Document #1327053
IRB – Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada (Author)
Please find attached some documents that
add to the information provided in Responses to Information
Requests VEN13930 of 21 May 1993 and VEN2132 of 18 September 1989.
Additional references to the DISIP can be found in Responses
VEN17065.E of 13 April 1994 and VEN2981 of 25 January 1990.
The attached documents provide different
translations of DISIP's full name and describe it as an
intelligence service or a political police under the command of the
Ministry of the Interior.
A summary provided by one of Venezuela's
main human rights organizations states that the organization and
number of agents of DISIP have not varied much over the years,
although its chiefs change according to the political party that
controls the government (PROVEA 22 Apr. 1993). The source also
states that DISIP is a state security body with internal security
control functions (funciones de control de seguridad interna
in the original Spanish text) dependent on the Ministry of the
Interior; in other words, according to PROVEA, a "political police"
(ibid.). PROVEA adds that DISIP was responsible for most of the
human rights violations (arbitrary detention, raids and tortures)
that took place in 1992 following the 4 February and 27 November
attempted coups, when constitutional guarantees were suspended. The
text sent to the DIRB by PROVEA cannot be attached to this
Response, as it is not written in one of Canada's official
languages, but it can be provided upon request, as it is a public
document received by the DIRB.
One of the attached reports describes
DISIP's role in preventing the regular circulation of at least one
newspaper from 7 to 10 February 1992 (Latinamerica Press 20
Feb. 1992, 1). Another report states that the statistics of the
attorney general's Human Rights Office on homicides allegedly
committed by police forces place DISIP as "the second worst
offender" among the security forces, with fifteen cases under
investigation in late 1993 (Latinamerica Press 28 Oct. 1993,
4). Human Rights Watch names DISIP as one of the Venezuelan police
forces which employed in 1993 "such abusive methods as force
disproportionate to the circumstances, extrajudicial executions and
physical abuse and torture" (Dec. 1993, 133). The same source
states that DISIP has been one of the three security forces
"principally responsible for interdicting drugs" (ibid., 135).
DISIP and Judicial Technical Police heads
conducted an investigation into a series of letter bombs sent to
judges of the supreme court in 1993 and identified an active DISIP
chief, Maximiliano José Monsalve Planchart, as the person
directly responsible for the attacks (Andean Newsletters
Aug. 1993, 7). After Monsalve Planchart's indictment, an official
report linked him to important human rights violations that took
place over the past decade (the attached excerpt from the Andean
Newsletter describes some of these cases). Monsalve Planchart
worked in the DISIP Investigation Brigade and was under the command
of a former DISIP commander, Henry López Sisco, who has also
been linked to the above-mentioned letter bombs and placed under
arrest (ibid., 8). The source adds that López Sisco's arrest
was a surprise for the Venezuelan public, as he "has been a major
power symbol within police forces for more than two decades"
(ibid.).
This response was prepared after
researching publicly accessible information currently available to
the DIRB within time constraints. This response is not, and does
not purport to be, conclusive as to the merit of any particular
claim to refugee status or asylum.
Andean Newsletter [Lima]. August
1993. "Terrorism and Human Rights Violations."
Human Rights Watch World Report
1994. December 1993. New York: Human Rights Watch.
Latinamerica Press [Lima]. 28
October 1993. Inés Scudellari. "Venezuelans Live with Police
Impunity."
_____. 20 February 1992. "Venezuela
under the Microscope after Coup Attempt."
Programa Venezolano de
Educación-Acción en Derechos Humanos (PROVEA),
Caracas. 22 April 1993. Fax received by DIRB.
Andean Newsletter [Lima]. August
1993. "Terrorism and Human Rights Violations," pp. 7-8.
_____. February 1993. "Amnesty
International Visit Makes Government Uncomfortable," pp. 7-8.
_____. December 1992. "The Coup and Its
Consequences," p. 7.
Human Rights Watch World Report
1994. December 1993. New York: Human Rights Watch.
Latinamerica Press [Lima]. 28
October 1993. Inés Scudellari. "Venezuelans Live with Police
Impunity."
_____. 20 February 1992. "Venezuela
under the Microscope after Coup Attempt."