Document #1126811
IRB – Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada (Author)
According to the Iran Desk officer at
Lawyers Committee For Human Rights in New York, people who failed
the reservist calls, including those who had performed their
military service under the Shah, during the Iran-Iraq War
(1980-1988) would not be at risk today in Iran (30 July 1999).
A contributor to the Jane's
Intelligence Review and a specialist on Iran's military,
stated that under the Shah educated people were assigned to
alternative military service, such as medical students performing
military training in military hospitals (27 July 1999). Military
service under the Shah was compulsory and lasted 18 months.
Military personnel who were recalled during the Iran-Iraq War were
mainly air force pilots and members of the navy, areas still
unfamiliar to the Pasdaran at the time. Those officers were
required to sign a declaration where they pledged to remain quiet.
People who would have failed to report to the call for reservists
during the Iran-Iraq War would have a file on them. The only
penalty upon their return to Iran today would be a fine.
The Director of the Foundation for Iranian
Studies in Bethesda added that person who have been residing abroad
and who failed to report to the call for reservists during the
Iran-Iraq War have been able to normalize their situation with the
authorities and return to Iran safely (30 July 1999).
It might be of interest to note that in
1988, acting as Commander-in-Chief of the Army, President Akbar
Hashemi-Rafsanjani stated that "soldiers who have completed their
two-year military service will no longer have to stay on another
four months as reservists" (IRNA 29 Dec. 1988). The Associated
Press (AP) indicated that "Iran will abolish reserve military
service by the end of the Persian year in March and will cut the
draft from 28 months to 24 starting next month" (29 Dec. 1988).
This Response was prepared after
researching publicly accessible information currently available to
the Research Directorate within time constraints. This Response is
not, and does not purport to be, conclusive as to the merit of any
particular claim to refugee status or asylum.
References
The Associated Press (AP). 29 December
1988. "Iran Abolishes Reserve Military Service." (NEXIS)
Director, Foundation for Iranian
Studies, Bethesda, Maryland. 30 July 1999. Telephone interview.
Iran Desk officer, Lawyers Committee for
Human Rights, New York. 30 July 1999. Telephone interview.
IRNA [Tehran, in English]. 29 December
1988. "Iran Decision to Abolish Reserve Military Service Announced"
(BBC Summary 31 Dec. 1988/NEXIS).
Specialist on Iranian military affairs
and contributor to the Jane's Intelligence Review, London,
UK. 27 July 1999. Telephone interview.
Additional Sources Consulted
Country File: Iran.
Iran: A Country Study. 1990.
Edited by Helen Metz. Washington, DC: Secretary of the Army.
Jane's Defence Review.
1990-1999.
Jane's Intelligence Review.
1997-1999
United Nations, Economic and Social
Council, Commission on Human Rights. 16 January 1997.
E/CN.4/1997/99. The Question of Conscientious Objectors to
Military Service.