFP MAIL topic@alc1.par.afp.com )
_____. 13 March 1997. "Treize partisans
du général Aoun condamnés à des peines
de prison." (Internet: AFP MAIL topic@alc1.par.afp.com )
_____. 5 April 1996. "Christians Stage
Protests During Chirac Visit." (NEXIS)
Deutsche Presse-Agentur (DPA). 18
December 1997. BC Cycle. "Lebanese Students in Freedom of Speech
Demonstration." (NEXIS)
Manchester Guardian Weekly. 12
January 1997. Lucien George. "Political Tension Rises in Beirut."
(NEXIS)
Mideast Mirror. 23 December
1996. "Wave of Arrests in Lebanon Linked to Israeli-Backed
Destabilization Scheme." (NEXIS)
Additional Sources Consulted
Electronic sources: IRB databases,
Global News Bank, REFWORLD (UNHCR database), World News Connection
(WNC).