Document #1081232
IRB – Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada (Author)
According to World Directory of
Minorities, "Pashtuns, Pashtouns, Pakhtuns, Afghans" are
alternative names for "Pathan" (MRGI 1990, 310). Political
Handbook of the World:1994-1995 states that alternative names
for "Pushtuns" are "Pashtuns or Pathans" (1995, 3), and information
provided in the glossary of Afghanistan: The Great Game
Revisited states that the term "Pathan" is the Indian form for
"Pushtun" or "Pukhtun" (1987, 465-66). Since these terms appear
interchangeable, the term "Pashtun" rather than "Pathan" will be
used for the purpose of this Response to Information Request.
Sources consulted by the DIRB differ on the
percentage of Pashtuns in Afghanistan. Some sources state that they
represent approximately 30 to 50 per cent of the population
(Manchester Guardian Weekly 24 Apr. 1994; Encyclopedia of
the Third World 1992, 2; UNHCR 13 June 1994; Asian
Survey July 1995, 631-33). However, The Herald and
Minority Rights Group (MRG) disagree, stating that these figures
reflect the situation before 1978 (Oct. 1995, 30; Feb. 1992, 11).
According to MRG, some 85 per cent of over 3 million Afghan
refugees in Pakistan are Pashtun, and according to a late 1987
Gallup poll, only 13 per cent of the population remaining in
Afghanistan is Pashtun (ibid.). Corroborating information for this
last statement could not be found among the sources consulted by
the DIRB.
According to the Manchester Guardian
Weekly, the Pashtuns wish to keep power out of the hands of the
Tajiks (24 Apr. 1994), who represent approximately 30 per cent of
the population (ibid.; UNHCR 13 June 1994; The Herald Oct.
1995, 30). The Pashtuns have ruled Afghanistan for between 250 and
300 years (ibid.; MRG Feb. 1992, 9; Manchester Guardian
Weekly 24 Apr. 1994).
The Pashtun are primarily Sunni Muslims who
live mainly in the east and south of Afghanistan (MRG Feb. 1992,
9). Those in the east belong to the Ghilzai tribes, and those in
the south to the Durrani (The Herald Oct. 1995, 30). Most of
the Mujahideen leaders are Pashtun from the east (ibid. Oct. 1995,
30-31), while the Taliban leadership and membership are largely
Durrani from the south (ibid.; FEER 18 May 1995, 24;
Facts on File 9 Mar. 1995). Further information on the
Pashtun can be found in the attachments from World Directory of
Minorities, The Herald of October 1995 and Asian
Survey of July 1995. A map indicating the locations of the
major ethnic groups is provided in the MRG attachment.
After the fall of the Najibullah
régime in April 1992, a Pashtun religious leader,
Sigbatullah Mojaddidi, took over as head of state of the Islamic
Republic of Afghanistan (Freedom in the World 1994-1995,
89). Fighting immediately broke out between the Mujahideen along
ethnic lines: the Pashtuns, represented by Gulbuddin Hekmatyar and
his Hizb-i Islami forces, battled the Tajiks, who were represented
by Burhanuddin Rabbani, his military strategist Ahmed Shah Masoud,
and the Jamaat-i Islami (ibid.; The Times 12 Sept. 1994;
The Daily Telegraph 16 Mar. 1994). At the end of 1992, the
Jamaat-i Islami forces of Rabbani and his army chief Masoud broke
with the Shi'is of the Wahdat coalition of nine Hazara minority
parties, who then joined Hekmatyar (Manchester Guardian
Weekly 24 Apr. 1994). Rabbani was elected president in June
1992, and in the 7 March 1993 Islamabad Accords, it was agreed that
Rabbani would continue as interim president while Hekmatyar became
prime minister (Asian Survey Feb. 1994, 187). On 1 January
1994, General Dostam and his mainly Uzbek forces deserted Masoud
and Rabbani and joined Hekmatyar (Manchester Guardian Weekly
24 Apr. 1994; Freedom in the World 1994-1995, 90).
In the autumn of 1994, the Pashtun-based
Taliban, an army consisting of religious students, appeared on the
political scene. Since then it has become a major political force,
and by February 1995 had gained control over ten Pashtun provinces
(Asian Survey July 1995, 623; Facts on File 9 Mar.
1995). According to The Herald, the Taliban has now captured
all of southern and western Afghanistan (Oct. 1995, 31). According
to two sources, the Taliban and its ally, General Dostam, joined
forces with Hekmatyar against Rabbani (ibid. Sept. 1995, 68;
MEI 6 Oct. 1995, 13-14; ibid. 20 Oct. 1995, 14) in order to
mount an offensive against Kabul (ibid.). Sources did not provide a
date for the union.
For additional information on the Taliban,
please consult Responses to Information Requests AFG21226.EX of 17
July 1995 and AFG20612.E of 9 May 1995, which are available at
Regional Documentation Centres.
For information on the current political
scene in Afghanistan, please consult the September 1995 attachment
from The Herald. Please consult Response to Information
Request AFG22133.E of 14 November 1995, available at Regional
Documentation Centres, for information on the current political
climate in Afghanistan. The attachments from Freedom in the
World 1994-1995 and Asian Survey of February 1995
provide background information on the political alliances between
the various players since the collapse of the Najibullah
régime in April 1992.
This Response was prepared after
researching publicly accessible information currently available to
the DIRB within time constraints. This Response is not, and does
not purport to be, conclusive as to the merit of any particular
claim to refugee status or asylum.
References
Afghanistan: The Great Game
Revisited. 1987. Edited by Rosanne Klass. New York: Freedom
House.
Asian Survey [Berkeley, Calif.].
July 1995. Vol. 35, No. 7. Anwar-ul-Haq Ahady. "The Decline of the
Pashtuns in Afghanistan."
_____. February 1994. Vol. 34, No. 2.
Barnett R. Rubin. "Afghanistan in 1993: Abandoned but
Surviving."
The Daily Telegraph [London]. 16
March 1994. Ahmed Rashid. "Afghan Fighting Threatens Wider Conflict
in Region." (NEXIS)
Encyclopedia of the Third World.
1992. 4th ed. Vol. 1. Edited by George Thomas Kurian. New York:
Facts on File.
Facts on File World News Digest
[New York]. 9 March 1995. "U.N. Peace Plan Stalls." (NEXIS)
Far Eastern Economic Review
(FEER) [Hong Kong]. 18 May 1995. Vol. 158, No. 20. Ahmed Rashid.
"Grinding Halt: Taliban Student Army Suffers Serious Setback."
Freedom in the World: The Annual
Survey of Political Rights & Civil Liberties, 1994-1995.
1995. Edited by James Finn et al. New York: Freedom House.
The Herald [Karachi]. October
1995. Vol. 26, No. 10. "The Pakhtun Factor."
_____. September 1995. Vol. 26, No. 9.
"Rabbani's Last Stand?"
Manchester Guardian Weekly
[London]. 24 April 1994. Bruno Philip. "'An Afghan Is for Hire, Not
for Sale,." (NEXIS)
Middle East International (MEI)
[London]. 20 October 1995. Mushahid Hussain. "Afghanistan: A
Decisive Round."
_____. 6 October 1995. Mushahid Hussain.
"Afghanistan: Taliban's New Successes."
Minority Rights Group (MRG). February
1992. No. 92.2. Nassim Jawad. Afghanistan: A Nation of
Minorities. London: MRG.
Minority Rights Group International
(MRGI). 1990. World Directory of Minorities. The High,
Harlow, Essex: Longman Group UK.
Political Handbook of the World,
1994-1995. 1995. Edited by Arthur S. Banks. Binghamton, NY: CSA
Publications.
The Times [London]. 12 September
1994. Adrian Brooks. "Children of Kabul Pay Bloody Price for Afghan
Conflict." (NEXIS)
United Nations High Commissioner for
Refugees (UNHCR). 13 June 1994. Public Information (PI) Fact
Sheet: Afghanistan. (DIRB country file)
Attachments
Afghanistan: The Great Game
Revisited. 1987. Edited by Rosanne Klass. New York: Freedom
House, pp. 465-66.
Asian Survey [Berkeley, Calif.].
July 1995. Vol. 35, No. 7. Anwar-ul-Haq Ahady. "The Decline of the
Pashtuns in Afghanistan," pp. 621-34.
_____. February 1995. Vol. 35, No. 2.
Zalmay Khalilzad. "Afghanistan in 1994: Civil War and
Disintegration," pp. 147-52.
Facts on File World News Digest
[New York]. 9 march 1995. "U.N. Peace Plan Stalls." (NEXIS)
Freedom in the World: The Annual
Survey of Political Rights & Civil Liberties, 1994-1995.
1995. Edited by James Finn et al. New York: Freedom House, pp.
89-91.
The Herald [Karachi]. October
1995. Vol. 26, No. 10. "The Pakhtun Factor," pp. 30-31.
_____. September 1995. Vol. 26, No. 9.
"Rabbani's Last Stand?," pp. 68-69.
Manchester Guardian Weekly
[London]. 24 April 1994. Bruno Philip. "'An Afghan Is for Hire, Not
for Sale,." (NEXIS)
Middle East International (MEI)
[London]. 20 October 1995. Mushahid Hussain. "Afghanistan: A
Decisive Round," p. 14.
Minority Rights Group (MRG). February
1992. No,. 92.2. Nassim Jawad. Afghanistan: A Nation of
Minorities. London: MRG, pp. 9-11.
Minority Rights Group International
(MRGI). 1990. World Directory of Minorities. The High,
Harlow, Essex: Longman Group UK, pp. 310-12.
United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR). 13 June 1994. Public Information (PI) Fact Sheet: Afghanistan. (DIRB country file)