Dokument #1122246
IRB – Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada (Autor)
According to an Israeli lawyer specializing
in human rights issues, the Teudat Zhut identity card provides
information on the holder's nationality and citizenship (9 June
1993a). If the holder is an Israeli citizen of Palestinian origin,
the Teudat Zhut card would indicate the citizenship as Israeli and
the nationality as Arab (or "Arabi" in Hebrew) (Ibid.). The
same lawyer added that the Teudat Zhut document is not in itself an
indication of citizenship (Ibid.). For example, in the case
of Palestinians living in East Jerusalem, which territory was
annexed by the Israeli government in 1967 and has been administered
since as an integral part of Israel, the Teudat Zhut card indicates
only that the Palestinian holder is a resident, not that he is an
Israeli citizen (Ibid.). The passport is still the strongest
evidence of citizenship (Ibid.). For example, the lawyer
reported that Israeli authorities use these identity documents at
the airport when Israeli citizens or residents are returning from
abroad (Ibid.). According to the lawyer, who could only
provide information on the treatment of Palestinians, Arab citizens
or residents of East Jerusalem returning from abroad can be
distinguished from Jewish Israeli citizens by the special travel
documents they carry. Unlike Jewish Israeli citizens, Palestinians
returning from abroad can be submitted to intensive searches
(Ibid.).
A representative of the Association of
Civil Rights in Israel (ACRI) mentioned that in Israel there is a
difference between citizenship and nationality (9 June 1993). The
representative added that the Teudat Zhut card carried by
Christians from the former Soviet Union would indicate Israeli
citizenship and Russian nationality, while a Jew from the former
Soviet Union would have Israeli citizenship and Jewish nationality
indicated on his card (Ibid.). The same representative added
that there is no Israeli nationality, only Israeli citizenship
(Ibid.). The representative further indicated that although
the nationality information can be removed from the Teudat Zhut
card, it will remain in the file at the Ministry of the Interior
(Ibid.). The Teudat Zhut card is also provided to temporary
or permanent residents of Israel, but the information on
citizenship shown on this document will not be as precise as that
found on an official passport (Ibid.). Information on the
religion of the holder is not indicated either on the Teudat Zhut
or the official passport (Ibid.). These two documents can be
used for a variety of purposes in Israel (Ibid.). According
to another Israeli lawyer specializing in human rights issues, a
Teudat Zhut card held by a Palestinian living in Israel (not in
East Jerusalem) would indicate that the holder was an Israeli
citizen bearing Arab nationality (9 June 1993b). The lawyer added
that the Teudat Zhut card carried by a Jew from either Israel or
the former Soviet Union would indicate that the card holder was an
Israeli citizen bearing Jewish nationality (Ibid.). The same
principle would apply to a Christian from the former Soviet Union;
the Teudat Zhut would indicate that he was an Israeli citizen
bearing Russian nationality (Ibid.). An Israeli passport
only indicates citizenship (Ibid.). The passport also
contains the holder's identification number, which enables the
Israeli authorities to access information on the person
(Ibid.).
Association of Civil Rights in Israel
(ACRI), Jerusalem. 9 June 1993. Telephone Interview with a
Representative.
Israeli lawyer specializing in human
rights issues, Jerusalem. 9 June 1993a. Telephone Interview.
Israeli Lawyer specializing in human
rights issues, Jerusalem. 9 June 1993b. Telephone Interview.