Document #1153811
IRB – Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada (Author)
According to a professor of political
science at the University of Michigan in Ann Arbor, mixed
Jewish/non-Jewish couples are treated no differently under the law
than Jewish couples (26 Oct. 1994.). By law, neither the Israeli
authorities nor the general population may treat a non-Jew
differently than a Jew. The professor stated that any
discrimination against a non-Jew or mixed Jewish/non-Jewish couple
would only be found at the private and individual level
(ibid.).
In a letter faxed to the Canadian
Department of Citizenship and Immigration and forwarded to the
DIRB, the director of the Jerusalem branch of the Association for
Americans and Canadians in Israel, who works closely with the
Russian immigrant communities, stated that some Israelis do have
negative attitudes towards Soviet émigrés. These
attitudes are a product of a number of factors, including
"resentment towards [the] high cost of absorbing immigrants, [and]
abuse of [the] system by some immigrants (26 Sept. 1994, 5). The
director also stated that
approximately 30 per cent of immigrants arriving fall into this
category [of mixed Jewish/non-Jewish marriages]. She admitted that
they may face some discrimination but pointed out that
discrimination could be found towards different groups of Jews as
well, such as the Ethiopian and Yemenite Jews (ibid.).
These sources indicate that couples are not deliberately
discriminated against as a result of an interreligious marriage
(ibid.; Professor of political science 26 Oct. 1994).
Please refer to the following Responses to
Information Requests, available at your Regional Documentation
Centre, for information on the treatment of couples in which the
husband is Jewish and the wife is not: ISR17873.E of 11 July 1994,
ISR17046.E of 14 April 1994, ISR15710.E of 17 November 1993 and
ISR14267.E of 3 August 1993. For information on couples in which
the woman is Jewish and the husband is a Palestinian Muslim, please
refer to Response to Information Request ISR14334 of 16 June 1993,
and the attachments from The Associated Press, St.
Petersburg Times and The Jerusalem Report of 30 June
1994. Response to Information Request ISR15397.E of 29 September
1993 examines the situation of a couple in which the wife is Jewish
and the husband Christian.
With the influx of Soviet
émigrés, mixed Jewish/non-Jewish couples now include
Jews who are not considered Jewish by the Rabbinical authorities
(The Jerusalem Report 24 Feb. 1994, 15-16). The difference
in the definition of Jewishness between the Law of Return and that
of halakhah, Jewish religious law, has led to discrepancies
in the treatment of Soviet émigrés to Israel (ibid.).
For information on this subject, please consult the 24 February
1994 attachment from The Jerusalem Report. Under the Law of
Return, having one Jewish grandparent is sufficient to be
considered Jewish, however under halakhah, a Jew is either
the child of a Jewish woman or is a convert (ibid.; Professor of
political science 26 Oct. 1994). Although Israel's Law of Return
grants citizenship to the non-Jewish spouses of Jews immigrating to
Israel, it is the ultra-orthodox Jews, the Rabbinical authorities,
who determine who is a Jew (The Washington Times 7 July
1993). According to The Jerusalem Report, unless the
Rabbinical authorities recognize one's Jewishness, one is unable to
marry a Jew, get divorced, adopt a child, or be buried as a Jew (24
Feb. 1994, 14-15). The source stated that according to experts,
almost one third of the 500,000 Soviet émigrés who
have come to Israel since 1990 are not considered Jewish under
halakhah religious law (ibid., 14).
For information on converting to Judaism,
please consult the 20 May and 19 February 1993 attachments from
The Jerusalem Report.
This response was prepared after
researching publicly accessible information currently available to
the DIRB within time constraints. This response is not, and does
not purport to be, conclusive as to the merit of any particular
claim to refugee status or asylum.
Citizenship and Immigration Canada
International Service, Ottawa. 3 October 1994. Fax received by the
DIRB.
. 24 February 1994. Tom Sawicki. "The
Wedding Banned." (DIRB "Israel" country file).
Professor of political science,
University of Michigan, Ann Arbor. 26 October 1994. Telephone
interview.
The Washington Times. 7 July
1993. Final Edition. "Rabbi Refuses to Pray over Slain Immigrant."
(NEXIS)
The Associated Press (AP). 26 April
1994. AM Cycle. Karin Laub. "Arab Husband Shuns Funeral Where
Jewish Family Curses Wife." (NEXIS)
Citizenship and Immigration Canada
International Service, Ottawa. 3 October 1994. Fax received by the
DIRB.
Groffier, Ethel. 1987. Mariages et
régimes matrimoniaux étrangers. Montréal:
Sorej Inc., p. 78.
The Jerusalem Post. 19 February
1993. Haim Shapiro. "Reform Conversion Again Before the Courts."
(DIRB country file)
The Jerusalem Report [Jerusalem].
30 June 1994. Isabel Kershner. "Love & Death in Kiryat Ata,"
pp. 20-21.
. 28 July 1994. "Consulate Marriages."
(DIRB Indexed Media Review [Ottawa], 26 July 1994-Aug. 1994,
Vol. 8, No. 4)
. 24 February 1994. Tom Sawicki. "The
Wedding Banned." (DIRB country file)
. 20 May 1993. Yossi Klein Halevi. "The
Hard Road to Judaism," pp. 10-12.
St. Petersburg Times. 10 March
1994. City Edition. Nancie L. Katz. "Lovers: 'We Didn't Think,
Arab, Jew'." (NEXIS)
The Washington Times. 7 July
1993. Final Edition. "Rabbi Refuses to Pray over Slain Immigrant."
(NEXIS)
Contemporary Religions: A World
Guide. 1992.
Country Reports on Human Rights
Practices. Annually. 1994.
DIRB "Israel" country file.
1993-1994.
Documentation, Information and Research
Branch (DIRB), Immigration and Refugee Board, Ottawa. February
1993. Israel: Jews from the Former Soviet Union.
Freedom in the World: The Annual
Survey of Political Rights & Civil Liberties. Annually.
1993.
International Migration [Geneva].
Quarterly. 1992-present.
International Migration Review
[New York]. Quarterly. 1992-present.
JDC-Brookdale Institute. 1994.
Immigrant Absorption in Israel.
Religion in Politics. 1989.
Revue Europeenne des migrations
internationales [Paris]. 1989-present.
Situation of Former Soviet Citizens
in Israel. January 1993. Toronto: Transcontinental Consulting
Company, Ltd. (unofficial translation of collection of
documents)
On-line search of media sources.