Dokument #1025810
IRB – Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada (Autor)
Ayatollah Mohammad Kazem Shariatmadari
taught at Qom, the religious centre of learning for Shi'ism. He was
an Azarbaijani who had the reputation of "being the most liberal
and forwardlooking of the [seven] clerics" (including Ayatollah
Khomeini) competing for ascendancy following the death of Ayatollah
Borujerdi. [ Ervand Abrahamian, Radical Islam: The Iranian
Mojahedin, (London: I.B. Tauris & Co. Ltd., 1989), p.
20.]
The differences between Shariatmadari and
Khomeini appear to arise principally from Shariatmadari's views
concerning the role of the Shi'ite clergy: he believed that the
country should be run by an elected government which adhered to the
constitution, whereas Khomeini firmly believed that Islam contained
prescriptions for political conduct and could be used to run the
affairs of an Islamic nation. In the words of one author (Dilip
Hiro), Shariatmadari believed in "non-intervention by the ulema in
the day-to-day administration of society; and Khomeini represented
the interventionist school". [ Dilip Hiro, Iran Under the
Ayatollahs, (London: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1987), p.
358.] Another author, Ervand Abrahamian, asserts that
Shariatmadari's followers (clerical liberals), "like previous
generations of Shii clerics, argued that the rightful role of the
ulama was to teach, preach, guide the community, protect the
shari'a, all the time keeping a safe distance from the inherently
corrupting state, and only in dire necessity intervening directly
in politics." [ Ervand Abrahamian, Radical Islam: The Iranian
Mojahedin, (London: I.B. Tauris & Co. Ltd., 1989), p.
45.]
For the principal differences between
Khomeini and Shariatmadari's followers, please refer to the section
entitled "Clerical populists" and "Clerical liberals" respectively
(Abrahamian, pp. 42-45). Shariatmadari allegedly backed Premier
Bakhtiar following the demise of the Shah. [ Hiro, p. 87.] By the
end of 1979, the clerical populists of Khomeini held much more
power than Shariatmadari's liberals, and when documents seized from
the U.S. Embassy were used to discredit Shariatmadari (for contact
with the Embassy), he was placed under house detention, his Islamic
People's Republican Party was dissolved, and 12 of his supporters
were executed. [ Abrahamian, pp. 57-8.] In April 1982,
Shariatmadari was further discredited by the Militant Students (who
had occupied the U.S. Embassy), and he was stripped of his
religious credentials by the elders of the Faizaya seminary in Qom.
[ Hiro, p. 219.] Iranian television reported contacts between
Shariatmadari and the CIA. [ Ibid.] Shariatmadari died in 1985.
For further information on the differences between Shariatmadari
and Khomeini, please refer to Hiro, pp. 139-143.
Attachments:
-
Ervand Abrahamian, Radical Islam: The
Iranian Mojahedin, London: I.B. Tauris & Co. Ltd., 1989
-
Dilip Hiro, Iran Under the
Ayatollahs, London: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1987