Document #1120685
IRB – Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada (Author)
1) Somalia is basically a patriarchal
society, and marriage is seen as a political and economic contract
between clan representatives. According to modern ethnographers,
all Somalis are divided into six major confederation of kinship
groups called clan-families. Although every Somali belongs to one
of the six clan-families, because these groupings are too large and
too dispersed to be effective units of political and social action,
Somalis identify more immediately with the clans into which each
clan-family is sub-divided. Clans are typically the largest
exogamous units in Somali society: marriage outside the clan is
encouraged because it helps to widen the circle of potential allies
that could be called upon in time of need. [Lee V. Cassanelli,
The Shaping of Somali Society (Philadelphia: University of
Pennsylvania Press, 1982), pp. 17-19.]
Notwithstanding the patriarchal nature of
Somali society, some analysts often make reference to a "special
son-to-mother bond" of Somali culture that defies the laws of
patriarchy. [David D. Laitin and Said S. Samatar, Somalia:
Nation in Search of a State (Boulder: Westview Press, 1987), p.
31.] Furthermore, it can well be said that a person born of, for
example, a Darood father and an Isaaq mother and brought up within
an Isaaq community may be more attached to and identified with the
Isaaq clan.
2) Since it assumed power in 1969, the
current Somali regime has effectively used clan politics in order
to maintain its hold on to power, by placing members of the
presidential Mareehan clan in all key positions in the civil
service, armed forces, security services, and state agencies. [
Laitin and Samatar, pp. 92-94.] Human Rights Watch and the Lawyers
Committee for Human Rights, American private non-governmental
organizations which promote international human rights and refugee
law, observe that "the monopoly that the relatives and clan members
of the President have had over education, health, employment and
business opportunities has bred deep-rooted grievances and has had
an important political effect in alienating other clans". [ Human
Rights Watch and Lawyers Committee for Human Rights, Critique:
Review of the Department of State's Country Reports on Human Rights
Practices (New York, July 1989), p. 156.]
Since the emergence of the opposition
Somali National Movement (SNM) in 1982, members of the Isaaq clan
have been particular targets of political persecution as well as
systematic economic and educational discrimination, due to their
alleged support for the SNM. [ U.S. General Accounting Office,
Somalia: Observations Regarding the Northern Conflict and
Resulting Conditions (Washington, May 1989), p. 2.] Although
IRBDC has no corroborative documentation, many prominent members of
the Somali community in Canada charge that in 1985 President Siad
Barre issued unpublished directives to systematically prohibit
members of the Isaaq clan from attending universities with the view
of "dealing strongly with people associated with the SNM".
3) The Darood clan-family is a vast
confederation of kinship groups which is composed of five major
component clans: the Mareehan, Majerteen, Ogadeen, Dulbahante, and
Warsangali. Because the Darood does not constitute a coherent
confederation, political issues related to this clan-family must be
analyzed in terms of its component clans.
During the early years of President Siad
Barre's rule, the Mareehan clan to which the President belongs had
formed a political alliance with the Ogadeen and the Dulbahante
clans, establishing a constellation code-named MOD. The MOD was
said to have provided the President with a reliable power base that
offered external as well as internal security. [ Laitin and
Samatar, pp. 92-94.] The Majerteen, which was considered one of the
three dominant clans in the pre-1969 civilian governments (with the
Isaaq and Hawiye), was not pre-eminent in the Siad Barre regime. As
a result, some Majerteen officers formed a clandestine opposition
movement, the Somali Salvation Front (SSF) in 1979 which later
became to be known as the Somali Salvation Democratic Front (SSDF).
I.M. Lewis, a distinguished scholar of Somali society, pointed out
that because "the SSDF reflected the hubris of the Majerteen whose
political ascendance had been eclipsed by Siad Barre's Mareehan
power", Somali armed forces and the civil service were purged of
Majerteens. [ I.M. Lewis, A Modern History of Somalia: Nation
and State in the Horn of Africa (Boulder: Westview Press,
1988), p. 252.]
Since the end of 1970s, the MOD alliance
that had helped to keep the Mareehan in power for so long has been
disintegrating into the traditional clan rivalries. President Siad
Barre has been making all the efforts to perpetuate the positions
and power of his Mareehan clan at the expense of all other clans.
Until a few years ago members of the Ogadeen clan dominated
Somalia's armed forces, but since mid-1984 the President has
instituted a policy of reducing the number and influence of senior
Ogadeni officers. In February 1986 alone, over 50 Ogadeni officers
up to the rank of major were reported dismissed from the Somali
army. [ "Somalia: Towards an Ogaden Pact", Africa
Confidential, 26 February 1986, pp. 6-7.] With the dismissal
and subsequent detention of the Minister of Defence, an Ogadeni, in
June 1989, most Ogadeni officers deserted the armed forces and
formed an armed opposition movement, the Somali Patriotic
Front.