Document #1323254
IRB – Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada (Author)
Ever since Somalia attained independence in
1960, virtually all of its foreign policy has centred around its
irredentist claim of a "Greater Somalia" which aims to incorporate
ethnic Somali populations in Ethiopia, Kenya and Djibouti into the
new Republic. In pursuit of its irredentism, the Somali government
had long been giving support to Somali nationalist movements in
these countries. [The historical development of the border dispute
between Somalia and Ethiopia is carefully treated in: Alan J. Day,
ed., Border and Territorial Disputes, 2nd. ed. (London:
Longman UK group, 1987), pp. 126-132. ] While the claims over parts
of Kenyan and Djibouti territories have been pursued through
diplomacy and mediation, Somalia's relations with Ethiopia
deteriorated to direct military conflict in 1964 and more recently
in 1977-1978.
According to the Somali government's
irredentist claims, the Somali-inhabited Ogaden region belonged to
the historic Somali nation, before being colonized by Ethiopia
during the colonial divisions of Africa in the late 19th century.
Ethiopia, on the other hand, takes the position that the Ogaden is
an integral part of its territory and, consequently, regards Somali
challenges as acts of aggression against its integrity. Thus, while
the people inhabiting the Ogaden are predominantly of ethnic Somali
origin and have deep-rooted social, cultural and economic ties with
Somalia, their land has legally been part of Ethiopia. [
Ibid., pp. 128-129.]
Under President Siad Barre, Somalia,
through its 1974 Treaty of Friendship and Cooperation with
the Soviet Union, was able to possess one of the largest air and
tank forces in Africa. [ Ahmed I. Samatar, Socialist Somalia:
Rhetoric and Reality (London: Zed Books Ltd., 1988), p. 128.]
Confident in its military superiority and taking advantage of the
Ethiopian political chaos of the early 1970s, the Somali regime
shifted its priority from internal construction to Somalia's
long-standing claim to the Ogaden region of Ethiopia. [
Ibid., p. 133.] In July 1977, Somali regular forces crossed
into the Ogaden to support the insurgent Western Somali Liberation
Front (WSLF), and fought a full-scale war with Ethiopia until their
defeat in November 1978.
The Somali-Ethiopian war had devastating
human and economic consequences for both countries, but the worst
tragedy has been the suffering brought to the people of the Ogaden
by the rivalry over who will control them and their land. [
"Ogaden: The Land But Not the People", Horn of Africa, Vol.
4, No. 1, 1981,
pp. 42-45. ] In addition to the refugee crisis, the long-term
repercussion of the Ogaden debacle was that it prompted a
realignment of the two superpowers in the Horn of Africa. The
Soviet Union abandoned Somalia and moved across the border to arm
the new socialist regime of Ethiopia, while the United States
adopted Somalia as its ally and gained access to military
facilities in the northern port of Berbera. [ Countries of the
World and Their Leaders Yearbook 1989 (Detroit: Gale Research
Inc., 1989), p. 1122. ]
Despite the common commitment of the
Ethiopian and Somali regimes to military socialism, Siad Barre had
reportedly found the "liberation" of the Ogaden crucial to the
legitimacy of his rule. The majority of Ogaden Somalis belong to
the Ogadeen clan, one of the three leading clans in the power
structure of the Siad Barre government. By playing a significant
role in Siad Barre's tribal coalition, the Ogadeen clan saw the
liberation of the Ogaden region as the highest goal for the Somali
government. Also, Siad Barre's mother is said to be from the
Ogadeen clan. [David D. Laitin and Said S. Samatar, Somalia:
Nation in Search of a State (Boulder: Westview Press, 1987), p.
140. ]
Siad Barre's war against Ethiopia in
1977-78 had kept the country briefly united around the long-held
dream of "Greater Somalia", which would have incorporated the
ethnic Somalis in the Ogaden. Nevertheless, Somalia's humiliating
defeat in the war and the resulting economic collapse were soon
added to the pre-war silent disenchantment with Siad Barre's
autocratic regime. Somalis shifted their priorities to domestic
politics, and open dissent and organized opposition to the
government emerged. [Samatar, pp. 137-139.]
Hostilities between Somalia and Ethiopia
continued throughout the 1980s, with Ethiopia providing substantial
support to the Somali Salvation Democratic Front (SSDF) and the
Somali National Movement (SNM) and Somalia backing the Western
Somali Liberation Front (WSLF). In 1986, the governments of Somalia
and Ethiopia took preliminary steps to discuss the resolution of
their long-standing territorial disputes. In April 1988, the two
countries reached a peace settlement and agreed to re-establish
diplomatic relations, to withdraw troops from border areas and to
exchange prisoners of war. Each side also undertook to "'refrain
from the use or threat of force against the territorial integrity
or political independence'" of the other. Because no concrete
agreement was made over the Ogaden frontiers, the border issue
remained a potential cause of conflict between the two countries. [
The Europa World Year Book 1989, (London: Europa
Publications Lt., 1989), p. 2284.]
Within a month of the Somali-Ethiopian
border agreement, SNM guerrillas crossed the Ethiopian border into
Somalia and launched a series of attacks on the northern cities of
Hargeisa, Burao, Berbera and several other small towns. The
government's brutal response to SNM attacks underlies the most
recent human rights crisis in Somalia: its artillery and aerial
shelling killed as many as 50,000 civilians, and left Hargeisa a
"ghost town"; over 400,000 people fled the war to become refugees
in Ethiopia; and some 1.5 million were internally displaced. [ U.S.
General Accounting Office, Somalia: Observations Regarding the
Northern Conflict and Resulting Conditions (Washington, 4 May
1989), pp. 4-6; Amnesty International, Somalia: The Imprisonment
of Members of the Isaaq Clan since Mid-1988 (AI Index: AFR
52/41/88, December 1988), p.2. ]
President Siad Barre's twenty years of
oppressive rule, and a political system based on family and clan
loyalties, brought Somalia into the bloody May 1988 civil conflict.
The political and economic consequences of the conflict are now
believed to lead to a full-scale civil war. [ "Voting With Their
Feet", Africa Confidential, 22 September 1989, p. 7.] In
August 1989, in a desperate last-ditch effort to hold onto power,
Siad Barre announced his government's approval of the creation of a
multi-party system by the end of 1990. Yet, at a time when large
areas of the country are outside government control, either because
of active opposition or because of a growing attitude of
indifference towards the government, Siad Barre's multi-party
promise is considered by many to be a mere device to keep the
opposition divided. [ "The End in Sight For Siad", Africa
Confidential, 8 September 1989, p. 6.] Meanwhile, while Somalia
is sliding towards chaos, family members and relatives of Siad
Barre and several other senior government officials are reported to
have left for the United States and Switzerland. [ "Voting With
Their Feet", p. 7.]
For detailed information on Somalia's
current human rights record, please find attached:
Africa Watch, Somalia: An Update on
Human Rights Developments Since Mid-July (Washington, 22
September 1989), pp. 1-16.
Amnesty International, Somalia: The
Human Rights Record After An Amnesty International Visit in
Mid-1989 (AI Index: AFR 52/02/89, January 1990), pp. 1-13.
"6,000,000 Dispossessed in the Horn of Africa", Horn Of
Africa, vol.4 No.1, London: Horn of Africa, 1981, pp.42-51.