Document #1275037
IRB – Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada (Author)
According to I.M. Lewis' 1955 map of Somali
clans (reprinted in the European Union's Study of Decentralised
Political Structures for Somalia: A Menu of Options), the Ogaden
branch of the Darod clan family is found in southern Somalia, west
of the Juba River (EU 1995, np). Some Ogadeni territory also
crosses the border between Kenya and Somalia, while other Ogadeni
subclans have traditionally occupied territory in Ethiopia (ibid.).
The following Ogadeni subclans have territory in Somalia, according
to Lewis' map: Aulihan, Mohamed Zubeir, and Makabul (ibid.).
In September 1994 Gilkes writes that the
Ogadeni controlled the hinterland north and west of Kismayo, the
main city in southern Somalia, which itself had a mixed clan
population (Sept. 1994, 84). Although Lewis' map lists the Bartire,
who are found west of the Juba River, as belonging to a different
branch of the Darod, other sources include the Bartire among the
Ogadeni clans via the Absame clan grouping (HRW/Africa Apr. 1995,
71; United Kingdom, Asylum Division, Oct. 1995, 71; Gilkes Sept.
1994, see clan chart, n.p.).
The Somali Patriotic Movement (SPM) was
formed to fight on behalf of the Ogadeni in 1989 and has continued
to represent at least some faction of Ogadeni subclans since then
(United Kingdom, Asylum Division Oct. 1995, 40; Gilkes Sept. 1994,
85). The original leader of the SPM was General Aden Abdullahi Nur
"Gebiyou" of the Aulihan subclan, but later following a schism
among the various Ogadeni subclans of the SPM, Colonel Ahmed Omar
Jess became leader of a SPM faction (ibid., 133). A Reuters report
referred to Gebiyou as chairman of the SPM in January 1996 (15 Jan.
1996).
As a military leader, Jess has continued to
skirmish with General Mohamad Hirsi "Morgan" for control of
Kismayo, since he lost control of the city in 1993 (Gilkes 1994,
84-90). In February 1996 Africa Confidential reported that Jess
remained in General Aydeed's self-appointed government even though
Jess "has mixed feelings about Aydeed and [his] own position is
shaky" (16 Feb. 1996, 4). The Indian Ocean Newsletter reported in
November 1995 that Jess had been weakened because 25 leaders in the
SPM had joined up with Aydeed's enemy in Mogadishu, Ali Mahdi
Mohamed (11 Nov. 1995, 2). Jess was accused of diverting the
group's funds for personal use by the defectors (ibid.). However,
Jess was in control of the area surrounding Kismayo, Agence France
Presse reported in January 1996 (AFP 17 Jan. 1996). Following
Aydeed's death, Africa Confidential reported that Jess remained in
Aydeed's government, although his involvement "has been
increasingly uneasy over the past year" (23 Aug. 1996, 4).
In a telephone interview on 6 September
1996, a political scientist at Davidson College in Davidson, North
Carolina, who was a political consultant for the United Nations
Operation in Somalia (UNOSOM) stated that the situation in the
Mohamed Zubeir territory was comparatively calm with little
fighting. However, the source stated that the situation in the Juba
River valley was "lawless and absolutely chaotic" (ibid.). This
source added that many Ogadeni refugees from recently closed
refugee camps in Kenya have arrived in Ogadeni territory in the
Juba River area. This influx has greatly taxed local resources
(ibid.). The refugees are largely urban people ill-prepared to live
in the rural territory in which they now find themselves (ibid.).
For additional information on this area of Somalia, please consult
Response to Information Request SOM24775.E of 9 September 1996,
which is available at Regional Documentation Centres.
For a recent history of Ogadeni clan
politics, including that of the various subclans, please consult
pages 133-36 and the chapter on Kismayo in The Price of Peace
(Gilkes, Sept. 1994). For information on the Darod-Ogaden lineage,
please consult pages 39-40, 71 and 106-10 of "Supplement to
Information Session on Country Conditions on Somalia" (DIRB Feb.
1996). Scattered references to the Ogadeni can be found in the
Human Rights Watch/Africa report, Somalia Faces the Future (Apr.
1995). These three documents are available at Regional
Documentation Centres. For additional information, please consult
the attachments.
Please note that the spelling of Somali
place names and clan names is not consistent in the literature, and
that each of the spellings used in this Response reflects the
original spelling found in the cited sources.
This Response was prepared after
researching publicly accessible information currently available to
the DIRB within time constraints. This Response is not, and does
not purport to be, conclusive as to the merit of any particular
claim to refugee status or asylum.
References
Africa Confidential [London]. 23 August
1996. Vol. 37, No. 17. "Somalia: Aydeed's Legacy."
_____. 16 February 1996. Vol. 37, No. 4.
"Somalia: Aydeed Again."
Agence France Presse (AFP). 17 January
1996. Ali Musa Abdi. "Somali Warlord Mohamed Farah Aidid
Captured..." (NEXIS)
EC Somalia Unit, European Union (EU).
August 1995. "Distribution of Somali Clans and Neighbouring
People." A Study of Decentralised Political Structures for Somalia:
A Menu of Options. London: European Union/United Nations
Development Office for Somalia.
Gilkes, P. September 1994. The Price of
Peace: Somalia and the United Nations: 1991-1994. Bedfordshire, UK:
Save the Children Fund, UK.
Human Rights Watch (HRW)/Africa. April
1995. Somalia Faces the Future. New York: Human Rights
Watch/Africa.
The Indian Ocean Newsletter [Paris]. 11
November 1995. No. 663. "Somalia: Aideed Ambitions."
Political scientist, Davidson College,
Davidson, North Carolina. 6 September 1996. Telephone
interview.
Reuters. 15 January 1996. BC Cycle.
"Reuters Africa Highlights." (NEXIS)
United Kingdom. Asylum Division of the
Home Office. October 1995. Somalia: Background Brief. (Compiled by
the DIRB. Feb. 1996. "Supplement to Information Session on Country
Conditions on Somalia.")
CSIS Africa Notes [Washington, DC]. May
1995. Ken Menkhaus and John Prendergast. "Governance and Economic
Survival in Postintervention Somalia," pp. 1, 3, 6.
United Nations. August 1996. From Relief
to Development in Somalia: Situation Report for the Period 16
July-2 August 1996. Nairobi: Office of the United Nations
Humanitarian and Resident Coordinator for Somalia, pp. 2-3,
5-6.
_____. July 1996. From Relief to
Development in Somalia: Situation Report for the Period 1-15 July
1996. Nairobi: Office of the United Nations Humanitarian and
Resident Coordinator for Somalia, pp. 2-5.
_____. June 1996. From Relief to
Development in Somalia: Situation Report for the Period 16-30 June
1996. Nairobi: Office of the United Nations Humanitarian and
Resident Coordinator for Somalia, pp. 3, 5-7.
_____. June 1996. From Relief to
Development in Somalia: Situation Report for the Period 1-15 June
1996. Nairobi: Office of the United Nations Humanitarian and
Resident Coordinator for Somalia, pp. 3, 5.
U.S. Agency for International
Development (USAID), Bureau for Humanitarian Response, Office of
U.S. Foreign Disaster Assistance (OFDA), Washington, DC. 19 August
1996. Situation Report No. 3. "Somalia - Complex Emergency," pp.
1-4.