Document #1210238
IRB – Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada (Author)
The Houston Chronicle states that although
the Movimiento El Barzon Agrupacion Civil (Barzon Movement)
originated "from a small group of farmers in northwestern Mexico in
1983, the Barzon claims 500, 000 members across Mexico" (26 Feb.
1995). The Financial Times states that El Barzon "claims more than
one million members nationwide" (18 June 1996).
Please consult the attachments for
additional information on the ideology, activities and political
affiliation of this organization. Please note that with respect to
political affiliations to specific parties, the secretary-general
of the movement hinted that the Barzon Movement may align itself
with the Zapatistas in Chiapas if "economic conditions don't
improve" (Dallas Morning News 2 Sept. 1995) and that the Barzon
Movement has politically aligned itself with the Partido de la
Revolución Democrática (PRD) on certain issues (Radio
Red Network 9 Sept.1995).
Please refer the following table for information on the states, cities and regions where members of the Barzon Movement have been recently active.
Chihuahua
Delicias and Camargo (UPI 20 June 1995)
Guanajuato
Santiago valley (La Jornada 28
Apr.1995)
Queretaro
(La Jornada 24 Aug. 1995;
La Jornada 28 Apr. 1995)
Sinaloa (La Jornada 24 Aug. 1995)
La Jornada 24 Aug. 1995)
Please note that according to La Jornada,
"El Barzon is represented in all parts of the country, except Baja
California. A meeting is to be held there next week to spread the
movement to that state" (21 Apr. 1995).
Known leaders of the Barzon Movement
include the president Juan Jose Quirino (The Guardian 18 Mar.
1996), Alfonso Ramirez Cuellar, the head of Mexico City branch (UPI
27 Dec. 1995) and secretary-general (Dallas Morning News 2 Sept.
1995), and Liliana Flores, a former congresswoman (AP 7 Nov.
1995).
This Response was prepared after
researching publicly accessible information currently available to
the DIRB within time constraints. This Response is not, and does
not purport to be, conclusive as to the merit of any particular
claim to refugee status or asylum.
References
The Associated Press (AP). 7 November
1995. PM Cycle. Susana Hayward. "Crushed by Debt, Middle Class
Debtors Angry and Fighting Back." (NEXIS)
The Arizona Republic [Phoenix]. 7 April
1995. State Edition. "Mexican Activists Vow to Shut Bridges to
U.S." (NEXIS)
Austin American-Statesman. 31 December
1995. "Mexico City Protest." (NEXIS)
The Dallas Morning News. 2 September
1995. Home Final Edition. Tracey Eaton and Alfredo Corchado.
"Zedillo Says Worst is Over for Mexico Reaction to Financial
Recovery Plan Mixed." (NEXIS)
EFE [Madrid, in Spanish]. 26 June 1995.
"El Barzon Movement Threatens to Paralyze Banking System."
(FBIS-LAT-95-124 28 June 1995, pp. 12-13)
The Financial Times [London]. 18 June
1996. Leslie Crawford and Daniel Dombey. "News: The Americas: Banks
Hold Key to Mexico's Recovery: Businesses Are Starved of Loans in
Country's 'Can't Pay, Won't Pay' Culture." (NEXIS)
_____. 19 March 1996. Leslie Crawford.
"Mexico's Banks Lick Their Wounds: Gloom Marked Bankers' Annual
Get-Together in Cancun Sun." (NEXIS)
The Guardian [London]. 18 March 1996.
Phil Gunson. "Mexican Debtors Demand Relief." (NEXIS)
The Houston Chronicle. 26 February 1995.
2 Star Edition. Dudley Althaus. "Economy Pushes Mexico's Middle
Class to Protests." (NEXIS)
La Jornada [Mexico City, in Spanish]. 24
August 1995. "El Barzon Movement Criticizes Government Measures."
(FBIS-LAT-95-166 28 Aug. 1995, pp. 14-15)
_____. 28 April 1995. Matilde Perez et
al. "El Barzon Action in Several States." (FBIS-LAT-95-091 11 May
1995, pp. 6-7)
_____. 21 April 1995. Laura Gomez Flores
et al. "New El Barzon Legal Defense Effort." (FBIS-LAT-95-083 1 May
1995, p. 16)
Radio Red Network [Mexico City, in
Spanish]. 6 December 1995. Norma Vargas. "El Barzon Movement
Demonstrates in Mexico City. (FBIS-LAT-95-234 6 Dec. 1995, pp.
15-16)
_____. 9 September 1995. Rafael Acevez.
"PRD, El Barzon, Propose Creation of Plural Committee."
(FBIS-LAT-95-175 11 Sept. 1995, p. 24)
_____. 4 August 1995. Norma Vargas. "El
Barzon Members Stage Sit-In at U.S. Embassy." (FBIS-LAT-95-151 7
Aug. 1995, pp. 16-17)
Reuters. 4 June 1996. BC Cycle. "Mexican
Stocks Thrive, Shrug Off Rate Hike Fears." (NEXIS)
_____. 5 December 1995. BC Cycle. Flor
Cordero. "Thousands of Mexican Debtors Protest in Capital."
(NEXIS)
United Press International (UPI). 27
December 1995. BC Cycle. "Mexican Debtor Group Leaders Released."
(NEXIS)
_____. 20 June 1995. BC Cycle. Mark
Stevenson. "Mexican Debtors to Step Up Protests." (NEXIS)
_____. 24 February 1995. BC Cycle. Mark
Stevenson. "Debtors' Protest Closes Mexican Banks." (NEXIS)
_____. 25 February 1994. BC Cycle. Tally
Neuman. "Mexican Farm Movement Shuts Down Regional Offices."
(NEXIS)
_____. 12 February 1994. BC Cycle. Talli
Nauman. "Farming Group Receives Support of Mexican Conflict
Mediator." (NEXIS)
The Associated Press (AP). 7 November
1995. PM Cycle. Susana Hayward. "Crushed by Debt, Middle Class
Debtors Angry and Fighting Back." (NEXIS)
The Arizona Republic [Phoenix]. 7 April
1995. State Edition. "Mexican Activists Vow to Shut Bridges to
U.S." (NEXIS)
Austin American-Statesman. 31 December
1995. "Mexico City Protest." (NEXIS)
_____. 3 December 1995. David Adams. "In
Mexico, Anger Grows as Interest Rates Soar; Citizens' Group El
Barzon Turns Growing Tide of Discontent into Political Clout."
(NEXIS)
The Dallas Morning News. 2 September
1995. Home Final Edition. Tracey Eaton and Alfredo Corchado.
"Zedillo Says Worst is Over for Mexico Reaction to Financial
Recovery Plan Mixed." (NEXIS)
EFE [Madrid, in Spanish]. 26 June 1995.
"El Barzon Movement Threatens to Paralyze Banking System."
(FBIS-LAT-95-124 28 June 1995, pp. 12-13)
The Financial Times [London]. 18 June
1996. Leslie Crawford and Daniel Dombey. "News: The Americas: Banks
Hold Key to Mexico's Recovery: Businesses Are Starved of Loans in
Country's 'Can't Pay, Won't Pay' Culture." (NEXIS)
_____. 19 March 1996. Leslie Crawford.
"Mexico's Banks Lick Their Wounds: Gloom Marked Bankers' Annual
Get-Together in Cancun Sun." (NEXIS)
The Guardian [London]. 18 March 1996.
Phil Gunson. "Mexican Debtors Demand Relief." (NEXIS)
The Houston Chronicle. 26 February 1995.
2 Star Edition. Dudley Althaus. "Economy Pushes Mexico's Middle
Class to Protests." (NEXIS)
La Jornada [Mexico City, in Spanish]. 24
August 1995. "El Barzon Movement Criticizes Government Measures."
(FBIS-LAT-95-166 28 Aug. 1995, pp. 14-15)
_____. 25 April 1995. Matilde Perez et
al. "El Barzon Actions in Several States." (FBIS-LAT-95-091 11 May
1995, pp. 6-7)
_____. 21 April 1995. Laura Gomez Flores
et al. "New El Barzon Legal Defense Effort." (FBIS-LAT-95-083 1 May
1995, p. 16)
Mexico Service (IACSM). 11 March 1994.
"Banks Renegotiate Farm Debt." (IAC Newsletter Database/NEXIS)
Radio Red Network [Mexico City, in
Spanish]. 6 December 1995. Norma Vargas. "El Barzon Movement
Demonstrates in Mexico City. (FBIS-LAT-95-234 6 Dec.1995, pp.
15-16)
_____. 17 November 1995. Antonio Guzman.
"Authorities, Bankers, El Barzon to Negotiate on 3 Dec."
(FBIS-LAT-95-223 20 Nov. 1995, pp. 27-28)
_____. 9 September 1995. Rafael Acevez.
"PRD, El Barzon, Propose Creation of Plural Committee."
(FBIS-LAT-95-175 11 Sept. 1995, p. 24)
_____. 25 August 1995. Gustavo Diaz. "El
Barzon Leaders Willing to Negotiate on Debtors Proposal."
(FBIS-LAT-95-167 29 Aug. 1995, pp. 15-16 )
_____. 4 August 1995. Norma Vargas. "El
Barzon Members Stage Sit-In at U.S. Embassy." (FBIS-LAT-95-151 7
Aug. 1995, pp. 16-17)
Reforma [Mexico City, in Spanish]. 29
December 1995. Daniela Pastrana. "Judge Releases Detained El Barzon
Movement Leaders." (FBIS-LAT-96-003 4 Jan. 1996, p. 7)
_____. 20 April 1995. Julieta Medina.
"El Barzon Decision to Use 'Commandos'." (FBIS-LAT-95-083 1 May
1995, pp. 15-16)
Reuters. 4 June 1996. BC Cycle. "Mexican
Stocks Thrive, Shrug Off Rate Hike Fears." (NEXIS)
_____. 5 December 1995. BC Cycle. Flor
Cordero. "Thousands of Mexican Debtors Protest in Capital."
(NEXIS)
Rocky Mountain News [Denver]. 15 April
1996. Julia Preston. "Mexican Economy Creates Fiscal Rebels
Variable Interest Rates on Loans Shake Faith in Banking System."
(NEXIS)
United Press International (UPI). 27
December 1995. BC Cycle. "Mexican Debtor Group Leaders Released."
(NEXIS)
_____. 20 June 1995. BC Cycle. Mark
Stevenson. "Mexican Debtors to Step Up Protests." (NEXIS)
_____. 7 April 1995. BC Cycle. Tim
Vandenack. "Mexicans Protest Against Interest Rates." (NEXIS)
_____. 24 February 1995. BC Cycle. Mark
Stevenson. "Debtors' Protest Closes Mexican Banks." (NEXIS)
_____. 25 February 1994. BC Cycle. Tally
Neuman. "Mexican Farm Movement Shuts Down Regional Offices."
(NEXIS)
_____. 12 February 1994. BC Cycle. Talli
Nauman. "Farming Group Receives Support of Mexican Conflict
Mediator." (NEXIS)
XEW Television Network [Mexico City, in
Spanish]. 27 December 1995. "Authorities Arrest Two Leaders of El
Barzon Movement." (FBIS-LAT-96-002 3 Jan. 1996, p. 23)
_____. 6 July 1995. "Secretariat Reaches
4 Accords With El Barzon." (FBIS-LAT-95-132 11 July 1995, p.
14)