Document #1208211
IRB – Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada (Author)
Amnesty International's Religious
Repression in China report and Human Rights Watch's China:
Religious Persecution Persists report state that since the
1950s, China's five official religions have been monitored by
state-controlled "patriotic organizations," which also assist in
implementing government policy (July 1996, 8; Dec. 1995, 6). For
Catholicism, the state-recognized organizations are the Catholic
Patriotic Association (CPA) and the Bishop's Conference, and for
Protestanism, the Three-Self Patriotic Movement (TSPM) and the
Chinese Christian Council (CCC) are the authorized organizations
(ibid.).
According to Human Rights Watch, the
Three-Self Patriotic Movement insists that Protestant denominations
renounce any link to foreign missionary organizations and that,
collectively, they form a "post-denominational Christian church"
(Dec. 1995, 7). Please consult Amnesty International's
Religious Repression in China report and Human Rights
Watch's China: Religious Persecution Persists report, both
available at all Regional Documentation Centres, as well Response
to Information Request CHN8824.E of 11 June 1991, for additional
information on Chinese Patriotic Churches.
Several sources state that official Chinese
Catholic Patriotic Churches are not permitted to recognize the
authority of the Pope (AFP 22 Jan. 1998; AI July 1996, 9; HRW Dec.
1995, 7; The Washington Post 25 Jan. 1998). In China, the
Chinese Catholic Patriotic Church has 4 million members, while the
numbers for the clandestine Catholic Church, openly loyal to the
Vatican and also called the "silent church," hover around 3 million
members (AFP 22 Jan. 1998). According to the same AFP report, the
Chinese Patriotic Catholic Association elected the bishop of
Beijing, Monsignor Fu Tieshan as president of the association
(ibid.).
In a 28 October 1997 testimony before the
United States House of Representatives Committee of International
Relations, Nina Shea, Director of the Center for Religious Freedom
at Freedom House stated that "there are priests and bishops in the
Patriotic Catholic Church who are also recognized by the Vatican,
and some of the official Protestant churches cooperate with
underground Christians...But independent churches they are not"
(Federal Document Clearing House Congressional
Testimony).
The latter source adds that Patriotic
churches are prohibited to work with people under the age of 18,
that their clergy must preach within set geographical boundaries,
and that their church venues must be approved by the government
(ibid.).
In reference to baptism, a 22 May 1996 AP
report specifies that the sacrament of baptism is limited to people
over the age of 18. The same report states that a World Council of
Churches delegation to China estimated that the number of baptized
Christians was approximately 10 million. In its White Paper on
Religious Freedom, the Chinese government states that baptism is
among the religious practices protected by law (Xinhua 18 Oct.
1997). A 14 December 1997 AFP report and an April 1995 Beijing
Review report also state that the Chinese Catholic Patriotic
Churches conduct baptisms. The Beijing Review report adds
that some 50,000 to 60,000 people have been baptized annually by
Catholic Patriotic Churches in China (Apr. 1995).
This Response was prepared after
researching publicly accessible information currently available to
the Research Directorate within time constraints. This Response is
not, and does not purport to be, conclusive as to the merit of any
particular claim to refugee status or asylum.
References
Agence France Presse (AFP). 22 January
1998. "Bishop of Beijing Elected President of China's Catholics."
(NEXIS)
_____. [Hong Kong, in English]. 14
December 1997. "China's Catholic Church Looks to Pope."
(FBIS-CHI-97-347/WNC) [Accessed 17 Feb. 1998]
Amnesty International. July 1996.
Religious Repression in China. (AI Index: ASA 17/69/96).
London: Amnesty International.
Associated Press (AP). 22 May 1996.
"Christianity Is Growing in China 'at Breathtaking Speed,' the
World Council of Churches Said Wednesday." (NEXIS)
Beijing Review [in English].
17-23 April 1995. "Bishop on Catholicism's Acceptance Viewed."
(FBIS-CHI-95-078/WNC) [Accessed 17 Feb. 1998]
Federal Document Clearing House
Congressional Testimony [Washington]. 28 October 1997.
"Testimony October 28, 1997 Nina Shea Director, Center for
Religious Freedom House International Relations International
Operations and Human Rights in China." (NEXIS)
Human Rights Watch (HRW)/Asia. December
1995. China: Religious Persecution Persists. New York:
Human Rights Watch.
Xinhua. 16 October 1997. "China Issues
White Paper on Religious Freedom." (BBC Summary 18 Oct.
1997/NEXIS)