Document #1345340
IRB – Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada (Author)
The principal Shi'ite militias in Lebanon
are Amal and Hezbollah. Amal has been aligned with Syria since the
mid-eighties, and Hezbollah has tended to be pro-Iranian. Other
smaller Shi'ite groups have also surfaced over the past decade, but
it is believed that many of the extremist Shi'ite groups claiming
responsibility for hijackings, kidnappings, and bombings are
answerable to Hezbollah. The Sunni Muslims have also been divided
into pro- and anti-Syrian camps. Please refer to background
information on Lebanese militias from Henry Degenhardt, (ed.,
Revolutionary and Dissident Movements, London: Longman Group
UK Ltd., 1988).
Mourabitoun:
West Beirut, particularly the southern
part, has traditionally been a Shi'ite (Amal) stronghold. The
Nasserist (Sunni) Mourabitoun militia helped defend West Beirut
during the Israeli invasion in 1982. [ David McDowall, Lebanon:
A Conflict of Minorities, Minority Rights Group, No. 61, p.
15.] When the Israeli forces moved into West Beirut, they brought
the Christian Phalangist (Kata'ib)-Lebanese Forces with them.
Following the massacre of Palestinian refugees in Sabra and Chatila
by Lebanese militias friendly to Israel, the United States ordered
the Israelis out of West Beirut. [ Ibid.,
p. 16.] During 1984, the Shi'ite forces of Nabi Berri grew
stronger, and Amal began to gain power over Mourabitoun. [George
Delury, World Encyclopedia of Political Systems and Parties,
(Detroit: Gale Research Company, 1984), pp. 673-674.] The influence
of Mourabitoun has declined in recent years, having suffered
defeats in 1984, 1985, and 1986 at the hands of Druze and Amal
militias. [ See the attached information from Henry Degenhardt,
Revolutionary and Dissident Movements, London: Longman Group
UK Ltd., 1988, p. 218.]
The Mourabitoun allied itself with Amal and
Druze militias at different times during the 1980s. It was driven
out of positions along the Green Line in Beirut by Druze forces in
March 1984, but fought with Palestinians, Amal and Druze militias
against the Christian Lebanese Forces under the command of Samir
Geagea in Sidon in March 1985. [ Keesing's Record of World
Events, Volume XXXI, June 1985, p. 33688; Henry Degenhardt,
Revolutionary and Dissident Movements, London: Longman Group
UK Ltd., 1988, p. 218.] Mourabitoun and pro-Arafat Palestinian
Liberation Organization (PLO) fighters clashed with Amal in Beirut
in April 1985, and in November 1985, Mourabitoun sided with Druze
PSP fighters against Amal. [Keesing's Record of World
Events, Volume XXXII, January 1986, p. 34132.] Amal gained
control of West Beirut from Mourabitoun in the 1985 conflicts. [
Amnesty International, Report 1987, (London: Amnesty
International Publications, 1987), p. 358.] No information on
executions of Mourabitoun during 1985 is currently available to the
IRBDC, however, Amnesty International reported that Amal held
hundreds of Palestinians and members of Mourabitoun in detention
during 1986, [ Report 1987, p. 358.] and the attached
Amnesty International reports for 1986 and 1987 allude to torture
and execution of prisoners by Amal and other militias.
On 3 June 1986, Mourabitoun militiamen
attacked Amal positions, but on 4 June 1986, "Amal decisively
defeated [the] attack by the Sunni `6th February' militia". [
Keesing's Record of World Events, Volume XXXII, August 1986,
p. 34587.] (Henry Degenhardt (Revolutionary and Dissident
Movements) identifies the 6th February militia as a brigade of
Mourabitoun.) [ Henry Degenhardt, Revolutionary and Dissident
Movements, London: Longman Group UK Ltd., 1988, p. 218.]
Mourabitoun was allied with the Druze militia in February 1987 when
they again fought against Amal. [ Ibid.]
Another example of a Shi'ite-Sunni conflict
in Lebanon began in May 1985, when Amal launched the "war of the
camps" against the Palestinian refugee camps in West Beirut. [
Amnesty International, Report 1986, (London: Amnesty
International Publications, 1986), p. 343.] Ninety percent of
Palestinians in Lebanon are Sunni. The Amal attack on the camps was
allegedly at "Syria's behest", and constituted an attempt to
prevent Arafat supporters from regaining a power base in Lebanon.
[Keesing's Record of World Events, Volume XXXIV, December
1988, p. 36363.]
Three Palestinian camps, Bourj al-Barajneh,
Chatila, and Rashidiyeh, were placed under siege by Amal during the
latter half of 1986. In April 1987, the arrival of the Syrian army
resulted in the partial lifting of the siege, and women and
children were allowed to leave the camps for supplies. [ Ibid.]
Between April and July 1988, Arafat supporters were driven from
Chatila and Rashidiyeh by members of the Fatah Revolutionary
Council (Fatah al-Intifadeh), and in July, the last of the
pro-Arafat fighters from Bourj al-Barajneh were removed to
Sidon.
Please consult the attachments from
Keesing's Record of World Events, which discuss several
clashes between Shi'ite and Sunni militias. Also, the Amnesty
International Report 1987, 1986 and 1985 for
Lebanon are attached.